TLDR
Charming Eastern European-inspired counter serving life-changing tuna melts, inventive Hungarian crepes, and non-traditional cheesecakes in a cozy Brooklyn setting.
Instagram Posts References
Agi's Counter offers comfort food with a unique twist, as evidenced by their distinctive tuna melt and delightful Hungarian pancake. The atmosphere appears to be a casual counter-service style.
Agi's Counter is a sought-after brunch destination, known for its delicious offerings. The reviewer noted that securing a reservation is advisable, especially for popular items like cheesecake, which unfortunately sold out during their visit. They were impressed by the 'green devils,' describing them as giant, plump, and rich, a must-order dish. The tuna melt was also well-received, with praise for the Pullman bread and alpine cheddar. The McAgi's Hashbrown was generally a hit, though the reviewer desired a crispier texture. The Picansinta, Hungarian crepes filled with port-stewed figs and butter, were described as rich yet light, with a deep sweetness from the figs and port. The reviewer expressed interest in returning for an early dinner to explore more of the menu.
Details
This beloved Crown Heights destination, celebrated for its unique fusion of Hungarian and Jewish-American comfort food, earned a Michelin Bib Gourmand for its exceptional bread-focused dishes [1]. Diners frequently raved about standout items like the tuna melt and inventive crepes, though the restaurant recently closed due to persistent structural issues within the building [2], [3]. While its physical presence has ended, fans fondly remember the establishment for its creative dessert program and vibrant atmosphere [4].
Food Overview
The menu blended Hungarian and Jewish influences, featuring highly recommended staples like the tuna melt—praised for its alpine cheddar and plush pullman bread—and diverse cheesecake offerings [7], [8]. Other standout items included the 'Green Devils' (deviled eggs), heritage pork porterhouse, and delicate crepes, while weekend-only donuts were also a major draw for visitors [5], [8], [9].
Patrons overwhelmingly expressed love for the unique, high-quality menu and dessert program, with many feeling genuine sadness regarding the restaurant's closure [4], [5]. While minor feedback mentioned difficulties reaching staff by phone, the consensus remained that the food was consistently divine [3], [6].
Caveats
The restaurant is now permanently closed due to recurring basement flooding and structural building issues [3], [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About AGI’S COUNTER
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Good Semolina Dumpling Soup Supă Cu GăLușTe In Nyc
"This Hungarian-American restaurant formerly served a soup similar to the user's request, but it featured a lot of dill. The restaurant closed recently with hopes to reopen in a larger space."
PositiveFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"The user provides the closing dates for Agi's Counter: last dinner service on June 14th and last lunch service on July 5th."
NegativeFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"The user observed signs of closure during a recent visit to Agi's Counter, noting a limited menu and checked-out staff, but stated they would support the owner's next venture."
NegativeFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"The user expresses hope that Agi's Counter finds a new location, as they love the owner's food."
PositiveFrom post: Which Restaurants Recently Exceeded Your
"The user elaborates that the building's structural issues, like flooding, are the reason for Agi's Counter's closure, and that the owner is looking for a new space."
Negative