Authentic Tuscan trattoria w/ incredible pasta & truffle dishes. A lively West Village gem.
A classic Italian trattoria in the heart of the West Village, this spot is beloved for its authentic Tuscan fare and lively atmosphere. Patrons rave about the fresh, house-made pasta dishes, with particular praise for the indulgent truffle pasta and creamy penne alla vodka. It's a place that feels like a true slice of Italy, perfect for a casual yet delicious meal.
This Italian restaurant is celebrated for its authentic Tuscan cuisine, with a strong emphasis on pasta dishes. The truffle pasta and penne alla vodka are frequently recommended. Some diners find the food to be average or overpriced, but the majority highlight the quality and authenticity.
"Highly recommended dishes include the truffle pasta, penne alla vodka, and fresh burrata. The menu often changes daily, offering a variety of authentic Italian pasta creations."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the authentic Italian cuisine, especially the pasta dishes. While most reviews are positive, a few mention it not living up to the hype or being overpriced.
Important Note
The restaurant is cash only and may require phone reservations. Some diners feel it doesn't live up to the hype or can be overpriced.
"This user stated that Pitti is the most authentic Southern Italian place, implying La Piccola Cucina is second most authentic."
Positive"This user recommended Bar Pitti, specifically advising to order from the black chalkboard menu rather than the regular menu."
Positive"Bar Pitti is recommended for its tiramisu, which can be had for dessert during lunch or dinner. It is described as really great."
Positive"Bar Pitti is listed as a place to get good truffle pasta."
Positive"Bar Pitti was added to the list of good suggestions for outdoor dining."
Positive"This restaurant is listed as having a love/hate relationship with the commenter."
Neutral"Bar Pitti is recommended as an Italian restaurant that is not too far from the discussed area."
Neutral"Bar Pitti was suggested as an option with good people-watching from its sidewalk seating."
Positive"This commenter listed several dishes they'd return for, including the penne alla vodka at Bar Pitti."
Positive"This restaurant is recommended by the commenter."
Positive"Recommends Bar Pitti in the West Village as a good Italian restaurant for dining with a four-year-old, noting the staff is wonderful with children and they can make kids pasta off-menu."
Positive"Bar Pitti is recommended for its pasta dishes."
Positive"The user Pitiful-Job7050 stated Bar Pitti (presumably as not living up to hype, based on context of thread)."
Negative"The user Mofrdo found that Bar Pitti didn't live up to the hype."
Negative"Pitiful-Job7050 recommends avoiding Bar Pitti."
Negative"Bar Pitti is a low-key, very Italian place near Carbone."
Neutral"The commenter deems a significant portion of the OP's restaurant list, including Bar Pitti, as average or overpriced."
Negative"Suggests Bar Pitti as a potential option for pasta."
Neutral"Bar Pitti was suggested as a potential venue for good truffle pasta in NYC. The comment listed it as one of several options."
Neutral
