TLDR
Iconic Nonna-style slices and dependable late-night eats in Manhattan. A polarizing local staple often debated as either the city's best or merely average.
Reddit Sentiment for BLEECKER STREET PIZZA(based on 49 Reddit opinions)
Details
Known for its highly debated but beloved status among New Yorkers, this spot is frequently cited for its iconic Nonna-style slices [12], [13], [14]. While some enthusiasts consider it the best pizza in the city [22], others argue that quality has declined in recent years, labeling it an average or overrated experience [5], [6]. Despite these conflicting opinions, the restaurant remains a staple for many, offering reliable options like the white basil slice and specialized gluten-free pies [20], [39].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic Italian-American pizza, with the Nonna and Nonna Maria slices receiving frequent acclaim for their quality [12], [13], [16]. Other popular items include the white basil slice [20] and chicken or meatball parm heroes [2], though some diners find standard cheese slices and garlic knots to be merely average [13], [33]. The restaurant also accommodates dietary needs with gluten-free personal pizzas prepared in dedicated pans [39].
Caveats
Quality is reportedly inconsistent, with several patrons noting a decline since the original ownership changed [6], [17]. Additionally, some diners find the basic cheese slices to be average, particularly when reheated [13], [33].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BLEECKER STREET PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Celiac Safe Restaurant Recommendations For Trip
"The restaurant prepares gluten-free personal pizzas in dedicated pans to prevent cross-contamination."
PositiveFrom post: Where Do You Go For A Healthylow Cal Item Or Treat
"Mentioned as a spot for pizza, though the user warns it may be calorie-dense."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Still Get Great Knots Slice Joints
"Briefly mentioned alongside other pizza spots."
NeutralFrom post: Need A Reco For Your Favorite Pizza In Soho That
"Considered a worthy place."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"This commenter suggests that the pizza could be from Bleecker Street Pizza, mentioning the brown plates and similar slice size."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"This commenter believes the pizza in the photo is from Bleecker Street Pizza, specifically their 'Anna Maria' slice."
NeutralFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"While acknowledging the rudeness of some comments, this user suggests Bleecker Street Pizza as a possibility, noting that while some say they cut their basil, they have personally experienced both cut and uncut basil on slices there."
NeutralFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"This commenter states they had a pie from Bleecker Street Pizza recently that looked exactly like the one in the original post, despite prior comments suggesting otherwise."
NegativeFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter notes that Bleecker Street Pizza cuts their basil for their fresh mozzarella slice, which differs from the basil pictured, but acknowledges their 'Caprese' slice also has basil."
NeutralFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"This commenter believes the pizza could be from Bleecker Street Pizza, noting they use brown paper plates, although they feel the pictured slice might not be up to Bleecker's usual standards."
NeutralFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter suggests the pizza could be from Bleecker Street Pizza, specifically their 'Nona Maria' slice."
NeutralFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user mentioned that Aria Nova on Bleecker Street is better than Bleeker Street Pizza."
NegativeFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"Replying to a comment about pricing, this user clarified that basic cheese slices are $4 and garlic knots are $3.50, but insisted their mushroom slice was amazing."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user stated that the garlic knots at Bleeker Street Pizza were average, and the basic cheese slices were $4, considered average at best. They also noted the place is open later than most."
NegativeFrom post: What Is The Most Overrated Or Overpriced Piece Of
"This user highly recommended Bleeker Street Pizza, calling it 'absolute perfection' and 'extremely reasonable,' citing an example of four slices and garlic knots for $13."
PositiveFrom post: My Almost Month Long Food Journey Through Nyc
"In response to the 'wild take' comment, the author playfully acknowledged their strong opinion on Bleecker Street pizza."
NeutralFrom post: My Almost Month Long Food Journey Through Nyc
"This commenter found the bagel takes debatable but defended the opinion on L'Industrie, noting its quality has declined and it's now just an average slice unless there's no line."
NegativeFrom post: My Almost Month Long Food Journey Through Nyc
"This commenter playfully teased the original poster about their strong opinion on Bleecker Street pizza."
NeutralFrom post: My Almost Month Long Food Journey Through Nyc
"This commenter agreed with the original poster's list, except for the strong opinion about Bleecker Street pizza."
NeutralFrom post: My Almost Month Long Food Journey Through Nyc
"This commenter found the claim that Bleecker Street is the best New York pizza to be a 'wild' take."
Neutral