Decadent pies with a perfect crust, from classic key lime to rich chocolate chess. A must-try for any pie enthusiast.
This charming bakery specializes in American-style pies, offering a delightful range of sweet and savory options. Customers rave about the quality of their crust, often described as tender yet substantial and perfectly salted. Many return for their favorites, while others explore the diverse selection, making it a go-to spot for pie lovers.
The restaurant is renowned for its American-style pies, with particular acclaim for the key lime, chocolate chess, and wild blueberry varieties. The crust is consistently praised for its tender, substantial, and well-salted texture, which perfectly balances sweet fillings. While most feedback is highly positive, one user noted a recent pecan pie was too sweet.
"Highly recommended are the key lime pie, chocolate chess pie, wild blueberry pie, and pecan pie. The crust itself is also frequently praised."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pies, with many calling them the best in the city. The quality of the crust is a recurring highlight.
Important Note
One user noted that a recent pecan pie was too sweet, contrasting with their previous positive experience.
"The original poster mentioned Petee's for their cherry pie."
Positive"This user directly stated that Petee's is great."
Positive"The author praised Petee's Pie's crust for its use of pastry flour, making it tender yet substantial and well-salted. They noted that the salted crust balances the sweetness of fillings like pecan."
Positive"The user notes that making a wild blueberry pie at home from Petee's cookbook can be more expensive than buying the pie directly, due to the cost of ingredients like wild blueberries."
Neutral"The user is interested in trying Petee's wild blueberry pie after hearing about it."
Neutral"The user considers the wild blueberry pie from Petee's their favorite birthday treat, even over cake, and has made it a tradition since 2021."
Positive"The commenter suggests trying Petee's Pie for pies."
Positive"Petee's Pie Company on the Lower East Side is highly recommended for dessert or a treat, with the commenter's sister loving it so much she gifts it for Christmas."
Positive"This user, responding to a recommendation for Petee's, advised trying their other pies as well, specifically mentioning the NY cherry and chess pie variations."
Positive"This user strongly recommended Petee's Pie Company on the Lower East Side as the best pie in the city, implicitly including their key lime pie."
Positive"This user strongly disagreed with the praise for Steve's, recommending other spots and mentioning Petee's Pie Company as a delivery alternative that is good, though not the best."
Positive"A user states they always get their pies from Petee's."
Positive"This commenter adds that Petee's has a happy hour with 25% off orders placed on weekdays before a certain time."
Positive"In response to a request for cream pies, this user recommends Petee's."
Positive"This user mentions that Petee's sells pies for $45 and smaller six-inch pies for $20, highlighting the brown butter honey pecan and salty chocolate chess as favorites."
Positive"This user suggests checking out Petee's pies, which are normally around $45 and considered 'so so good,' linking to their Thanksgiving menu."
Positive"The author mentions having cherry pie from Petee's on the same occasion they tried Sugar Sweet Sunshine's coffee pudding."
Positive"This user recommended Petee's Pie for pumpkin pie and also suggested trying a slice of their lavish chocolate crème pie."
Positive"This user recommended Petee's Pies in response to a request for pumpkin pie. They noted that the restaurant sometimes sells out of pies early and mentioned that they always buy a whole pie, though were unsure if slices were available."
Positive"This user specifically recommends the Chocolate Chess pie from Petees Pie."
Positive
