TLDR
Indulgent, decadent cake slices and a must-try pistachio-filled lobster tail pastry. A local go-to for late-night sweets with a wide variety of dessert options.
Reddit Sentiment for MIA'S BAKERY TIMES SQUARE(based on 100 Reddit opinions)
Details
A popular destination for indulgent desserts, this spot is frequently recommended for its extensive selection of cakes, including the celebrated Brooklyn Blackout and various chocolate mousse options [1], [2]. While many diners praise the consistently high-quality cake slices and pastries, the establishment's reputation remains polarized [3]. Some visitors report excellent experiences with items like lobster tails and rainbow cookies, whereas others have raised serious concerns regarding ingredient quality and even isolated incidents of food poisoning [4], [5], [6].
Food Overview
The menu features a wide array of American-style bakery staples, with the chocolate blackout cake, chocolate fudge cake, and pistachio-filled lobster tail receiving frequent accolades for their flavor and texture [1], [5], [6]. Customers also frequently order cheesecakes and rainbow cookies, though some find the frosting on various cakes overly sweet and have expressed dissatisfaction with specific items like faux cronuts [2], [4], [7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MIA'S BAKERY TIMES SQUARE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Strawberry Pastries Near Times Square Or Close By
"Highly recommended as having the best baked goods in the Times Square area."
PositiveFrom post: Bakerycake Shop Recos Within Manhattan Where I
"Suggested as a possibility for cake shopping."
NeutralFrom post: Best Lemon Bars In The Citythe Tangier The Better
"The user recommends Mia's."
PositiveFrom post: Chocolate Cake With Vanilla Frosting
"The user suggests this bakery as a recommendation for the requested cake style."
PositiveFrom post: Tasting And Ranking Of Seven Chocolate Cakes In
"Recently tried the blackout cake for a birthday and found it incredible."
Positive