Next.js logo

GUS & MARTY'S

Updated

Phone: (917) 579-5510

Address: 232 NORTH 12 STREET 11211

TLDR

Sublime pita and dream-worthy dips paired with vibrant Greek fare.

Reddit Sentiment for GUS & MARTY'S(based on 5 Reddit opinions)

60% Positive20% Neutral

Tags

greek 4anchovies 2bread 2View All

Neighborhoods

Greenpoint

Instagram Posts References

Tagged and mentioned as one of the 'dimly lit restaurants' visited by the user. No specific food items or images were provided for this restaurant.

Featured Articles

Dedicated reviews and comprehensive features focusing directly on this restaurant.

Gus and Marty's
positive

Will Hartman reviews Gus and Marty's, a Greek restaurant in Williamsburg known for its excellent fresh bread, dips, and lively atmosphere, perfect for groups.

Will HartmanNov 16, 2024
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

Experience a vibrant Greek culinary journey at this Williamsburg gem, renowned for its intoxicatingly fresh bread and an array of delicious dips. From perfectly fried anchovies to a delightful feta saganaki, the starters are a must-try. Dive into flavorful petit gyros or a comforting minced meat pie, and don't leave without indulging in their unique baklava sundae for a sweet finish.

Food Overview

This Greek restaurant is celebrated for its exceptional fresh bread and dips, with taramasalata and tzatziki being standouts. Fried anchovies and feta saganaki also receive high marks. While most dishes like the petit gyros and minced meat pie are well-loved, the lemon chicken was noted as potentially dry.

Highlights / Recommended

"Highly recommended dishes include the fresh bread and dips like taramasalata and tzatziki, the fried anchovies with fried lemon, feta saganaki with honey, pork souvlaki petit gyros, and the baklava sundae."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a positive view of the restaurant, praising its vibrant atmosphere and flavorful Greek dishes, particularly the fresh bread and dips. Some dishes received mixed reviews, but the overall experience is highly regarded.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About GUS & MARTY'S

A user raved about the pita at Gus and Marty's, describing it as sublime and something they've been dreaming about.
This post recommends Gus and Marty's as a solid Greek dining option and specifically suggests trying their fries, crispy anchovies, horiatiki salad, and whole fish.
Gus and Marty's is highlighted as a reliable choice for Greek cuisine in NYC.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: What Brooklyn Restaurant Wowd You Recently

"User has been dreaming about the pita at Gus and Marty’s, calling it sublime."

Positive
May 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Greek Dishes In Nyc

"Suggests specific dishes at Gus and Marty 's: fries, crispy anchovies, horiatiki salad, and whole fish for 2."

Positive
Feb 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Greek Dishes In Nyc

"Recommends Gus and Marty 's as a reliable Greek option in NYC."

Positive
Feb 27, 2025View Comment →

More in Greenpoint

See all

More greek in NYC

See all