Viral Pesto Pepperoni Pizza w/ imported Italian ingredients & crispy crust. A buzzed-about East Village spot.
This East Village pizzeria has quickly become a buzzed-about spot, particularly known for its viral Pesto Pepperoni Pizza. They pride themselves on using imported Italian ingredients, resulting in a distinctively crispy crust. While some debate the authenticity of its rapid rise in reviews, many agree the pizza is a solid choice for the neighborhood.
Specializing in Italian-American pizza, this spot is particularly famous for its Pesto Pepperoni Pizza, which has gained viral traction. Customers also recommend the Mushroom Pizza and Double Side Sicilian Pizza, often noting the desirable crispy bottom. However, there's a persistent discussion regarding the legitimacy of its numerous high ratings.
"The viral Pesto Pepperoni Pizza is a must-try, with the Mushroom Pizza and Double Side Sicilian Pizza also suggested."
Customer sentiment is mixed, with some praising the quality and unique viral dishes, while others express skepticism about the authenticity of its high ratings and popularity.
Important Note
There are significant discussions and suspicions among online commenters regarding the authenticity of the restaurant's high ratings and reviews.
"Nuovo York is considered okay, but certainly not among the top 20 pizza places as suggested by a particular list."
Neutral"The post author is organizing a pizza tour across Manhattan and lists Nuovo York Pizza as one of the pizzerias to visit."
Neutral"A commenter suggested Nuovo York Pizza as a good pizza choice in the East Village for someone with a simple palate."
Positive"Commenter saw Nuovo York Pizza on Instagram and checked Google reviews; despite good reviews, something felt off, especially after seeing posts alleging paid reviews. They decided not to try it due to distrust."
Negative"Commenter acknowledges the owner uses paid advertising, potentially including unmarked influencer posts and a TimeOut article. They state the pizza is decent, a good choice in the East Village, but not exceptional."
Neutral"Commenter ordered the vodka pizza from Nuovo York Pizza a few weeks prior and personally found it to be very good."
Positive"While acknowledging some legitimate reviews might exist, the commenter believes the high 4.9 rating and frequency of 5-star reviews for Nuovo York Pizza are suspicious red flags."
Negative"Explains that Nuovo York Pizza's 4.9 rating is unusually high and suspicious compared to the average and even highly-regarded places like L'Industrie (4.7) and Best Pizza (4.5)."
Negative"The commenter questions why Nuovo York Pizza specifically stood out to the original poster, suggesting that fake reviews are a common occurrence."
Neutral"A commenter identifying as a Google Local Guide reviewed the newest reviews and found many legitimate-seeming ones, disagreeing with the claim of obvious fakes. They live nearby and may try a slice to report back."
Neutral"Mentions Cello's as a better alternative near Nuovo York Pizza, implying Nuovo York Pizza is not recommended."
Negative"After looking at pictures and reviews, the commenter couldn't find obvious evidence of fake reviews, noting the pizza looks appealing (except the crust) and many reviewers are tourists."
Neutral"The commenter described a weird experience after posting a negative Google review for Nuovo York Pizza, alleging the owner found their unlinked Instagram and liked many posts."
Negative
