No-frills East Village Italian. Cozy vibes, great for groups & celebrations. Must-try spaghetti al limone.
Willa Moore reviews Supper, an East Village Italian restaurant that has been a top pick for birthday dinners for two decades, praising its group-friendly atmosphere and delicious pasta dishes like the spaghetti al limone.
For two decades, Supper has been a beloved East Village Italian gem, consistently ranking as a top choice for birthday dinners and group celebrations. Its inviting ambiance, complete with a cozy brick-walled dining room and charming sidewalk patio, makes it ideal for both special occasions and casual get-togethers. The menu boasts classic, satisfying pasta dishes, with the spaghetti al limone being a particular standout, all complemented by an affordable wine list.
Supper is praised for its classic Italian dishes, particularly its spaghetti al limone, which is frequently highlighted as a must-try. The restaurant is also noted for its hearty pasta dishes like tagliatelle al ragu bolognese and a refreshing shaved mushrooms salad. While most feedback is positive, one commenter found the overall experience to be 'mediocre'.
"The Spaghetti Limone is frequently praised as a standout, with other recommended dishes including Tagliatelle Al Ragu Bolognese and a Shaved Mushrooms Salad."
Customers generally have a very positive sentiment towards Supper, frequently recommending it for its Italian cuisine, cozy atmosphere, and suitability for group gatherings.
Important Note
This establishment may still be a cash-only restaurant.
"Supper in the East Village is mentioned as a good red sauce restaurant."
Positive"Frank! was mentioned as a red sauce spot. The user later clarified Frank and Supper are in the East Village."
Neutral"The chicken parm at Supper in the East Village is described as very delicious."
Positive"Supper in the East Village is recommended for its no-frills atmosphere and a highly satisfying red sauce meal reminiscent of grandmother's cooking."
Positive"This is a restaurant suggestion."
Neutral"Supper is recommended as a potential dining option."
Positive"Recommends Supper in the East Village, highlighting a private library room suitable for groups. They recall a family-style meal with unlimited drinks costing around $200 per person."
Positive"This user simply recommends Supper."
Positive"This user mentions that Supper, like Frank, is cash-only and does not accept credit or debit cards."
Neutral"This commenter lists Lil Frankie's, Frank, and Supper as recommendations."
Positive"This commenter echoes the recommendation for Supper, stating it's great."
Positive"This commenter suggests Supper as a good cozy Italian option in the East Village, recommending it alongside Frank."
Positive"This user states that one can't go wrong with Supper or Frank."
Positive"Supper is recommended as a restaurant that is more upscale than Parm. It's described as a chill, cozy spot with great staff, located on the LES."
Positive"Supper in the East Village is listed as one of the user's favorite Italian restaurants."
Positive"This restaurant was recommended as a potential option for a large group dinner in the East Village."
Neutral"Supper was mentioned as having a nice private room."
Positive"This user, affiliated with Avital Experiences, mentioned Supper as part of their East Village food tour. It is described as an Italian restaurant with Michelin Bib Gourmand status."
Positive"This restaurant is suggested as a potential option for a large party."
Neutral"Supper might be a little too hip, but it's a great Italian spot."
Neutral
