A go-to for brunch & breakfast, famed for fluffy buttermilk pancakes. Can be pricey & book up fast.
Sarabeth's is a well-regarded American restaurant celebrated for its exceptional brunch and breakfast offerings. Many patrons rave about the quality and taste of their dishes, with specific mentions of their delicious buttermilk pancakes. While generally a popular choice, some reviews indicate that it can be on the pricier side, and on occasion, reservations might be difficult to secure.
Sarabeth's is primarily known for its American breakfast and brunch fare, with buttermilk pancakes frequently highlighted as a must-try. While many appreciate the quality, a recurring theme in customer feedback is the perception of high prices, with some meals costing upwards of $90. There are also mixed reviews, with one user specifically advising to avoid it after considering other options.
"The buttermilk pancakes at Sarabeth's are frequently recommended and highly praised by patrons."
Customers generally have a positive view of Sarabeth's, particularly praising their breakfast and brunch items like buttermilk pancakes. However, some find it to be an overpriced dining experience and note that it can be difficult to get reservations.
Important Note
Some customers find the restaurant to be overpriced for the experience. Additionally, it can be difficult to secure reservations, especially for popular times.
"This restaurant was recommended as a spot that could accommodate a large group for brunch."
Neutral"The commenter loves the buttermilk pancakes at Sarabeth's."
Positive"Sarabeths is recommended."
Positive"This user suggested Sarabeths as a potential option for the original poster's request."
Positive"This commenter listed Sarabeths as a potential breakfast spot, implying it's a good choice for a weekday visit."
Positive"The original poster mentions having brunch at Sarabeth recently as part of their dining experiences."
Neutral"Sarabeths was mentioned as a potential dining option."
Neutral"The commenter followed up to state that Sarabeth's CPS was fully booked for their desired date."
Negative"This establishment is recommended as a brunch spot, noted to be a 14-minute walk away. The user later confirmed that reservations were unavailable for their requested date."
Neutral"A user mentioned Sarabeths as a potential option but warned that it is similarly expensive to Parker & Quinn, noting the grilled cheese costs around $25."
Negative"A user reported a very mediocre experience at Sarabeth’s last month, noting they spent over $100 for two people despite ordering the bare minimum."
Negative"Despite a positive overall experience at Sarabeth's, a user highlighted the high cost, noting their turkey sandwich meal came to $90."
Positive"Sarabeth’s was recommended by a user as an overpriced breakfast spot."
Positive"Sarabeth's is stated to be quite good specifically for dinner."
Positive"The user recommends Sarabeths as a brunch spot."
Positive"The user was considering Sarabeth's but they are fully booked."
Neutral"Recommends Sarabeth's for brunch."
Positive"FastChampionship2628 lists Sarabeth's as a place to avoid, after The Smith and Jack's Wife Freda."
Negative"User recommended Sarabeth's as a potential spot for Mother's Day brunch or lunch in the Midtown/Chelsea area."
Positive
