Cheesy, stretchy slices with a great cheese pull. A go-to for classic NY-style pizza, though some find it pricey.
East Village Pizza has garnered a reputation as a solid spot for classic New York-style pizza, frequently highlighted on Reddit for its satisfying cheese pull and overall quality. It's a go-to recommendation for a "good ol slice" and a reliable neighborhood pizza joint. The establishment even participated in the One Bite Pizza Festival, showcasing its pizza to a wider audience. While many find it a great option, particularly for those seeking that authentic New York pizza experience, a recent mention of an $8 slice has raised some concerns about its price point for some patrons. Despite this, it remains a popular choice for many, often cited as a good starting point for exploring the East Village food scene.
East Village Pizza is celebrated for its New York-style pizza, with many customers specifically praising its 'stretchy cheese' and recommending it as a 'good ol slice.' It's often mentioned as a reliable spot for pizza in the East Village. While generally well-regarded, one reviewer found the price of a single slice to be off-puttingly high.
"Customers frequently recommend the New York-style pizza slices, highlighting their cheesy quality and impressive cheese pull."
Customers generally have a positive view of East Village Pizza, frequently recommending it for its classic New York-style pizza, particularly noting its cheese pull and overall quality. However, a few recent experiences have highlighted concerns about pricing, with one customer finding a single slice to be excessively expensive. While some see it as a solid neighborhood option, others suggest it might not be the top choice for a curated tourist food tour.
Important Note
One user reported a single slice costing $8, which they found too expensive. Another user advised against recommending it to tourists for a food tour.
"The commenter rated East Village Pizza around 7.5, which closely aligned with professional and audience reviews."
Neutral"User advises the original poster to skip East Village Pizza on future trips. They state that while it's "not a bad slice," they would never recommend it to a tourist as part of a food tour."
Negative"The original poster explains they went to East Village Pizza late in the day to meet a self-imposed "quota of 5 slices" and it was the "best slice around me" at that specific moment, not necessarily a strong endorsement of its overall quality."
Neutral"User recounts visiting East Village Pizza once, finding a slice cost $8, and consequently left without purchasing. This implies a negative experience due to perceived high price."
Negative"Says East Village Pizza is known for its cheese pull."
Positive"Recommends East Village Pizza for cheesy pizza."
Positive"Lists East Village Pizza as a recommendation."
Positive"Recommends East Village Pizza for New York style pizza."
Positive"A commenter recommended East Village Pizza for visitors in the East Village."
Positive"A commenter suggested starting a food tour at East Village Pizza."
Positive"A commenter recommended East Village Pizza as one of several good pizza options in its neighborhood for a picky eater."
Positive"A commenter expressed fondness for a 'good ol slice' from East Village Pizza."
Positive"Recommending East Village Pizza"
Positive
