NOLA-inspired 1950s vibe w/ amazing oysters & elevated po-boys. Don't miss the $25 lunch deal!
Strange Delight in Fort Greene brings a vibrant 1950s aesthetic with a New Orleans-inspired menu. They offer a variety of oyster preparations, elevated po-boys on milk bread, and a popular $25 lunch deal featuring head-on shrimp and sides.
This restaurant offers a New Orleans-inspired menu with a strong emphasis on seafood, particularly oysters prepared in various ways, including charbroiled. Elevated po-boys on milk bread and a standout 'seafood and three' lunch option with options like roasted head-on shrimp are frequently recommended. While generally loved, some users have noted that the po-boys themselves might be lacking compared to other items.
"Standout dishes include the charbroiled oysters, the 'seafood and three' lunch special, roasted head-on shrimp, and the smoked fish dip. The cornbread accompanying the lunch special is also highly praised."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Strange Delight, highlighting its delicious seafood, unique New Orleans-inspired dishes, and enjoyable atmosphere. Some note it can be a bit pricey, but the overall experience is highly recommended.
Important Note
Some users have noted that the po-boys at Strange Delight may not meet expectations for authenticity or texture, and the restaurant is considered a bit pricey for casual dining by some.
"Strange Delight is listed as a restaurant recommendation, potentially in or near Fort Greene."
Neutral"This commenter described Strange Delight as a fantastic seafood restaurant located in Fort Greene, recommending it alongside Sunken Harbor Club and Gage and Tollner."
Positive"This user recommended Strange Delight as one of their picks near the Brooklyn Paramount."
Positive"This user recommended Strange Delight as one of their top picks for a romantic and quiet date night near Barclays."
Positive"Strange Delight was mentioned as a place for fried shrimp."
Positive"Strange Delight offers New Orleans-style food in Fort Greene and is considered a very good, uniquely American option."
Positive"Strange Delight was recommended, though the user notes it is a bit pricey for casual visits."
Neutral"The user is eager to try Strange Delight, finding it a bit pricey for casual dining."
Neutral"Strange Delight was mentioned as a recommendation."
Neutral"This restaurant in Fort Greene is mentioned."
Positive"This commenter expresses a negative opinion of Strange Delight."
Negative"The commenter acknowledges the original poster's list and is reminded to revisit Strange Delight."
Neutral"Strange Delight was a gem for the author, who particularly enjoyed the 'seafood and three' lunch, with the cornbread being the standout star for its softness and flavor."
Positive"The commenter initially listed Strange Delight as a favorite but later edited to clarify it is not located in Manhattan, which is the preferred borough for the user."
Neutral"This user recommended Strange Delight if the original poster misses New Orleans, but advised skipping poboys."
Positive"This user stated that Strange Delight's sandwich is delicious but not a po'boy, noting it's made with milk bread which they found gets soggy."
Neutral"The user recalled Strange Delight having good meals and was interested to see if their lunch menu, which they had forgotten about, offered a po'boy."
Positive"This user recommended Strange Delight for lunch, suggesting it as an option for those missing New Orleans."
Positive"Strange Delight is mentioned as a potential option."
Positive"This user loves Strange Delight, stating that 'literally every single dish' they had was delicious with no notes."
Positive
