Customers generally have a positive view of the restaurant, highlighting standout dishes like the squid roe and calamari. However, there's a mixed opinion on the squid roe, with one user finding it bland.
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01squid roe2 mentions
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE CRABBY SHACK
This user highly recommends the restaurant's squid roe and fantastic calamari, urging others to try them. They specifically praise the squid roe as a must-try dish.
This user had a less enthusiastic experience, describing the squid roe as only 'okay' and somewhat bland.
This commenter suggested the restaurant as a good seafood option for someone located in Brooklyn.
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Any Good Options For Lobster Rolls
"This commenter suggested Crabby Shack if the original poster is in Brooklyn."
PositiveNov 5, 2025View Comment →
From post: Where Can I Buy Squid Roe
"User2 found The Seafood Shack to be only 'okay' overall, specifically noting that their squid roe was a bit bland."
NegativeMay 21, 2025View Comment →
From post: Where Can I Buy Squid Roe
"User1 highly recommends The Seafood Shack in Brooklyn, praising their squid roe and fantastic calamari as must-try dishes."
PositiveMay 21, 2025View Comment →