Old-school Italian in Coney Island, w/ a unique dice game for a free meal. Classic ambiance, century-old charm. Standout calamari & pasta.
Will Hartman reviews Gargiulo's, a century-old Italian restaurant in Coney Island, praising its classic ambiance and unique dice game, despite the food not being the main draw.
Step back in time at this century-old, white-tablecloth Italian institution in Coney Island. Renowned for its classic ambiance and a unique dice game where patrons can win a free meal, it offers a grand dining experience reminiscent of old New York. While the food, including standout dishes like Calamari Racanati and Orecchiette Con Salsiccia, is well-regarded, the overall atmosphere and nostalgic charm are the true stars.
This historic Italian restaurant offers classic red-sauce fare. Standout dishes include the Calamari Racanati, described as a refined appetizer, and the Orecchiette Con Salsiccia, praised for its flavorful combination. While generally well-received, some reviews suggest the food may not be the primary draw compared to the atmosphere.
"The Calamari Racanati is highlighted as a standout appetizer, described as a refined grilled calamari dish. The Orecchiette Con Salsiccia is also recommended, praised for its chewy texture and flavorful combination of ingredients."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment, appreciating the classic ambiance and unique features like the dice game. While the food is considered good, it's often seen as secondary to the overall nostalgic experience.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest that while the food is good, it may not be the primary reason to visit, with the atmosphere and unique experiences taking precedence. It's also noted as being pricier than some other comparable Italian establishments.
"Gargiulos in Coney Island is recommended."
Positive"Gargiulos in Coney Island is recommended."
Positive"Visiting Coney Island in winter, including Gargiulo's, can be a unique experience, involving boardwalk walks and trying Russian places."
Neutral"Visiting Coney Island in winter, including Gargiulo's, can be a unique experience, involving boardwalk walks and trying Russian places."
Neutral"This commenter argues that traveling to Coney Island for Italian food is impractical due to the long journey from Midtown and limited activities in winter."
Negative"This commenter argues that traveling to Coney Island for Italian food is impractical due to the long journey from Midtown and limited activities in winter."
Negative"Gargiulo's in Coney Island is a historic establishment (116 years old) that fits the old-school criteria, though the food may not be the best. Coney Island in winter is also mentioned as an experience."
Neutral"Gargiulo's in Coney Island is a historic establishment (116 years old) that fits the old-school criteria, though the food may not be the best. Coney Island in winter is also mentioned as an experience."
Neutral"Gargiulo's in Coney Island is an old establishment, over a hundred years old, that is considered solid, though pricier than L&B."
Positive"A user corroborates the recommendation for Gargulio's, stating it was a regular spot for their mother who grew up in Seagate."
Positive"Gargulio's is located just off the boardwalk and is praised for its delicious Italian food, specifically mentioning the fusili a carciofi."
Positive"This commenter suggests Gargiulo's for Italian food, noting that it is close to Luna Park."
Neutral"The commenter lists Gargiulo's as one of the top Brooklyn recommendations for old-school Italian, after Michael's of Brooklyn."
Positive"The commenter describes Gargiulo's as an old-school, white tablecloth Italian restaurant in Coney Island, known for its local clientele and a unique game where customers can win a free meal. The commenter recounts a personal experience of winning the game."
Positive
