TLDR
Classic coal-oven pies and hearty Italian fare in a comfortable sit-down setting. Perfect for groups seeking a reliable, high-quality pizza experience near the park.
Details
Renowned for its coal-oven pies, this destination is a staple for those seeking a traditional sit-down pizza experience in the heart of Midtown [1], [9]. While celebrated for its family-style dining and quality, it serves as a reliable go-to for both locals and visitors near major landmarks [5], [9], [16]. Patrons generally enjoy the atmosphere, though experiences with pizza consistency can occasionally vary [6], [9].
Caveats
Some visitors have noted that the pizza quality can be inconsistent, with instances of pies being served underdone [6].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ANGELO'S PIZZERIA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Decent Foodpizza Near Central Park South Upper
"Recommended for pizza near Central Park South."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter suggests Angelos Pizza near Carnegie Hall."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter states with certainty that the pizza is from Angelo's Pizza or something very similar."
NeutralFrom post: Cheap Eats In Upper Midtown
"This user recommended Angelo's on 58th street if the original poster is looking for a pizza restaurant rather than just a slice shop."
NeutralFrom post: Help Me Find A Clam Pizza Slice
"This commenter recommended Angelo's on 2nd Ave off 34th."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can A Girl Get Some White Sauce Prosciutto
"Angelo's Coal Oven Pizza was listed as a place to consider for pizza."
NeutralFrom post: Celebration Dinner Near Columbus Circle
"Angelo's coal oven pizza is highly recommended for its delicious family-style pizza and pasta dishes, and great service, making it good for groups."
PositiveFrom post: Suggestions For Pizza Near Rockefeller Center
"This commenter recommended Angelo's on 57th as one of their favorites, suggesting it for ordering a pie and sitting down if the user changes their mind about takeout."
PositiveFrom post: Midtown Recs
"Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria is mentioned without further detail."
NeutralFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"This user suggests getting pizza from Angelo's to go, noting that dining in is also an option."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"Another user recommends Angelo's."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"This comment seconds the recommendations for Angelo's and Pops."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"This user feels that Angelo's pies are sometimes underdone since becoming more popular, but still acknowledges its great location."
NeutralFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"This user agrees that Angelo's on 57th street is a good choice for pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"Angelo's is mentioned as one of the user's favorites for pizza in the area."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pizza Near Columbus Circle
"Angelo's is a great option for pizza, though it is more of a sit-down establishment."
Positive