Iconic Brooklyn pizzeria serving legendary NY-style slices w/ a perfect crust & tangy sauce. A must-try for pizza aficionados!
Luigi's Pizzeria, a Brooklyn institution since 1973, is lauded as a top-tier New York-style pizza destination. Known for its classic, hand-stretched dough and traditional techniques, it consistently earns high praise from patrons and critics alike. While the plain cheese slice is a standout, their Sicilian marinara pie and Margherita slice also receive rave reviews, solidifying its reputation as a must-visit for authentic pizza.
Luigi's Pizzeria is celebrated for its authentic New York-style pizza, with many customers hailing it as the best in the city. The regular slice, cheese slice, and Margherita slice are frequently recommended. One unique dish mentioned is the Sicilian marinara pie, described as 'really special.' While the vast majority of feedback is positive, a minority of opinions suggest the pizza can be 'mid' or 'underwhelming,' with one user finding it overly sour.
"The regular slice and cheese slice are frequently lauded as must-tries, with many deeming them the best in NYC. The Sicilian marinara pie is also highlighted as a unique and highly recommended option."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Luigi's for its exceptional New York-style pizza, often calling it the best slice they've ever had. While most reviews are positive, a few diners found it to be average or not worth a special trip.
Important Note
One Reddit user noted that the Luigi's listed on Seamless might not be the original location. Another commenter mentioned that a specific pie, the supreme, is only made once a day and may sell out. Cash is also noted as the only accepted payment method for takeout.
"This user simply stated that Luigi's Pizza is 'crap.'"
Negative"The user rated Luigi's Pizza 7.4, indicating a somewhat mixed or less enthusiastic experience compared to others."
Positive"The commenter expresses confusion about why Luigi's is considered worth trying, stating they lived nearby for a long time and it never became their regular spot. They recommend Nino's in Bay Ridge for their Grandma's Pizza instead."
Negative"The commenter states that Luigi's in Park Slope is a superior option compared to Da Nonna Rosa, despite having previously expressed a negative view on Da Nonna Rosa."
Positive"This commenter loves Luigi's pizza and states that it helped them get through the pandemic."
Positive"The user mentioned Luigi's Pizza, noting it's worth visiting."
Positive"The user found this pizza to be delicious, with a perfect crust. They were inspired to add it to their list of places to try in Park Slope."
Positive"Replying to a query about a past failed date at Luigi's, this user encourages trying it again, stating the pizza is good."
Positive"This commenter expresses strong nostalgia for Luigi's pizza, having lived nearby previously."
Positive"This user offers a neutral assessment, calling Luigi's pizza 'pretty good'."
Neutral"This user had a negative experience with Luigi's pizza, finding it overly sour, but remains open to trying it again due to its popularity, while also expressing disappointment with Bleecker St Pizza."
Negative"A native Queens resident declares Luigi's as their favorite slice in all of NYC."
Positive"This commenter states Luigi's is one of the best slices available anywhere."
Positive"A long-time patron expresses loyalty to Luigi's, highlighting the owners' kindness and the quality of their supreme pizza, while also noting past criticisms that he disputes."
Positive"This commenter simply affirms Luigi's pizza as righteous and congratulates the OP on their choice."
Positive"The user discusses how publicity, social media, and food critics have boosted Luigi's, comparing its lines to other popular spots like L'Industrie and mentioning other ventures by associated pizzerias."
Neutral"This user humorously asks for the post to be taken down to prevent long lines, but later clarifies they were joking."
Neutral"Simply states that Luigi's serves very good pizza."
Positive"Expresses happiness that the OP enjoyed Luigi's pizza."
Positive"This commenter notes the increased popularity of Luigi's over the past seven years, reminiscing about a time when it was less crowded."
Neutral
