Authentic coal oven pizza, family-style Italian. Great for sit-down or group dining.
A classic New York pizzeria that has stood the test of time, this spot is renowned for its authentic coal oven pizzas. Customers rave about the traditional Italian fare, often recommending it for a sit-down meal or for feeding a crowd. The atmosphere is casual and family-friendly, making it a reliable choice for a satisfying pizza experience.
Specializing in traditional coal oven pizza, this Italian restaurant is a beloved spot for a classic New York slice experience. Many patrons recommend it for its flavorful pizzas and family-friendly atmosphere. However, a few recent comments suggest that the pizza might sometimes be undercooked, possibly due to increased popularity.
"The restaurant is primarily known for its coal oven pizzas, which are frequently recommended by customers. Pasta dishes are also mentioned positively."
Customers largely praise the authentic coal oven pizza and family-style Italian dishes. While generally positive, some recent feedback suggests potential inconsistency with undercooked pies since gaining popularity.
Important Note
One user noted that Angelo's pies are sometimes underdone since becoming more popular.
"This user recommended Angelo's on 58th street if the original poster is looking for a pizza restaurant rather than just a slice shop."
Neutral"This commenter recommended Angelo's on 2nd Ave off 34th."
Neutral"Angelo's Coal Oven Pizza was listed as a place to consider for pizza."
Neutral"Angelo's coal oven pizza is highly recommended for its delicious family-style pizza and pasta dishes, and great service, making it good for groups."
Positive"This commenter recommended Angelo's on 57th as one of their favorites, suggesting it for ordering a pie and sitting down if the user changes their mind about takeout."
Positive"Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria is mentioned without further detail."
Neutral"This user suggests getting pizza from Angelo's to go, noting that dining in is also an option."
Positive"Another user recommends Angelo's."
Positive"This comment seconds the recommendations for Angelo's and Pops."
Positive"This user feels that Angelo's pies are sometimes underdone since becoming more popular, but still acknowledges its great location."
Neutral"This user agrees that Angelo's on 57th street is a good choice for pizza."
Positive"Angelo's is mentioned as one of the user's favorites for pizza in the area."
Positive"Angelo's is a great option for pizza, though it is more of a sit-down establishment."
Positive"Angelo's on West 57th Street is recommended as a pizza place."
Positive"Halfadash6 considers Angelo's a solid choice for coal oven pizza, noting that while not an iconic slice, it's a New York style and a good option for sit-down dining."
Positive"Killerasp includes Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria in a list of recommendations for pizza and beer outside of Times Square."
Positive"The original poster expresses gratitude for the congratulatory message."
Neutral"The commenter congratulates the original poster, implicitly on their upcoming wedding."
Neutral"The original poster humorously notes that Angelo's is exactly what they are looking for, implying it fits their wedding-related event needs."
Positive"The commenter confirms that Angelo's was a great venue for their wedding welcome dinner, indicating its suitability for similar large events."
Positive
