TLDR
Artisanal, "Grandma-coded" American pies featuring a signature well-salted, tender pastry crust. A top-tier local favorite for both fruit-forward and decadent cream-based slices.
Reddit Sentiment for PETEE'S PIE COMPANY(based on 34 Reddit opinions)
Details
Renowned for its meticulously crafted American pies, this shop has become a local staple for those seeking high-quality, "Grandma-coded" desserts [6]. Enthusiasts frequently praise the establishment's signature salted, pastry-flour crust, which offers a delicate yet substantial texture that perfectly balances sweet fillings [27]. While many consider it the premier destination for pie in the city [19], some customers note that specific flavors can occasionally lean too sweet depending on the visit [2].
Food Overview
Specializing in a wide array of American-style pies, the menu is widely celebrated for its balanced flavor profiles, particularly due to a standout, well-salted pastry crust [27]. Highly recommended varieties include wild blueberry [22], [27], salty chocolate chess [3], [15], brown butter honey pecan [4], [15], and their "incredible" ice box pies [35]. Customers are advised that availability can fluctuate and items may sell out early [10].
Highlights / Recommended
"Patrons frequently recommend the salty chocolate chess pie [3], [15], brown butter honey pecan pie [4], [15], and wild blueberry pie [22], [27]. The ice box pies are also highlighted as a standout menu item [35]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •wild blueberry pie(4)
- •chess pie(2)
- •pecan pie(2)
- •pie crust(2)
Caveats
The shop can experience shortages, and popular pies sometimes sell out early in the day [10].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PETEE'S PIE COMPANY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"The commenter considers all their pies to be excellent, with a specific preference for the banana crème."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"The commenter notes that the shop's ice box pies are incredible."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"They prefer this place over Blackbirds due to having a more flavorful crust."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"The user suggests checking out this pie shop."
PositiveFrom post: Lower East Side Dinner Before Attaboy
"Peetee's Pie Company is suggested as a dessert option."
PositiveFrom post: Searching For A Cherry Pie
"The user suggested going to Pete's Pie Company in Nolita, stating that it is unmatched in Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: Cherry Dessertsdrinks
"The original poster mentioned Petee's for their cherry pie."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pecan Pie In Nyc For Piday
"This user directly stated that Petee's is great."
PositiveFrom post: Best Pecan Pie In Nyc For Piday
"The author praised Petee's Pie's crust for its use of pastry flour, making it tender yet substantial and well-salted. They noted that the salted crust balances the sweetness of fillings like pecan."
PositiveFrom post: Two Little Red Hens Ill Never Stop Asking
"The user notes that making a wild blueberry pie at home from Petee's cookbook can be more expensive than buying the pie directly, due to the cost of ingredients like wild blueberries."
NeutralFrom post: Two Little Red Hens Ill Never Stop Asking
"The user is interested in trying Petee's wild blueberry pie after hearing about it."
NeutralFrom post: Two Little Red Hens Ill Never Stop Asking
"The user considers the wild blueberry pie from Petee's their favorite birthday treat, even over cake, and has made it a tradition since 2021."
PositiveFrom post: Only Here 3 Days Need Pizza Breakfast Lunchdinner
"The commenter suggests trying Petee's Pie for pies."
PositiveFrom post: Great Eats For A Picky Teen
"Petee's Pie Company on the Lower East Side is highly recommended for dessert or a treat, with the commenter's sister loving it so much she gifts it for Christmas."
PositiveFrom post: Best Key Lime Pie In Nyc
"This user, responding to a recommendation for Petee's, advised trying their other pies as well, specifically mentioning the NY cherry and chess pie variations."
PositiveFrom post: Best Key Lime Pie In Nyc
"This user strongly recommended Petee's Pie Company on the Lower East Side as the best pie in the city, implicitly including their key lime pie."
PositiveFrom post: Best Key Lime Pie In Nyc
"This user strongly disagreed with the praise for Steve's, recommending other spots and mentioning Petee's Pie Company as a delivery alternative that is good, though not the best."
PositiveFrom post: Thanksgiving Pie Prices
"A user states they always get their pies from Petee's."
PositiveFrom post: Thanksgiving Pie Prices
"This commenter adds that Petee's has a happy hour with 25% off orders placed on weekdays before a certain time."
PositiveFrom post: Thanksgiving Pie Prices
"In response to a request for cream pies, this user recommends Petee's."
Positive