Classic NYC coal oven pizza, a must-try for sit-down meals & large parties.
Known for its authentic Italian pizza, this establishment offers a classic New York style coal oven experience. It's frequently recommended for its quality pies, making it a solid choice for both casual dining and larger gatherings, with many finding it a great spot for sit-down meals.
This restaurant is celebrated for its authentic Italian and New York-style coal oven pizza. It's consistently recommended by patrons as a great option for pizza lovers, with many appreciating it as a sit-down dining experience. A few comments suggest that the pizza quality might occasionally be affected by its growing popularity, with some pies sometimes appearing underdone.
"The restaurant is highly recommended for its authentic Italian and New York-style coal oven pizzas."
Customers overwhelmingly recommend this spot for its excellent pizza, highlighting its suitability for both casual visits and events. Some minor feedback suggests pies might be underdone as it gains popularity.
Important Note
Some customers feel the pizza may be undercooked at times due to increased popularity.
"Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria is mentioned without further detail."
Neutral"This user suggests getting pizza from Angelo's to go, noting that dining in is also an option."
Positive"Another user recommends Angelo's."
Positive"This comment seconds the recommendations for Angelo's and Pops."
Positive"This user feels that Angelo's pies are sometimes underdone since becoming more popular, but still acknowledges its great location."
Neutral"This user agrees that Angelo's on 57th street is a good choice for pizza."
Positive"Angelo's is mentioned as one of the user's favorites for pizza in the area."
Positive"Angelo's is a great option for pizza, though it is more of a sit-down establishment."
Positive"Angelo's on West 57th Street is recommended as a pizza place."
Positive"Halfadash6 considers Angelo's a solid choice for coal oven pizza, noting that while not an iconic slice, it's a New York style and a good option for sit-down dining."
Positive"Killerasp includes Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria in a list of recommendations for pizza and beer outside of Times Square."
Positive"The original poster expresses gratitude for the congratulatory message."
Neutral"The commenter congratulates the original poster, implicitly on their upcoming wedding."
Neutral"The original poster humorously notes that Angelo's is exactly what they are looking for, implying it fits their wedding-related event needs."
Positive"The commenter confirms that Angelo's was a great venue for their wedding welcome dinner, indicating its suitability for similar large events."
Positive"The commenter confirms Angelo's suitability by sharing their positive experience of hosting a wedding welcome dinner there."
Positive"The original poster finds the suggestion of Angelo's on 57th Street as a large party venue to be "super reasonable.""
Positive"The original poster finds Angelo's to be a "super reasonable" suggestion for their event."
Positive"Angelo's on 57th Street is suggested as a venue that can accommodate up to 70 people."
Neutral"Angelo's on 57th Street is suggested as a venue capable of holding up to 70 people."
Positive
