TLDR
Exceptional, well-salted pastry crusts elevate these legendary slices. Unmatched, 'Grandma-coded' American pies that frequently sell out.
Details
Renowned for its meticulously crafted, salted pastry crusts, this bakery is frequently cited as the premier destination for pie in New York City [14], [25], [29]. Patrons consistently praise the exceptional balance of flavors, particularly in fruit-forward offerings like wild blueberry and cherry, which are never overly sweet [21]. Beyond their signature fruit pies, the shop's rich chocolate and cream-based varieties are highly celebrated, earning a reputation as a must-visit indulgence [6], [26], [27], [28].
Food Overview
The menu features a wide array of American-style pies, with particular acclaim given to the salted pastry crust made with high-quality flour [21]. Recommended flavors include the wild blueberry, cherry, salty chocolate chess, and brown butter honey pecan pies [10], [21]. Customers also speak highly of their ice box pies and the exceptional whipped cream [26], [27]. Some note that popular flavors can sell out early, and others mention that while high-quality, the shop is generally priced around $45 for a whole pie [5], [7], [10].
Highly recommended favorites include the wild blueberry, salty chocolate chess, and brown butter honey pecan pies [10], [21]. The banana crème and chocolate silk pies, paired with their signature whipped cream, are also widely praised [26], [27], [28].
Patrons express overwhelming loyalty, with many considering the shop's offerings the best in the city [14], [29]. The feedback is consistently glowing, with the quality of the crust and fillings frequently highlighted as standout features [21], [26].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01wild blueberry pie4 mentions
- 02chess pie2 mentions
- 03pecan pie2 mentions
- 04pie crust2 mentions
Caveats
Popular pie flavors can sell out quickly, so early arrival or ordering ahead is advised [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PETEE'S PIE COMPANY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: If You Could Only Pick One What Is Your Favorite
"The user enjoys their chocolate silk pie and specifically praises the quality of the whipped cream."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Recs For A Couple Days In The Les One
"Regarded as arguably the best pie in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"The commenter considers all their pies to be excellent, with a specific preference for the banana crème."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"The commenter notes that the shop's ice box pies are incredible."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"They prefer this place over Blackbirds due to having a more flavorful crust."
Positive