TLDR
Cozy, authentic Roman-style Italian featuring a legendary Sunday-only lasagna and seasonal market-driven specials.
Reddit Sentiment for IL POSTO ACCANTO(based on 65 Reddit opinions)
Details
Renowned for its cozy, authentic Roman-style atmosphere, this family-run establishment is frequently cited as one of the best Italian restaurants in Manhattan [1]. The menu highlights include fresh, market-driven ingredients and highly acclaimed traditional dishes [2]. While the experience is generally lauded for its hospitality, some diners note that the space can be quite intimate [3].
Food Overview
The restaurant specializes in homey, traditional Italian cuisine, with a menu that changes to reflect fresh, seasonal ingredients [5]. The lasagna, served exclusively on Sundays, is a widely celebrated highlight [6], while other popular dishes include meatballs [7], the cotoletta panini [8], and seasonal appetizers like soft shell crab [9]. Some diners recommend exploring the non-pasta options for a unique experience [10].
The Sunday-only lasagna is the most consistently recommended dish [6], alongside the flavorful cotoletta panini [8] and the light fettuccine with shiitake mushrooms in a white wine sauce [11].
Overall sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with many diners praising the warm hospitality and nostalgic atmosphere [4]. However, a small minority of guests have reported inconsistent service and found the dining area to be cramped [3].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01lasagna5 mentions
- 02puntarelle alla romana2 mentions
- 03cotoletta panini2 mentions
Caveats
The restaurant is intimate and can feel cramped at times [3]. Reservations are recommended and must be made by phone [12], and some popular seasonal items like the Puntarelle alla Romana salad can sell out quickly [13].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About IL POSTO ACCANTO
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Restaurants You Keep Going Back To Any
"Not cheap, but great Italian food and a fun vibe."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurants You Keep Going Back To Any
"Recommended restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: 63 Clinton Is Their Newest Menu Not Good Would
"The user suggests this as a better value option for dining and wine."
PositiveFrom post: Italian Resto For Last Minute Chill Birthday
"Recommended as a potential spot for a birthday dinner."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurants Like Osteria 57 For A Cozy Birthday
"Recommended as a suitable option for a cozy birthday dinner."
Positive