LITTLE ITALY PIZZA

Updated 3 months ago

Address: 55 WEST 45 STREET 10036

TLDR

Classic NYC pizza-by-the-slice joint; reliable, no-frills, and a go-to for Theater District lunch. Some find it pricey but a satisfying slice.

Reddit Sentiment for LITTLE ITALY PIZZA(based on 4 Reddit opinions)

75% Positive25% Negative

Achievements and Accolades

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Instagram Posts References

Little Italy Pizza is featured as a recommended establishment for pizza, standing out as a top spot that lives up to its reputation in the city's vibrant food scene.

Details

A classic NYC pizzeria that serves up New York-style pizza by the slice, this spot is a go-to for those in the know, especially if you're in the Theater District or near Bryant Park. It's a no-frills establishment that delivers on a satisfying pizza experience. While many find it to be a reliable and tasty option, especially for a quick lunch, some find the prices a bit high for a standard slice.

Food Overview

This establishment specializes in New York-style pizza, served by the slice, making it a convenient option for a quick meal. It's frequently recommended for its classic pizza offerings, though a few patrons feel the prices are a bit steep for what is considered a standard slice.

Highlights / Recommended

"The establishment is known for its New York-style pizza, particularly served by the slice."

Customer Sentiment

Customer sentiment is generally positive, with many appreciating the classic New York-style pizza for a quick and satisfying meal, though some note that the prices can be a bit high for a simple slice.

Caveats

Some customers find the prices to be high for a standard pizza slice.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Suggestions For Pizza Near Rockefeller Center

"This commenter recommended Little Italy Pizza on 45th."

Positive

Mar 9, 2026View Comment →

From post: Bryant Park Lunch Recommendations

"When the user worked near Bryant Park, they frequented Little Italy Pizza on 45th street."