Old-school NYC Italian with stellar coal-fired pizza and a charming, classic vibe.
Step into a charming, old-school New York experience at this Italian eatery, a true hidden gem that has been serving the community since 1957. It's renowned for its exceptional coal-fired pizzas, boasting a perfect crust and vibrant sauce that many consider the best in the city. Beyond the outstanding pizza, this spot offers a classic, unpretentious ambiance, making it a beloved choice for both casual meals and memorable celebrations, with some even noting the presence of live music contributing to its unique vibe.
The restaurant is highly praised for its traditional Italian and Italian-American cuisine, with a particular emphasis on its coal-fired pizzas. Specific highlights include the sausage pizza, with its perfect crust and flavorful sauce, and the clams oreganata. While most diners find the food excellent, one individual noted their pizza was too doughy and heavy.
"The coal-fired pizza, particularly the sausage variety, is highly recommended for its perfect crust and flavorful sauce. Additionally, the clams oreganata are suggested as a great appetizer."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the authentic, old-school Italian atmosphere and the excellent pizza, with many considering it an underrated gem. While most reviews are positive, one user found the pizza too doughy and heavy.
Important Note
The restaurant is not open for lunch. One reviewer found the pizza too doughy and heavy.
"This user recommended Arturo's as a place for a casual nice lunch."
Neutral"This is a sit-down pizza and Italian restaurant located on Houston Street, known more for its vibe than its food, though the food is considered fine. They accept reservations via Yelp."
Neutral"The commenter expresses excitement about hosting a large event at Arturo's, specifically mentioning the presence of a jazz band."
Positive"The commenter expresses excitement about hosting an event at Arturo's, specifically mentioning the presence of a jazz band."
Positive"Arturo's is simply listed as a suggestion for the requested large party venue."
Neutral"Arturo's is simply listed as a suggestion for a large party venue."
Neutral"Arturo's is suggested as a potential venue for a large party, though it would require a full buyout."
Neutral"Arturo's is suggested as a venue capable of accommodating 60-80 people, though it would require a buyout."
Positive"Arturo's on Houston Street is recommended, suggesting it deserves recognition."
Positive"Recommends Arturo's located on Houston St."
Positive"Considers Arturo’s an underrated spot."
Positive"Recommends Arturo’s for Italian food."
Positive"Praises Arturo’s as very charming with good food and an authentic old-school NY atmosphere."
Positive"Recommends Arturo’s on Houston St, noting it's coal-fired and has a long history."
Positive"User No_Parsnip_6086 includes Arturo’s in their list of go-to restaurants, a classic pizzeria."
Positive"User recommends Arturo's."
Positive"User describes Arturo's as an old-school spot (opened 1957) with lots of character, noting it's not open for lunch."
Positive"User recommends Arturo's on Houston as a sit-down pizza place with a bar."
Positive"User lists Arturo's Coal Oven as a recommended sit-down pizza place, noting the bonus of live music."
Positive"User recommends Arturo's among other options for sit-down pizza with a bar."
Positive
