TLDR
Old-school Brooklyn pizzeria serving a classic, thin-crust slice. Renowned for quality ingredients & family legacy.
Reddit Sentiment for LUIGI'S PIZZERIA(based on 66 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
This post captures a revisit to Luigi's Pizza, a well-regarded pizzeria in Park Slope, Brooklyn. The author expresses positive sentiment about the experience, specifically highlighting a 'tasty trio of slices' that included a traditional cheese slice, a fresh mozzarella slice, and a Grandma slice. The interaction with a staff member named Gio also contributes to the positive tone, suggesting a friendly and welcoming atmosphere. The emphasis is on the quality and enjoyment of the pizza offerings.
Luigi's Pizza is highlighted as potentially the most famous pizzeria in the country, having received a 9.3 rating from Dave Portnoy and being featured in Adam Sandler's movie 'Big Daddy.' The owner, Giovanni, is noted for expertly preparing the pies. Reviewers taste both a plain slice and a Margherita slice, finding the plain slice to be crunchy with a great sauce and cheese, and the Margherita slice praised for its fresh mozzarella and pesto. Both pizzas received exceptionally high scores from the reviewers.
Luigi's Pizza is a long-standing pizzeria in Brooklyn, New York, founded in 1973. The current owner, Gio, inherited and mastered the pizza recipe from his father, demonstrating traditional techniques like hand-stretching dough and preparing each pizza fresh to order. The establishment is renowned for its classic, simple recipe that results in a thin and crispy crust, often receiving high praise, including a notable 9.3 rating from Dave Portnoy. Beyond the famous cheese pie, Luigi's also offers a variety of specialty pizzas and rolls, maintaining a legacy of quality New York-style pizza.
Details
Luigi's Pizza, a historic Brooklyn establishment founded in 1973, is celebrated for its traditional Italian-American pizzas, particularly its thin and crispy crust and classic cheese pie [1]. The current owner, Gio, continues his father's legacy, hand-stretching dough and preparing each pizza fresh, earning it high praise and a notable rating from Dave Portnoy [1], [2]. Beyond the classic, the menu features specialty pizzas and rolls, all served in a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere [1].
Food Overview
Luigi's Pizza is renowned for its classic Italian-American pizza, featuring a thin, crispy crust and a flavorful sauce. The cheese pie is a standout, often described as perfection with a super thin and crispy crust and rich, tangy tomato sauce [1]. Reviewers also praise the Margherita pie with fresh mozzarella and pesto [2]. While many consider it one of the best slices in NYC, some find it to be average or dry, with opinions varying on their square slice compared to the grandma slice [3]. The owner, Gio, is also a celebrated figure, often referred to as a 'pizza hero' [4].
Highlights / Recommended
"The cheese pie is a highly recommended classic, known for its thin, crispy crust and flavorful sauce. The Margherita and Grandma slices also receive notable praise."
Customer Sentiment
Customers overwhelmingly praise Luigi's Pizza for its classic, high-quality slices and fair prices, with many considering it a favorite [1]. While most experiences are positive, there's an acknowledgment of increased popularity and occasional mixed feelings about its standing among the city's best.
Caveats
While widely praised, some users have found Luigi's pizza to be average, dry, or overly sour. It's also noted that while great if you're nearby, it may not be worth a long trip from Manhattan.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About LUIGI'S PIZZERIA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Pizza Recommendations In The R Train Corridor Of
"This user reported having Luigi's today and found it to be exceptionally good."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza Recommendations In The R Train Corridor Of
"This commenter recommended Luigi's on 5th."
NeutralFrom post: Pizza Recommendations In The R Train Corridor Of
"This user also seconded the recommendation for Luigi's."
NeutralFrom post: Pizza Recommendations In The R Train Corridor Of
"Luigi's is recommended as a pizza place."
NeutralFrom post: Pizza Recommendations In The R Train Corridor Of
"In response to a query about Luigi's crust, this commenter noted that Luigi's has a particularly 'juicy' sauce, which might be similar to Chrissy's."
NeutralFrom post: Pizza Recommendations In The R Train Corridor Of
"This commenter recommended Luigi's for pizza."
NeutralFrom post: Pizza Recommendations In The R Train Corridor Of
"This commenter recommended Luigi's in South Slope, particularly noting their squares as a must-try."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user stated that the pizza at Luigi's is average and very dry, and that the owner Gio, while interesting to hear talk, doesn't elevate the pizza itself."
NegativeFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user stated that Luigi's pizza is average and very dry, and that while the owner Gio is interesting, the pizza itself is not elevated."
NegativeFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This commenter found Luigi's Pizza to taste better than average but was surprised by the claims of it being one of the best, noting it's not a place they'd crave."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This commenter found Luigi's pizza to be better than average but was surprised by the hype, noting it's not a place they'd actively crave."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user called Luigi's Pizza 'completely mid' and an 'average slice shop at best,' believing it doesn't deserve to be considered among the best slice shops in NYC."
NegativeFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user described Luigi's in Park Slope as 'completely mid' and an 'average slice shop at best,' not deserving of being called one of the best."
NegativeFrom post: Four Day Food Itinerary
"Luigi's Pizza was described as providing a solid slice, but the commenter suggested other pizza places like Stretch or Mama's Too might be better options."
NeutralFrom post: Best Pizza For Nyc Day Trip
"Luigi's is recommended if you happen to be in Brooklyn."
NeutralFrom post: Best Pizza For Nyc Day Trip
"Luigi's Pizza offers a great classic slice and a good atmosphere, feeling like a 70s spot with locals. However, it's not worth a long trip from Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza For Nyc Day Trip
"Luigi's Pizza is a good slice if you're nearby, but not worth going out of your way for as it won't blow you away."
NeutralFrom post: Best Pizza For Nyc Day Trip
"Considering Luigi's Pizza in Brooklyn as a potential option for a classic NY-style slice, but unsure if it's worth the travel time compared to other options."
NeutralFrom post: Theyve Been Making Pizza In Brooklyn For 101 Years
"The original post highlights Luigi's Restaurant in Brooklyn, a historic establishment that has been serving pizza for 101 years. The poster encourages support for such long-standing businesses to preserve history and support dedicated owners, suggesting a visit if in the NYC area."
NeutralFrom post: Is Patsys Or Totonnos Still Good
"Luigi's is ranked number 1 by this user."
Positive