Quintessential NYC slice shop w/ thin-crust pizza, calzones & garlic knots. A beloved neighborhood gem for a quick, satisfying bite.
This East Village institution has been serving up classic New York-style pizza for years, with a loyal following that appreciates its consistent thin-crust pies. While some lament the price of a single slice, many consider it a quintessential neighborhood spot, perfect for a quick, satisfying bite. Beyond pizza, they also serve well-regarded calzones and garlic knots, making it a versatile choice for casual dining.
The restaurant is primarily known for its New York-style pizza, with customers frequently recommending the thin-crust slices. Calzones and garlic knots are also noted as being good. One concern raised is the price of individual slices, with one user finding an $8 slice too expensive.
"Customers frequently recommend the New York-style thin-crust pizza slices, as well as the calzones and garlic knots."
Customers generally have a positive view, praising the classic New York-style pizza, calzones, and garlic knots. However, some find the price of a single slice to be on the higher side.
Important Note
Some users have noted that the price for a single slice can be high ($8 mentioned), and one user experienced inconsistency with slice quality, finding it greasy and soggy on one occasion.
"This individual has been a loyal customer of East Village Pizza since 1997, traveling from Queens to Manhattan for it. They emphasize that the restaurant still makes the same good thin-crust pizza."
Positive"This commenter elevates the description of East Village Pizza from 'good enough' to the 'platonic ideal of an NYC slice shop', suggesting it's superior to most pizza places nationwide."
Positive"This user reflects on their age, noting that they now perceive East Village Pizza, a place they've known for a while, as a newer establishment in the neighborhood."
Neutral"This is a one-word reply ('Za?') to another comment, indicating curiosity or questioning the slang used."
Neutral"This commenter briefly states that the pizza from East Village Pizza looks like 'stretch pizza'."
Neutral"In response to the inconsistency issue, this commenter brings up that the employees at East Village Pizza often seem miserable."
Negative"This user's main issue with East Village Pizza is the inconsistency in their slices, noting that one visit might yield a great slice while another results in a greasy and soggy mess."
Negative"This commenter confirms East Village Pizza now only serves pizza and agrees that their calzones are good, also adding garlic knots as a recommended item."
Positive"This commenter used to frequent East Village Pizza years ago and enjoyed their calzones. They note the removal of 'and kebabs' from the name and question if they still serve pita sandwiches."
Positive"This commenter suggests that many NYC pizza places, including potentially East Village Pizza, are supported by tourists and drunk patrons."
Negative"This user considers East Village Pizza a good option for post-drinking food in the East Village, though they acknowledge they frequent it less now as they drink there less often."
Positive"This commenter views East Village Pizza as a platonic ideal of an NYC slice shop, perfect for a quick, enjoyable bite. Although not the absolute best pizza, they appreciate its role in the neighborhood."
Positive"The commenter suggests East Village Pizza might offer a stuffed pizza, though not the exact style requested. They are unsure about their own opinion of the place."
Neutral"The user recommended East Village Pizza as a good pizza option in the city, in addition to recommending places in Brooklyn and Staten Island."
Positive"East Village Pizza is recommended to be dropped as it is not that good."
Negative"East Village Pizza is grouped with Joe's and Bleecker Street Pizza as tasting nearly indistinguishable and generic."
Neutral"East Village Pizza is recommended to be skipped."
Negative"The commenter states that Godfather's Pizza is superior to Cicis Pizza, lamenting the absence of Godfather's nearby."
Negative"The user is advised to take their child to Cicis Pizza as this is a unique childhood experience that will only happen once."
Neutral"The commenter expresses a desire to get intoxicated and visit a Cicis Pizza, play arcade games, and consume a large quantity of pizza."
Neutral
