East Village Italian gem, loved for its cult-favorite Spaghetti Limone and accommodating atmosphere. A consistent top pick for celebrations and casual catch-ups.
Willa Moore reviews Supper, an East Village Italian restaurant that has been a top pick for birthday dinners for two decades, praising its group-friendly atmosphere and delicious pasta dishes like the spaghetti al limone.
This East Village Italian spot has been a go-to for celebrations for two decades, offering a welcoming atmosphere perfect for both intimate dinners and larger groups. It's celebrated for its simple yet satisfying pasta dishes, with the Spaghetti Limone being a standout favorite. The restaurant also boasts an affordable wine list, making it a consistent and well-loved recommendation.
The restaurant is praised for its Italian cuisine, with particular acclaim for its Spaghetti Limone, described as life-changing, and Tagliatelle Al Ragu Bolognese. The Shaved Mushrooms Salad is also noted as a good option. While most feedback is positive, one user described the restaurant as 'mediocre'.
"The Spaghetti Limone is a standout, described as bright, velvety, and exceptionally good, while the Tagliatelle Al Ragu Bolognese is a hearty pasta option. The Shaved Mushrooms Salad is also positively reviewed."
Customers generally have a positive view of the restaurant, frequently recommending it for its Italian cuisine and specific dishes like the Spaghetti Limone. Some find it a great alternative to other popular spots.
Important Note
One user mentioned that the restaurant is cash only.
"Supper is mentioned as being open for all holidays and may offer comped meals to those dining alone on Christmas or Thanksgiving."
Positive"The Spaghetti Limone at Supper was a memorable dish for this commenter. It's also available at their sister restaurants."
Positive"This user enjoyed the bread and a bean/olive oil dip at Supper, finding it substantial enough to make a meal of."
Positive"Supper is described as great and not too expensive."
Positive"The commenter expresses strong positive sentiment for Supper, in agreement with another recommendation."
Positive"Supper is recommended for Italian cuisine."
Neutral"Franks / Lil Frankie's/ Supper are all good, same owners, cash only."
Positive"Commenter suggests Supper as a potential restaurant option, listing it among 'safe foods' like Italian during their first trimester of pregnancy."
Positive"Recommends Supper for a great dinner without reservations, describing it as a New York style Italian place that is quintessentially real NYC."
Positive"Suggests emailing Supper regarding availability for a dinner party of 11."
Neutral"Another user disagrees, stating that Supper is also mediocre ("mid")."
Negative"User recommends Supper as a better alternative to L'Artusi, highlighting its moderate pricing and accessibility."
Positive"Restaurant mentioned as recommendation"
Neutral
