Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (212) 966-2526
Address: 61 DELANCEY STREET 10002
A slice of heaven! Pies that are a must-try, from key lime meringue to decadent chocolate cream.
Known for its exceptional pies, this establishment offers a delightful range of sweet and savory options that have garnered significant praise. Customers rave about the quality and variety, often highlighting specific flavors like key lime meringue and chocolate cream pie. Whether you're seeking a classic American dessert or a unique treat, this pie company promises a memorable culinary experience.
The restaurant is highly acclaimed for its pies, with customers frequently recommending various flavors. Popular choices include key lime meringue pie and chocolate cream pie, with the chocolate chess pie also receiving specific praise for its decadent taste. While most feedback is positive, one customer noted that their pecan pie was too sweet on a recent visit.
"Customers highly recommend the key lime meringue pie and the chocolate cream pie. The chocolate chess pie is also frequently praised for its decadent flavor, and the brown butter pecan pie is a noted favorite."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pies, with many highlighting specific flavors as exceptional and recommending the establishment for its dessert offerings.
Important Note
One customer reported that the pecan pie was too sweet on a recent visit, contrasting with earlier positive experiences.
"The commenter enjoys the salted chocolate chess pie from Petee's, noting a recent observation about potential price or size changes."
Positive"The commenter loves Petee's and often gets their brown butter pecan pie a la mode."
Positive"The commenter recommends a slice of salty chocolate chess or sour cherry pie from Petee's Pie."
Positive"Initially, this user found Peetie's Pecan pie amazing, but a recent visit was disappointing due to it being too sweet."
Negative"This user simply mentions "Peetie's pies" in response to a dessert recommendation."
Neutral"Petee's Pie is recommended as an excellent option, open until 11 PM. The chocolate chess pie is a go-to for decadence, and the key lime pie is recommended for something refreshing."
Positive"Petee's Pie Company is recommended for its great chocolate cream pie."
Positive"Recommends Petee's chess pie, which is noted as being available at Montague Diner, implying Petee's Pie Company itself offers good pies."
Positive"Recommends Peetee's Pie on Delancey for their key lime meringue pie."
Positive"Recommended Petee's Pie cookbook."
Positive"Not pizza but petees pies always used to do a special on the day"
Neutral
