Neighborhood institution, serving up some of the city's best traditional bagels. A classic Jewish deli experience.
This classic Jewish deli is a beloved neighborhood institution, renowned for its traditional bagels that some consider the best in the city. While many rave about their authentic flavors and the satisfying egg and cheese on a sesame bagel, it's a place that evokes strong opinions. It's a go-to for many, offering a taste of classic New York.
The star of the show here are the bagels, often praised as traditional and among the best in NYC. The egg and cheese on a sesame bagel is specifically called out as a must-try. While most feedback is positive, one user found the bagels unremarkable, and another noted that quality can differ between locations.
"The egg and cheese on a sesame bagel is a standout dish that has prompted repeat visits. Olive bagels are also noted as being delicious."
Customer sentiment is largely positive, with many hailing it as a favorite bagel spot and a neighborhood gem. However, a few negative comments mention rude service and high prices, with opinions on quality varying by location.
Important Note
Opinions on the quality of bagels can vary by location, and some customers have reported experiences with rude service and high prices.
"Tal bagels offers an olive bagel that is described as quite delicious."
Positive"This commenter recommends Tal Bagels as the best traditional, non-gimmicky bagel in the city, suggesting buying a bag directly from the shop."
Positive"Tal Bagels was stated to always have chopped liver available."
Positive"This user found the Tal Bagels on the east side in the 50s to be good, but other locations were just average."
Neutral"This user reported rude service and high prices at Tal Bagels compared to better local options."
Negative"This user found Tal Bagels to be unremarkable during their experience living nearby."
Negative"This user lists Tal's as a recommended NYC bagel spot, contrasting it with Ess-a-Bagel's doughier texture."
Positive"The egg and cheese on a sesame bagel from Tal was listed as a dish that prompted a return visit."
Positive"A user personally loves Tal Bagels, though notes it's not often mentioned in the subreddit and quality might vary by location."
Positive
