Authentic Italian w/ incredible homemade pasta & legendary Sunday lasagna. Cozy, unpretentious, great vibes.
This charming Italian restaurant is celebrated for its authentic, home-style cooking, particularly its homemade pasta and a legendary lasagna that's a Sunday tradition. It's a cozy, unpretentious spot that offers a genuine taste of Italy, with many patrons praising its friendly owners and consistent quality. While generally highly regarded, some recent feedback suggests potential inconsistencies in food quality or service, though many still consider it a top-tier neighborhood gem.
Known for its exceptional homemade pasta and a highly recommended lasagna, this Italian eatery offers a taste of traditional Roman and Italian cuisine. While most reviews highlight the quality and authenticity, a few recent comments suggest that portion sizes or pasta consistency might vary. The fritto misto and meatballs also receive nods of approval.
"Homemade pasta, lasagna (especially the Sunday special), fritto misto, and meatballs are frequently recommended. The Puntarelle alla Romana salad is also a favorite but tends to sell out quickly."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the authentic, home-style Italian food, especially the homemade pasta and legendary lasagna. The friendly owners and neighborhood feel contribute to a positive experience for many.
Important Note
Reservations must be made by phone. Some recent reviews suggest potential inconsistencies in food quality or portion sizes, and one commenter found the owner to be rude, contrary to the general sentiment.
"This commenter highly recommends Il Posto Accanto."
Positive"The commenter recently visited Il Posto Accanto for the second time and found it to be an underrated spot."
Positive"This is a great little Italian wine bar."
Positive"The user expressed significant disappointment with Posto Acanto, stating it did not meet their expectations."
Negative"This user initially recommended Il Posto Accanto for dinner on the Lower East Side, noting it would likely fit the specified budget and be a good option if Italian cuisine were desired."
Neutral"Il posto accanto is suggested."
Positive"Il Posto Accanto is suggested as a sit-down option that can also be very quick."
Positive"In response to a negative review, the original commenter defended Il Posto Accanto, stating they and their guests have never had a bad experience and that only Torrisi is better. They've eaten there many times and taken friends from various backgrounds, including chefs."
Positive"This commenter believes Il Posto Accanto has become overrated and is not a top-tier restaurant. They describe it as cramped with inconsistent service and a potentially rude owner, disagreeing that it excels in hospitality."
Negative"This commenter strongly co-signed the recommendation for Il Posto Accanto, praising the spot and Julio for always providing fresh and good food."
Positive"Il Posto Accanto is highly recommended as the best Italian in the city, praised for its family ownership, traditional lasagna, fresh ingredients, and excellent hospitality. The commenter encourages informing Julio about special occasions."
Positive"Expressed positive sentiment towards Il Posto Accanto."
Positive"Highly recommended Italian restaurant, known for its constantly changing menu based on fresh ingredients and a consistently excellent lasagna. The owner has been running it since the 90s, and it's described as a cool, OG NYC spot with reasonable prices that teenagers also enjoy."
Positive"Il Posto Accanto is suggested as a restaurant with excellent food and great service, with a note to order off the specials menu for the best experience."
Positive"This commenter states that Il Posto Accanto is the best Italian restaurant in the city in their opinion."
Positive"This user clarifies that the salad in question is 'Puntarelle alla romana'."
Neutral"This user inquires about the specific salad mentioned at Il Posto Accanto."
Neutral"This commenter states that the paninis at Il Posto Accanto are very good during lunchtime."
Positive"This user suggests going at lunchtime to avoid the salad selling out quickly at Il Posto Accanto."
Neutral"This commenter expresses their love for Il Posto Accanto and mentions a specific salad, Puntarelle alla Romana, that they enjoy but notes it sells out quickly."
Positive
