TLDR
Authentic, family-owned Italian grub in Little Italy w/ old-school charm. Fun for groups, great food, but not a fancy spot.
Details
This family-owned Italian restaurant in the heart of Little Italy offers an authentic taste of traditional cuisine. It's a place that evokes old-school charm, making it a great spot for lively gatherings. While some find its atmosphere a bit dated, the food consistently receives praise for its deliciousness.
Food Overview
This restaurant is recommended for its authentic Italian and Italian-American dishes, with customers praising its delicious food. It's noted as a good option for family-style dining and is suggested as a top choice for authentic Italian in Little Italy. One commenter described the food simply as 'Real good.'
Caveats
The establishment is described by some as 'pretty dumpy' and not a 'nicer establishment,' suggesting it may lack a refined ambiance. It's recommended more for casual group outings than for a special occasion dinner.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About LA MELA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Italian Restaurants In Manhattan
"This commenter agrees that La Mela has an "old Mulberry St charm" but advises against it for a nice dinner. They suggest Il Cortilé or Da Nico as alternatives."
NegativeFrom post: Best Italian Restaurants In Manhattan
"La Mela is described as fun for large groups but not a nicer establishment, with a commenter calling it "pretty dumpy.""
NegativeFrom post: Best Italian Restaurants In Manhattan
"A brief positive comment states that La Mela is "Real good.""
PositiveFrom post: Best Italian Restaurants In Manhattan
"La Mela in Little Italy is suggested as a dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For Italian Lunch In Lower Manhattan
"This restaurant was recommended for an Italian lunch in Lower Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: Italian Restaurant With Mussels
"This user suggests La Mela on Mulberry Street in Manhattan, praising its delicious food. They also recommend visiting a nearby bakery for dessert afterward."
Positive