TLDR
NYC's best non-gimmicky bagel? [1] Egg & cheese on sesame, a return-visit worthy dish [1]. Olive bagels and chopped liver also available [2], [3].
Details
A go-to spot for traditional New York bagels, this establishment is praised for its classic offerings, particularly the egg and cheese on a sesame bagel which prompts return visits. While some find it unremarkable, others champion it as the best non-gimmicky bagel in the city, with a particular nod to their olive bagels and the availability of chopped liver.
Food Overview
This spot is known for its traditional New York bagels, with the egg and cheese on a sesame bagel being a standout dish that some customers would return for [1]. They also offer olive bagels described as delicious and consistently have chopped liver available [2], [3]. While some consider it the best traditional bagel option, others have found it unremarkable [4].
Caveats
While some users highly recommend the bagels, others found them unremarkable and have reported negative experiences with service and pricing.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About TAL BAGELS DELI
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Visiting From Seattle With A Group Critique My
"This user recommended Tal Bagel as a better alternative to Ess-a-Bagel if one happens to be in that area."
PositiveFrom post: Which Bagel Places Make Flavors Unique To Them Or
"Tal bagels offers an olive bagel that is described as quite delicious."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Bagel Shop That Both Delivers
"This commenter recommends Tal Bagels as the best traditional, non-gimmicky bagel in the city, suggesting buying a bag directly from the shop."
PositiveFrom post: Chopped Lover
"Tal Bagels was stated to always have chopped liver available."
PositiveFrom post: The 17 Best Bagels In New York City Right Now
"This user found the Tal Bagels on the east side in the 50s to be good, but other locations were just average."
NeutralFrom post: The 17 Best Bagels In New York City Right Now
"This user reported rude service and high prices at Tal Bagels compared to better local options."
NegativeFrom post: The 17 Best Bagels In New York City Right Now
"This user found Tal Bagels to be unremarkable during their experience living nearby."
NegativeFrom post: Best Way To Preserve Nyc Bagels
"This user lists Tal's as a recommended NYC bagel spot, contrasting it with Ess-a-Bagel's doughier texture."
PositiveFrom post: One Dishrestaurant You Had To Go Back To The Next
"The egg and cheese on a sesame bagel from Tal was listed as a dish that prompted a return visit."
Positive