A 1950s-inspired NOLA gem with amazing charbroiled oysters & standout seafood; try the 'seafood and three' for a guaranteed banger.
Drawing inspiration from New Orleans with a distinct 1950s aesthetic, this Fort Greene establishment offers a unique culinary journey. It's celebrated for its exceptional seafood, with charbroiled oysters and the 'seafood and three' option being particular highlights. While the po'boys have garnered some debate regarding their milk bread base, the restaurant's commitment to quality and memorable flavors shines through, making it a standout dining destination.
The restaurant is highly praised for its New Orleans-inspired seafood, particularly its charbroiled oysters, which are described as a must-try. The 'seafood and three' option is also a standout. While some dishes like the po'boys on milk bread receive mixed reviews (some find them delicious, others note the bread gets soggy), the overall consensus points to exceptional seafood and a memorable culinary experience. Desserts and pastries are also noted as a positive aspect.
"Highly recommended are the charbroiled oysters, the 'seafood and three' option which is called a 'fuckin banger,' and the BBQ shrimp. The smoked fish dip is also noted as memorable, and the hush puppies with smoked trout roe are highlighted."
Customers have a very positive overall sentiment, frequently recommending the restaurant for its unique New Orleans-inspired cuisine and lively atmosphere. Specific praise is given to their oyster preparations and seafood dishes.
Important Note
While the charbroiled oysters and other seafood dishes are highly praised, the po'boys have received mixed reviews, with some finding the milk bread base to be a less authentic or desirable element that can become soggy.
"The commenter initially listed Strange Delight as a favorite but later edited to clarify it is not located in Manhattan, which is the preferred borough for the user."
Neutral"This user recommended Strange Delight if the original poster misses New Orleans, but advised skipping poboys."
Positive"This user stated that Strange Delight's sandwich is delicious but not a po'boy, noting it's made with milk bread which they found gets soggy."
Neutral"The user recalled Strange Delight having good meals and was interested to see if their lunch menu, which they had forgotten about, offered a po'boy."
Positive"This user recommended Strange Delight for lunch, suggesting it as an option for those missing New Orleans."
Positive"Strange Delight is mentioned as a potential option."
Positive"This user loves Strange Delight, stating that 'literally every single dish' they had was delicious with no notes."
Positive"Strange Delight is recommended as a casual seafood option."
Positive"Strange Delight is suggested for its seafood and New Orleans style, with a relaxed atmosphere, making it a good birthday choice."
Positive"The user inquired if Oyster Mornay was a seasonal item or a regular menu item at Strange Delight, as their current menu only lists Oysters Rockefeller."
Neutral"This restaurant was suggested in response to the original post. The user later confirmed that while it serves Oysters Rockefeller, it does not have Oyster Mornay on the menu."
Neutral"Strange Delight was mentioned as a good restaurant option that isn't specifically for steak."
Positive"Recommended the BBQ Shrimp at Strange Delight."
Positive"Mentioned that the charbroiled oysters at Strange Delight are good, but the po'boys are lacking."
Neutral"Strange Delight is suggested as a place that serves hush puppies with smoked trout roe, implying a positive recommendation for the dish."
Positive"Strange Delight is noted to offer BBQ shrimp."
Neutral"The commenter highly recommends Strange Delight, specifically praising its "seafood and three" option as a "fuckin banger.""
Positive"In response to a request for more recommendations at Strange Delight, the user highlights the memorable smoked fish dip. They also mention the popular shrimp loaf sandwich, though they haven't tried it themselves."
Positive"The user enjoyed the charbroiled oysters at Strange Delight and had a fantastic overall experience. They also found the swordfish to be exceptional and noted a fun, energetic vibe at the counter."
Positive"The user, actively searching for authentic New Orleans-style charbroiled oysters in NYC, mentions not having tried Strange Delight yet."
Neutral
