Old-school, white tablecloth Italian in Coney Island. Classic ambiance, unique dice game for a free meal, and a taste of history.
Will Hartman reviews Gargiulo's, a century-old Italian restaurant in Coney Island, praising its classic ambiance and unique dice game, despite the food not being the main draw.
Step into a piece of New York history at Gargiulo's, a Coney Island Italian institution since 1907. This classic establishment offers a grand dining experience with high ceilings and formal service, reminiscent of old-school Italian charm. While the food is solid, the real magic lies in the atmosphere and the unique dice game that offers a chance for a free meal, making it a memorable destination.
Gargiulo's offers classic Italian-American cuisine. Standout dishes mentioned include the Calamari Racanati appetizer and the Orecchiette Con Salsiccia. Some reviews suggest the food is good but not necessarily the primary reason to visit, with the overall atmosphere and unique dice game being significant draws.
"The Calamari Racanati is highlighted as a standout appetizer, and the Orecchiette Con Salsiccia is recommended for a classic Italian pasta dish."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, appreciating the classic ambiance and unique atmosphere of this historic establishment. While the food is considered good, the overall experience and special features often stand out as the main draw.
Important Note
Some diners suggest that while the food is good, it might not be the absolute best, and the journey to Coney Island, especially in winter, might be considered impractical by some.
"Gargiulo's on Coney Island was mentioned as a place with good reviews for Italian food."
Positive"Gargiulos in Coney Island is recommended."
Positive"Gargiulos in Coney Island is recommended."
Positive"Visiting Coney Island in winter, including Gargiulo's, can be a unique experience, involving boardwalk walks and trying Russian places."
Neutral"Visiting Coney Island in winter, including Gargiulo's, can be a unique experience, involving boardwalk walks and trying Russian places."
Neutral"This commenter argues that traveling to Coney Island for Italian food is impractical due to the long journey from Midtown and limited activities in winter."
Negative"This commenter argues that traveling to Coney Island for Italian food is impractical due to the long journey from Midtown and limited activities in winter."
Negative"Gargiulo's in Coney Island is a historic establishment (116 years old) that fits the old-school criteria, though the food may not be the best. Coney Island in winter is also mentioned as an experience."
Neutral"Gargiulo's in Coney Island is a historic establishment (116 years old) that fits the old-school criteria, though the food may not be the best. Coney Island in winter is also mentioned as an experience."
Neutral"Gargiulo's in Coney Island is an old establishment, over a hundred years old, that is considered solid, though pricier than L&B."
Positive"A user corroborates the recommendation for Gargulio's, stating it was a regular spot for their mother who grew up in Seagate."
Positive"Gargulio's is located just off the boardwalk and is praised for its delicious Italian food, specifically mentioning the fusili a carciofi."
Positive"This commenter suggests Gargiulo's for Italian food, noting that it is close to Luna Park."
Neutral"The commenter lists Gargiulo's as one of the top Brooklyn recommendations for old-school Italian, after Michael's of Brooklyn."
Positive"The commenter describes Gargiulo's as an old-school, white tablecloth Italian restaurant in Coney Island, known for its local clientele and a unique game where customers can win a free meal. The commenter recounts a personal experience of winning the game."
Positive
