TLDR
Inventive, high-concept ice cream flavors and indulgent frozen treats. A polarizing local favorite known for bold, signature recipe experiments.
Reddit Sentiment for AMPLE HILLS CREAMERY(based on 28 Reddit opinions)
Details
Renowned for creative, elaborate ice cream flavors, this spot has long been a destination for frozen treat enthusiasts in NYC [1]. While many fans praise standout offerings like their unique seasonal flavors, some diners have noted a perceived decline in quality and consistency in recent years [2]. Despite debates over texture and business management, many visitors still prefer these scoops to other major local chains [3].
Food Overview
The menu features elaborate ice cream flavors and limited-time seasonal releases [2]. While some enjoy the distinct, sometimes chewy mouthfeel caused by stabilizers [2], critics often point to an overly sweet profile or a waxy texture as detractions [2]. Notable mentions include the spicy mango sorbet [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About AMPLE HILLS CREAMERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Recommendation For Corn Ice Cream In Manhattan Or
"Notes they are bringing back their 'Corn To Run' flavor for a limited weekend run."
NeutralFrom post: Favorite Places To Buy Ice Cream Pints In
"The commenter lists this as a recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Where Do I Find Mexican Ice Cream Like This In
"While not authentic, the user notes they serve a spicy mango sorbet with Tajin that evokes Mexican desserts."
PositiveFrom post: The Ample Hills Couple Is Back Again
"The commenter felt that the quality of Ample Hills ice cream had declined in the last three years, with some pints being icy."
NegativeFrom post: The Ample Hills Couple Is Back Again
"The commenter mentioned that Ample Hills ice cream uses too much stabilizer, resulting in a texture they disliked."
Negative