Coal-fired, whole-pie pizza perfection. A historic NYC institution serving up classic slices that are pure magic.
Step into a piece of New York history at John's of Bleecker Street, a legendary pizzeria serving up authentic coal-fired pies since 1929. Renowned for its thin crust and classic toppings, this beloved institution has earned its place as a top-tier pizza destination. Whether you're a local or a tourist, experiencing a whole pie here is a quintessential New York culinary journey.
This pizzeria is celebrated for its classic, thin-crust, coal-fired pizzas, with many customers recommending the cheese or pepperoni pies. While most reviews are overwhelmingly positive, a few mention that the pizza is best eaten immediately and can be 'mid' if reheated. It's important to note that they exclusively serve whole pies, not slices.
"Customers frequently recommend the classic cheese pie and pepperoni pizza. One user also specifically praised the 'meatballs' and dipping them in marinara sauce."
Customers consistently praise the authentic, delicious pizza and the historic atmosphere, though some note that it only serves whole pies and can have long waits.
Important Note
This establishment exclusively serves whole pies and does not offer pizza by the slice. Some reviews suggest that the pizza is best enjoyed immediately and might not be as good when reheated.
"The user commented that the pizza crust from John's of Bleecker St did not look good."
Negative"Johns of Bleecker is suggested as a great place for pizza and beer, open until 11pm. The commenter notes it's quiet later in the evening, meaning no line."
Positive"This commenter suggests John's of Bleecker Street as a recommendation for visitors looking for classic New York pizza."
Positive"Lists John's of Bleecker as a recommended pizza place in the Greenwich/West Village area."
Positive"Mentions John's of Bleecker as a recommended pizza spot."
Positive"John's of Bleecker Street is recommended for taking out-of-town friends."
Positive"John's of Bleecker is recommended as a sit-down option for pizza."
Positive"This user inquired about John's of Bleeker, asking if it's worth going and potentially giving away half the pie. This was part of a discussion about pizza consumption and options."
Neutral"This user stated that John's of Bleeker is one of the few pizza places worth the wait, but not ideal for a solo diner as they only serve whole pies. They provided this advice in the context of recommending pizza spots."
Positive"This user considered going to John's of Bleeker for pizza, noting it as a potential option. They were weighing it against other pizza places."
Neutral"John's of Bleecker Street is recommended as a place for pizza with no reservations, a cheap staple that showcases New York, suggesting a potential wait but manageable by arriving when they open."
Positive"The commenter finds the idea of brown-bagging beers while waiting less than an hour at John's of Bleeker Street to be excessive."
Negative"For a quieter experience at John's of Bleeker Street, it's recommended to go between 3:30 PM and 4 PM."
Neutral"The commenter suggests eating in at John's of Bleeker Street, as to-go pizzas can become soggy from steam. They believe the line moves quickly, especially on a holiday weekend."
Positive"The wait time at John's of Bleeker Street can be longer than stated, and the commenter suggests getting a to-go pie to enjoy in Washington Square Park."
Neutral"The commenter recommends Denino's in Greenwich Village as a fantastic alternative to John's of Bleeker Street, offering great classic NYC pizza without a long wait. They also mention Luzzos as a former favorite coal oven pizza spot."
Neutral"Arriving around 5 PM at John's of Bleeker Street usually results in a manageable wait, which significantly increases later in the evening. Eating earlier is advised."
Neutral"This commenter found the pizza at John's of Bleeker Street to be average and advised not to have high expectations."
Negative"The atmosphere at John's of Bleeker Street is enjoyable, and the line moves quickly."
Positive"John's of Bleeker Street has a great atmosphere and is reasonably priced. The commenter also recommended Totonno's in Coney Island as a tasty and eccentric alternative."
Positive
