A historic West Village gem serving authentic, coal-fired NYC pizza pies since 1929. Classic thin-crust pies w/ a 9.4 rating - no slices! A must-try.
This historic West Village pizzeria, established in 1929, is a beloved institution for classic, coal-fired New York-style pizza. Known for its thin-crust pies, served whole and not by the slice, it offers a traditional dining experience with a family-like atmosphere. Despite occasional debates about its ranking among NYC's best, many consider it a top-tier destination for authentic pizza.
This pizzeria is renowned for its classic New York-style pizza, specifically its thin-crust, coal-fired pies. While many rave about the cheese pizza and the quality of the sauce, a few commenters have found the sauce to be too sweet or bland. It is important to note that they exclusively serve whole pies, not slices. Some recommend keeping toppings simple, like just cheese or pepperoni, to best appreciate the pizza.
"The cheese pizza is frequently highlighted as a must-try. Other recommended options include the pepperoni pizza and meatballs. For those seeking something unique, the 'Picante Pie' has also been recommended."
Overall, customer sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with many hailing it as the best pizza in NYC and a timeless classic. However, a minority find it to be average or overrated, with some specific critiques about the sauce.
Important Note
This establishment exclusively serves whole pies and does not offer pizza by the slice, which can be a drawback for solo diners or those wanting to sample multiple places efficiently. Some patrons have found the wait times to be long, especially during peak hours.
"The post author is organizing a pizza tour across Manhattan and lists John omenclature's of Bleecker Street as one of the pizzerias to visit."
Neutral"The user estimates the wait time at John's of Bleecker Street to be about an hour, noting that the line was very long the previous week."
Negative"The user notes that lines at John's of Bleecker Street have been extremely long, possibly due to competition with Salt Hanks. However, they believe wait times on an early Tuesday might be 15-30 minutes, or 60+ on Thursdays-Saturdays. They recommend Denino's as a backup with a similar pie style that accepts reservations."
Positive"The user mentions that wait times at John's of Bleecker Street can sometimes be surprisingly short and encourages giving it a try."
Positive"The user anticipates a 30-60 minute wait for John's of Bleecker Street during Thanksgiving week due to crowds, but still recommends trying it. They also suggest several alternative pizza places nearby if the wait is too long."
Neutral"The user suggests ordering pizza from John's of Bleecker Street for delivery to avoid wait times, estimating the in-restaurant wait to be around 30 minutes."
Neutral"John's of Bleecker was recommended for its coal oven pizza, representing a classic New York pizza style."
Positive"John's of Bleecker Street was recommended as a quintessential NYC pizza spot, suggesting it as a first stop for pizza."
Positive"John's Pizza in the Village is recommended for pizza, to be followed by pastries from Rocco's."
Positive"Suggests traveling to The Village to eat at John's on Bleecker Street, differentiating it as a sit-down restaurant compared to Joe's. Mentions other restaurants are available in The Village."
Positive"Mentions having enjoyed John's Pizza in Times Square on a previous night."
Positive"John's of Bleecker Street is described as a coal oven pizza place with a burnt crust, and it only serves whole pies."
Neutral"John's of Bleecker Street is noted as a place that does not serve slices."
Neutral"John's of Bleecker Street is in close proximity to other recommended pizza places like Joe's and L'Industrie."
Positive"John's of Bleecker Street is listed under 'Worth going out of the way for'."
Positive"John's Pizza on Bleeker St. in the Village is recommended."
Positive"John's of Bleecker St. is recommended for pizza as a fantastic cheap eat option."
Positive"This user argues that John's of Bleeker, established in 1929, is exemplary of New York pizza."
Positive"This user had a negative experience at John's of Bleeker years ago due to seeing a mouse and has not returned since."
Negative"This user agreed that John's of Bleeker is overrated and stated that many other pizza places in New York are better."
Negative
