Cozy East Village Italian spot w/ a cult-favorite spaghetti al limone. Great for group celebrations, no-frills vibes, and consistently good food.
Willa Moore reviews Supper, an East Village Italian restaurant that has been a top pick for birthday dinners for two decades, praising its group-friendly atmosphere and delicious pasta dishes like the spaghetti al limone.
A long-standing East Village gem, Supper has been a go-to for celebratory dinners for two decades. It's lauded for its ability to host large groups with a comfortable, brick-walled ambiance and sidewalk patio. The restaurant is celebrated for its straightforward yet satisfying Italian fare, particularly its cult-favorite spaghetti al limone.
This Italian restaurant is known for its comforting, red-sauce style dishes, with the spaghetti al limone being a standout, frequently recommended item. Other praised dishes include the chicken parm and a notable Saturday special of Osso Bucco. The bread and bean/olive oil dip are also highlighted as satisfying starters.
"The Spaghetti Limone is a highly recommended and frequently mentioned dish, described as bright and velvety. The Saturday special Osso Bucco and the chicken parm are also noted as delicious options."
Overall, customer sentiment is highly positive, with many praising the restaurant for its consistently good Italian food, welcoming atmosphere, and suitability for celebrations.
Important Note
The restaurant may still be cash-only, and some users have noted it can be perceived as 'mid' or mediocre.
"This user recommended Frank Pricinzano's places, including Supper, as great spots that are fairly easy to book."
Positive"This user recommended Supper as a great option near the LES that is a bit easier to get into than top spots."
Positive"Supper usually has a good skirt steak option for brunch and larger cuts for dinner. The Saturday special Osso Bucco is also highly recommended."
Positive"Supper in the East Village is mentioned as a good red sauce restaurant."
Positive"Frank! was mentioned as a red sauce spot. The user later clarified Frank and Supper are in the East Village."
Neutral"The chicken parm at Supper in the East Village is described as very delicious."
Positive"Supper in the East Village is recommended for its no-frills atmosphere and a highly satisfying red sauce meal reminiscent of grandmother's cooking."
Positive"This is a restaurant suggestion."
Neutral"Supper is recommended as a potential dining option."
Positive"Recommends Supper in the East Village, highlighting a private library room suitable for groups. They recall a family-style meal with unlimited drinks costing around $200 per person."
Positive"This user simply recommends Supper."
Positive"This user mentions that Supper, like Frank, is cash-only and does not accept credit or debit cards."
Neutral"This commenter lists Lil Frankie's, Frank, and Supper as recommendations."
Positive"This commenter echoes the recommendation for Supper, stating it's great."
Positive"This commenter suggests Supper as a good cozy Italian option in the East Village, recommending it alongside Frank."
Positive"This user states that one can't go wrong with Supper or Frank."
Positive"Supper is recommended as a restaurant that is more upscale than Parm. It's described as a chill, cozy spot with great staff, located on the LES."
Positive"Supper in the East Village is listed as one of the user's favorite Italian restaurants."
Positive"This restaurant was recommended as a potential option for a large group dinner in the East Village."
Neutral"Supper was mentioned as having a nice private room."
Positive
