TLDR
A breezy Prospect Heights neighborhood favorite featuring a spacious backyard, excellent sandwiches, and a relaxed counter-service vibe.
Instagram Posts References
This post highlights sandwiches from Gertie NYC, specifically mentioning a 'pastrami turkey' sandwich and a 'tuna salad sandwich'. The author expresses strong positive feelings about both, calling the tuna salad sandwich 'perfect' and being 'obsessed' with the pastrami turkey.
Will Hartman reviews Gertie, a counter-service spot in Prospect Heights, highlighting their standout sandwiches and crispy latkes as perfect for a relaxed neighborhood lunch.
Details
Located in Prospect Heights, this counter-service Jewish-American diner offers a relaxed atmosphere highlighted by a spacious, pebbled backyard perfect for casual dining [4]. Guests can enjoy a variety of sandwiches and shared plates in an environment that balances quick service with a social, neighborhood vibe [1], [4]. While the bakery roots are evident, visitors should be aware that the culinary experience is best enjoyed by focusing on the specialty sandwiches rather than the bagels [2], [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on Jewish-American diner fare, with sandwiches standing out as the highlight, particularly the turkey club and pastrami turkey [1], [4], [5]. Latkes are highly recommended for sharing [1], [4], and the salmon salad is noted for its freshness [4]. Visitors are generally advised to skip the bagels, which are often described as overly dense or chewy [2], [4].
Overall customer sentiment is positive, with many diners appreciating the casual, neighborhood feel and frequenting the spot as a reliable local haunt [4], [7]. While the food generally receives praise for its flavors, some diners have noted that the bagel texture is not to their preference [2], [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About GERTIE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Williamsburg Bagel Search Concluded Bk Bagel
"The commenter asks if the author has tried this location, which is identified as having moved to Prospect Heights after closing its original Williamsburg site."
NeutralFrom post: Which Restaurant Whether Fancy Wellknown Or Not
"Part of a group of restaurants considered a frequent local haunt."
NeutralFrom post: Good Cafe Near Barclays Bonus For Tea Breakfast
"This restaurant was provided as a recommendation for a cafe near the Barclays Center."
PositiveFrom post: Which Coffee Shops Have Both Great Coffee And
"This user recommended Gem and Gerties."
PositiveFrom post: Best New Restaurantscoffee Shopsbakeries Opened
"This user lists Gertie as a new opening."
Neutral