TLDR
A highly regarded bagel shop in Brooklyn, often cited as one of the best in the area. Known for unique flavors like Zaatar bagels [2].
Reddit Sentiment for OLDE BROOKLYN BAGEL SHOPPE(based on 12 Reddit opinions)
Details
This Brooklyn bagel shop is frequently recommended as a top-tier spot for bagels in the area, often drawing comparisons to other local favorites [5], [6], [7], [8]. While many patrons find it to be a solid choice, some believe it stands a step above competitors like Bagel Pub [7], [8]. However, not all feedback is positive, with one user strongly advising against it due to concerns about sanitation [11].
Food Overview
The shop is primarily known for its bagels, with a unique Zaatar flavor being specifically mentioned as a highlight [2]. Some customers suggest preparing the Zaatar bagel with cream cheese and falafel [3]. There's also an inquiry about a truffle bagel option [4]. While generally well-regarded, one review strongly criticizes the establishment as 'awful and unsanitary' [11].
The Zaatar bagel is a standout unique flavor that customers enjoy, often recommended with cream cheese and falafel.
Customer sentiment is generally positive, with many recommending the shop for its bagels and considering it a top contender in the area. However, there are strong dissenting opinions regarding cleanliness and overall quality [11].
Caveats
One user strongly advises against the restaurant, describing it as 'awful and unsanitary' [11]. Another review found the everything bagel to be too 'over-everythinged' and salty [9].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About OLDE BROOKLYN BAGEL SHOPPE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Bagelsbreakfast Near Barclays My Wife Put Me
"Olde Brooklyn bagel is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Best Bagelsbreakfast Near Barclays My Wife Put Me
"This user considers Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shop to be really solid, but less good than Bagel Pub. They also find Gertie's fine but their everything bagel is too 'over-everythinged' and salty, and Bergen Bagels is decent."
NeutralFrom post: Best Bagelsbreakfast Near Barclays My Wife Put Me
"This user states to stay away from Olde Brooklyn Bagel."
NegativeFrom post: Best Bagelsbreakfast Near Barclays My Wife Put Me
"This user strongly advises against Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shop, calling it 'awful and unsanitary' and suggesting it's for those unfamiliar with good bagels."
NegativeFrom post: Best Bagelsbreakfast Near Barclays My Wife Put Me
"This user believes Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shop is better than Bagel Pub."
Positive