Old-school Queens ice cream parlor since 1925. Classic flavors, huge sundaes w/ 'the works', & thick milkshakes.
Step back in time at Eddie's Sweet Shop, a beloved Queens institution serving up classic ice cream since 1925. This old-school parlor offers a nostalgic experience with 18 traditional flavors, from mint chip to vanilla fudge, all made from the original recipe. It's the perfect spot for a generously topped sundae or a thick, creamy milkshake.
Eddie's Sweet Shop specializes in classic American ice cream, sundaes, and milkshakes. Customers highly recommend the generous toppings, particularly the hot fudge and hand-whipped cream, which are often described as the best. The mint chip and vanilla fudge are noted as popular flavors, best enjoyed with these decadent additions.
"The hot fudge sundaes, especially with the generous amounts of thick hot fudge and fresh whipped cream, are highly recommended. Classic milkshakes and mint chip ice cream are also popular choices."
Customers rave about the nostalgic, old-fashioned atmosphere and the generous portions of classic ice cream, sundaes, and milkshakes. The hot fudge and hand-whipped cream are frequently highlighted as must-haves.
Important Note
The shop is located in Forest Hills, Queens, which may be a bit of a journey from other parts of the city, and potentially a walk from the nearest subway station.
"While not standard, the commenter suggested asking Eddie's Sweet Shop for a thick ice cream shake with added toppings as a way to achieve a blend-in experience."
Neutral"Highly recommends Eddie's Sweet Shop in Forest Hills, emphasizing that their hand-whipped whipped cream makes the milkshakes heavenly."
Positive"Suggests Eddie's Sweet Shop in Forest Hills for a good milkshake if one is willing to travel to Queens."
Positive"Praises the old-fashioned soda fountain vibes at Eddie's Sweet Shop."
Positive"Comments that Eddie's Sweet Shop is a good option, located far out in Forest Hills but worth visiting for the experience."
Positive"Recommends Eddie's Sweet Shop as another option for a traditional milkshake."
Positive"This comment suggests getting dessert at Eddie's Sweet Shop, described as an old-fashioned ice cream parlor."
Positive"Eddie's Sweet Shop is mentioned as a recommendation for milkshakes."
Positive"The commenter confirms Eddie's Sweet Shop is in Forest Hills, specifically on Metropolitan Avenue, but notes it can be a bit of a hike from the subway, which might be difficult with an 8-year-old."
Neutral"This is described as an old-time soda shop located in Forest Hills, Queens, offering a nostalgic experience."
Positive"The user expresses a strong craving for Eddie's Hot Fudge sundae, having not had one in a while."
Positive"Eddie's is praised as the 'gold standard' for hot fudge viscosity, prompting users to make special trips for its proper thick consistency."
Positive"Eddie's is considered the best option for hot fudge by this user."
Positive"The user enjoys Eddie's hot fudge and whipped cream so much that they would eat a bowl of it without the ice cream."
Positive"Eddie's Sweet Shop is listed as a recommended place for hot fudge, implying a positive experience for ice cream sundaes."
Positive"Eddie's offers a very generous amount of hot fudge with the right thick texture, almost more topping than ice cream, creating a large molten pool of chocolate. Getting fresh whipped cream is also highly recommended."
Positive"Eddie's Sweet Shop was listed as a unique ice cream shop in the outer boroughs."
Neutral
