Last Updated: 24 days ago
Phone: (212) 594-7817
Address: 69 7 AVENUE SOUTH 10014
Best pizza in NYC, 3 years running! Don't miss the Nonna Maria slice.
This West Village staple is a must-visit for pizza lovers, consistently drawing crowds with its highly acclaimed slices. It's been recognized multiple times for its exceptional pizza, even earning the title of 'best pizza in NYC' by The Food Network. The Nonna Maria slice is a standout, praised for its unique flavor and execution, though some argue it's just one of many great options in the area.
The pizza here is the star, with the Nonna Maria slice receiving widespread acclaim and multiple 'best pizza' awards. Other popular options include the Grandma slice and garlic knots. While most diners rave about the quality, a few commenters find it to be average or overrated compared to other NYC pizzerias.
"The Nonna Maria slice is consistently highlighted as a must-try, often cited as one of the best in the city. Other recommended items include the Grandma slice and garlic knots."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pizza, especially the Nonna Maria slice, with many considering it among the city's best. While most feedback is positive, a few dissenting opinions suggest it can be average or overrated.
Important Note
There is some debate among commenters about whether Bleecker Street Pizza is overrated or if it's mistakenly chosen over John's of Bleecker Street. One commenter noted that the pizzeria only sells full pies, which may be a consideration for some visitors.
"This user advised against Bleecker St Pizza, stating it has been exceedingly average for over a decade. They did note that their chicken and meatball parm heroes are still on point."
Negative"The user mentioned Bleecker Street Pizza as part of their 5-day NYC itinerary."
Neutral"The grandma slice at Unregular Pizza in Union Square was tried and loved, considered on par with Bleecker Street Pizza and better than John's of Bleecker for the reviewer's taste."
Positive"The Nonna Maria slice at Bleecker Street Pizza in the West Village is highly recommended, as is their plain cheese slice. The depth of tomato flavor, fresh mozzarella, and parmesan are notable."
Positive"This commenter agreed that the Nonna slice from Bleecker Street Pizza is very good."
Positive"The commenter planned to have a slice of Nonna pizza from Bleecker Street Pizza as part of their day of last meals."
Positive"Bleecker St Pizza is included in a list of recommended slice joints for a pizza crawl."
Neutral"The user notes that Bleecker Street (likely Bleecker St Pizza) is conveniently located less than two minutes' walk from Marie's Crisis for a quick slice."
Neutral"The user recommends Bleecker St Pizza as a reliable option for a quick late-night slice, noting its location in the West Village."
Positive"Bleecker Street Pizza was the commenter's favorite pizza spot during their visit."
Positive"The commenter asserts that Bleecker St Pizza is one of the most overrated pizza spots in NYC, along with Artichoke Basille's."
Negative"The user highly recommends Bleecker Street Pizza, stating it is 'way better' than John's."
Positive"The user states John's is not good, L'Industrie is better, and so is Bleecker St nonna slice."
Positive"The author prefers Bleecker Street Pizza for a classic slice, favoring their "Nonna" and "Red Sicilian" options due to the excellent sauce. They also appreciate that the pizzeria accepts cards and offers good garlic rolls."
Positive"The user decides to visit L'Industrie instead of Bleecker St Pizza for their fiancé's experience, saving Bleecker St for a future trip."
Neutral"The commenter strongly supports the suggestion of L'Industrie for pizza in the West Village, preferring it over Joe's or Bleecker St."
Negative"The commenter strongly recommends L'Industrie for pizza, suggesting it as a superior alternative to Bleecker St Pizza or Joe's Pizza."
Negative"JayMoots suggests that the best approach is to try both Joe's Pizza and Bleecker Street Pizza, specifically recommending a nonna maria slice from Bleecker."
Neutral"One-Plantain-9454 enthusiastically agrees with the recommendation for the Nonna slice from Bleecker Street Pizza."
Positive"BumFroe states a strong preference for Joe's Pizza over Bleecker Street Pizza."
Negative
