Next.js logo

PETEE'S PIE COMPANY

Last Updated: 8 days ago

Phone: (212) 966-2526

Address: 61 DELANCEY STREET 10002

TLDR

Decadent pies with rave reviews for flavors like chocolate cream and key lime. A must-try for pie lovers.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 9 Reddit comments)

67% Positive22% Neutral11% Negative

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo
Next.js logo

Tags

american 5pie 6pies 2key lime pie 2View All

Neighborhoods

Lower East Side

Instagram Posts References

Summary

Details

If you're craving a slice of homemade goodness, this pie shop is a must-visit. Renowned for their American-style pies, customers rave about the exceptional quality across all flavors. Don't miss out on customer favorites like the decadent chocolate cream pie or the refreshing key lime pie.

Food Overview

This establishment specializes in American-style pies, with customers highly recommending a variety of flavors. The chocolate cream pie, key lime pie, and chess pie are frequently highlighted as must-try items. While most feedback is positive, one user noted a recent pecan pie was overly sweet.

Highlights / Recommended

"Highly recommended are the chocolate cream pie and key lime pie, with the chocolate chess pie also noted for its decadence."

Customer Sentiment

Customers overwhelmingly recommend this pie shop, frequently praising the quality and variety of their pies. Some specific mentions include the chocolate cream pie, key lime pie, and chess pie.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

This user recommends Petee's Pie Company for its great chocolate cream pie.
Petee's Pie is recommended as an excellent option, open until 11 PM. The chocolate chess pie is a go-to for decadence, and the key lime pie is recommended for something refreshing.
This post recommends Peetee's Pie on Delancey for their key lime meringue pie.
Petee's chess pie is recommended, and it's noted that this pie is available at Montague Diner.
One user found the Pecan pie at Petee's pies amazing, but a recent visit was disappointing due to it being too sweet.

Recent Mentions

From post: Best Pecan Desserts

"Initially, this user found Peetie's Pecan pie amazing, but a recent visit was disappointing due to it being too sweet."

Negative
Aug 11, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Pecan Desserts

"This user simply mentions "Peetie's pies" in response to a dessert recommendation."

Neutral
Aug 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Looking For Good Sit Down Dessert Places That Are

"Petee's Pie is recommended as an excellent option, open until 11 PM. The chocolate chess pie is a go-to for decadence, and the key lime pie is recommended for something refreshing."

Positive
Jul 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Your Favorite Dessert Spot In Manhattan

"Petee's Pie Company is recommended for its great chocolate cream pie."

Positive
Jun 4, 2025View Comment →

From post: Favorite Restaurants To Get Just Desserts In

"Recommends Petee's chess pie, which is noted as being available at Montague Diner, implying Petee's Pie Company itself offers good pies."

Positive
May 7, 2025View Comment →

From post: Somewhere To Get Coconut Cake Or Key Lime Pie

"Recommends Peetee's Pie on Delancey for their key lime meringue pie."

Positive
Apr 26, 2025View Comment →

From post: Suggestions For A Fab Nyccentric Cookbook W Lots

"Recommended Petee's Pie cookbook."

Positive
Apr 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: Pi Day

"Not pizza but petees pies always used to do a special on the day"

Neutral
Mar 4, 2025View Comment →