TLDR
Nautical-themed Fort Greene bistro serving elevated, butter-drenched classics. Renowned for its cult-favorite roast chicken and lively, neighborhood atmosphere.
Instagram Posts References
Sailor was the second restaurant visited in the search for a table. The waitlist for the bar was quoted as an hour and a half, leading the creator to move on without dining there.
The host initially visited Sailor around 8:03 pm but was faced with a 45-minute wait, leading him to Bar Heretic. He later returned to Sailor at 9:00 pm, experiencing a "double wait" before finally being seated. Once inside at 9:11 pm, he ordered a "Martini" and an "Aviation." Both cocktails were described as "beautiful" and the establishment offered "amazing service" in a "beautiful place," indicating a highly positive dining and drinking experience.
Sailor in Fort Greene is noted for its expertly cooked, thick patty burger, topped with onions and cheddar cheese. The restaurant also has famous French toast that diners should save room for.
Enjoy chilled martinis, seasonal vegetables, and a standout roast chicken at Sailor, a popular Fort Greene bistro from Gabriel Stulman and April Bloomfield.
Amber Sutherland-Namako reviews Sailor, a Fort Greene bistro, highlighting its popular chicken and other well-executed dishes in a warm, nautical setting.
Bryan Kim reviews Sailor, a charming maritime-themed bistro in Fort Greene that offers a "genre of one" dining experience, praised for its unapologetically bold dishes and inviting atmosphere.
Details
Located in Fort Greene, this nautical-themed bistro from chef April Bloomfield and restaurateur Gabriel Stulman has become a neighborhood destination known for its elevated takes on classic fare [1]. The restaurant has expanded to include a larger space that accommodates walk-ins, making it easier to enjoy their expertly prepared signature dishes [2]. While the food is widely acclaimed for its rich, concentrated flavors and perfect execution, the establishment has occasionally been the subject of discussion regarding the chef's past controversies [3], [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on seasonal ingredients and bold, classic bistro preparations, with the roast chicken—served in a glossy herbal sauce with Parmesan-crusted potatoes—frequently cited as a standout [1], [2]. Other highly recommended items include the branzino with crispy skin, beef tongue, and a notably bold Caesar salad [1]. While the lamb burger is widely praised, it is exclusively available in the bar area [1], [2]. Some dishes, such as the mussel toast, have seen mixed reception or rotation off the menu [3], [4].
The roast chicken with Parmesan-crusted potatoes is a recurring cult favorite [1], [2]. Additionally, the beef tongue, branzino, and Caesar salad are frequently recommended by diners [1].
Patrons frequently praise the restaurant for its consistent quality, romantic vibe, and excellent value in drinks [1], [2]. However, sentiment remains polarized due to ongoing ethical concerns surrounding the chef's past professional conduct [3], [4].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01French toast20 mentionsThe French toast is a highly recommended item, praised for its ba...
- 02burger10 mentionsSailor's burger is praised for its juicy, fatty texture, compleme...
- 03roast chicken9 mentionsThe roast chicken is a cult favorite and a significant contributo...
- 04lamb burger3 mentions
- 05bavette steak3 mentions
- 06profiteroles3 mentions
Caveats
Reservations can be challenging to secure, though walk-in opportunities exist at the expanded bar area [1], [2]. Some diners have expressed ethical objections to supporting the restaurant due to the chef's past professional controversies [3], [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About SAILOR
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Hard To Get Reservations That Are Now Getable And
"A popular restaurant where reservations are tough, but walk-ins are possible if you are willing to wait or eat at the bar."
PositiveFrom post: Sos Date Night In Brooklyn Iso Restaurant For My
"Recommended as a potential option."
NeutralFrom post: Where To Use Credit Card Dining Credits In Nyc
"The user frequently uses their Chase Sapphire Reserve credit at this restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Who Makes The Best Chicken Breast In Nyc Juicy
"Sailor was listed as a restaurant that might serve good chicken breast."
Neutral