Coal-fired pies w/ a historic vibe. A true NYC pizza staple serving up classic pies since '29.
A true New York institution, this pizzeria has been serving up classic coal-fired pizzas since 1929. Known for its thin-crust pies and vibrant atmosphere, it's a spot that consistently draws praise for its authentic taste and a dining experience that feels like stepping back in time. While some debate its standing among the city's best, many agree it offers a quintessential New York pizza experience.
This pizzeria is renowned for its classic, coal-fired, thin-crust pizzas, often described as the "real deal" and a quintessential New York experience. While many highly recommend the cheese pie and other simple toppings, some find pizzas with more toppings can be less impressive. A common point of discussion is that they only serve whole pies, not slices.
"The cheese pie is frequently mentioned as a must-try, and the meatballs are also recommended. For those looking for a specific pie, the 'Sasso' and 'Picante Pie' have been positively noted."
Overall, customer sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with many praising the pizza as exceptional and a must-try in NYC. Some minor criticisms exist regarding consistency or preference for other styles, but the overall consensus points to a highly satisfying and authentic pizza experience.
Important Note
The restaurant only serves whole pies, not slices. Some reviews mention that the quality can vary, and a few find it overrated or not worth a long wait.
"John's of Bleecker is listed as one of several recommended pizza places."
Positive"This user recommends classic NYC slice joints like Joe's or Suprema, and also mentions John's of Bleeker as a solid coal oven option."
Positive"This user recommends John's on Bleecker for pizza."
Positive"This commenter states that traditional coal-fired, brick oven pizzerias like John's of Bleecker offer a thin crust with some char, very similar to New Haven Apizza."
Positive"This user suggests Johns of Bleeker is very aligned with New Haven Apizza style."
Positive"This is one of the highly regarded pizzerias located within the 'Pizza Triangle' area of the West Village."
Positive"Old John's (presumably referring to John's Pizza) near Lincoln Center was recommended, with a suggestion to avoid Times Square."
Positive"The original poster mentioned John's for a pizza fix, indicating it was a desired stop."
Positive"This commenter expressed strong positive sentiment towards John's Pizza, stating it is "so good"."
Positive"John's Pizza was suggested as a dining option for a child's birthday."
Positive"John's of Bleecker is listed as one of several establishments that offer a New York dining experience."
Positive"This commenter mentions L'Industria Pizza as a place for pizza."
Positive"John's of Bleeker St is listed as one of several recommended establishments for an authentic New York experience."
Neutral"This commenter advises the original poster to search the subreddit for pizza recommendations based on personal preference and location."
Neutral"John's of Bleecker is recommended for pizza."
Positive"The user confirms they have been to John's on Bleecker St before, found it very good, and plans to go again."
Positive"The author recommends John's on Bleecker St if the user has time for more pizza."
Positive"John's of Bleecker is mentioned as a true Neapolitan original institution that makes its own sauce, uses double zero flour, real mozzarella, and basil, and is cooked in coal-burning ovens."
Positive"John's of Bleecker St is confirmed to be an 'old school' pizza place."
Positive"This place is identified as 'old school'."
Positive
