TLDR
Specializing in tangy, cheeseless marinara slices and robust tomato pies, this St. Marks favorite is a go-to for unique, char-forward NYC pizza.
Instagram Posts References
Cello's Pizzeria is featured for its classic New York-style pizza slices. The author sampled both a pepperoni slice and a sausage and broccoli rabe slice, appreciating the variety and quality of this beloved local staple.
Details
Located on St. Marks Place, this spot is frequently recommended for its distinctive approach to New York-style pizza [2], [3], [7], [8]. Fans of the pizzeria celebrate its unique cheeseless options, such as the tangy marinara slice and tomato pie [3], [8]. While many enjoy the charred crust, some visitors find the pizza can be overly salty or occasionally burnt [4], [5], [11].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on Italian-style pizza, earning praise for its tangy tomato-forward red slices and specialty toppings like sausage and broccoli rabe [3], [16]. While the cheeseless marinara and tomato pie are standout recommendations for many [3], [8], some diners find the sauce overwhelming or the crust overly bitter due to excessive char [5], [11].
Caveats
Diners should be aware that the pizza features a heavy char, which some may find bitter [5], and there have been reports of high salt levels in certain slices [11].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About CELLOS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Recent Eats 6 Slices And A Hot Dog Paulie Gees Ev
"Found the pizza to be more interesting than Paulie Gee's."
PositiveFrom post: Recent Eats 6 Slices And A Hot Dog Paulie Gees Ev
"Simply states that Cello's is good."
PositiveFrom post: Recent Eats 6 Slices And A Hot Dog Paulie Gees Ev
"Mentions having a plain cheese and tomato slice that was different from the author's experience."
NeutralFrom post: Recent Eats 6 Slices And A Hot Dog Paulie Gees Ev
"Considers the vodka slice great, but calls the rest of the menu super mid."
NeutralFrom post: Recent Eats 6 Slices And A Hot Dog Paulie Gees Ev
"The author felt the slice was overly salty and not as good as the competition, noting the cashier seemed confused by cash payment."
NegativeFrom post: Best Cheeseless But Not Necessarily
"This user recommended getting a tomato pie from Cello's as a cheeseless option."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter agrees that the pizza looks like it could be from Cellos."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter suggests Cellos."
PositiveFrom post: Anyone Have Any Rec For To Go Lunch Places In The
"Cellos is listed as a recommendation."
NeutralFrom post: Which Places Have Become Part Of Your Regular
"Cello's is mentioned by the commenter."
NeutralFrom post: Solo Dining Near Battery Park
"Cello on St. Marks is suggested as a pizza place."
PositiveFrom post: Recent Eats Cafe Cluny Casa Next Door Kolkata
"The commenter stated that Cello's offers a pure red slice, which is a top contender along with Finis."
PositiveFrom post: Recent Eats Cafe Cluny Casa Next Door Kolkata
"This commenter noted that Cello's Pizza tends to char their pizza, finding it a bit bitter and the sauce quite strong."
NeutralFrom post: Recent Eats Cafe Cluny Casa Next Door Kolkata
"This commenter found the slice from Cello's Pizza to be burnt, despite liking some char on pizza."
NegativeFrom post: Recent Eats Cafe Cluny Casa Next Door Kolkata
"The author appreciates Cello's Pizza for its cheeseless marinara slice, which is not common. They described the sauce as tangier rather than sweet and enjoyed this slice."
Positive