Last Updated: ~1 month ago
Phone: (212) 594-7817
Address: 69 7 AVENUE SOUTH 10014
Award-winning NYC pizza! Famous for its #1 ranked Nonna Maria slice. A must-try West Village slice shop.
This West Village institution is a must-visit for pizza lovers, consistently drawing crowds with its award-winning pies. Since its opening, it has solidified its reputation as a top-tier pizza destination in NYC. It's a beloved spot for both locals and tourists seeking a classic New York pizza experience.
This pizzeria is celebrated for its exceptional pizza, with the Nonna Maria slice receiving widespread acclaim and multiple 'best pizza' awards. Other popular choices include the Grandma slice and garlic knots. While most reviews are glowing, a minority of customers find the pizza to be average or not living up to the hype, with some noting a decline in quality over the years.
"The Nonna Maria slice is highly recommended and has won numerous awards. Other praised items include the Grandma slice and garlic knots."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pizza, particularly the acclaimed Nonna Maria slice, and many consider it a top-tier, must-visit spot. While most feedback is positive, a few find it to be average or overrated.
Important Note
Some users feel the quality has declined over the years or find it to be overrated, with a few suggesting other pizzerias are superior.
"This commenter recommended the 'Nonna Maria' slice at Bleecker Street Pizza as the best."
Positive"The author enjoyed a white basil slice and a margarita slice. The cheese on the white pizza was praised, though the slice was a bit oily. The margarita was standard and yummy. It was a quick stop they would revisit."
Positive"Bleecker street p.zzA is mentioned as a late-night option."
Neutral"This user stated that the 'Nonna' slice is the best, and the cheese is excellent when fresh. They noted that reheated cheese slices are just okay."
Positive"The user expressed enjoyment of the pizza with a simple positive comment."
Positive"The user simply expressed that Bleecker Street Pizza is their favorite."
Positive"Had a comparably good slice at Bleecker Street Pizza over Thanksgiving weekend to Joe's, finding them on par."
Neutral"Recommended Bleecker Street Pizza and mentioned Taco Mahal next door as a good option if hungry."
Positive"Likes Bleecker Street Pizza but feels the quality has changed in recent years."
Neutral"Stated the Nonna slice at Bleecker Street Pizza is preferred, and Joe's slice is too thin."
Positive"Stated that Bleecker Street Pizza's quality has declined."
Negative"Recommended the Nonna Maria slice at Bleecker Street Pizza."
Neutral"Prefers Bleecker Street Pizza between the two options, also mentioning L'Industrie and Mama's Too as better alternatives."
Negative"Suggests to lose Bleecker Street Pizza from the list."
Negative"Bleecker Street Pizza is considered alright."
Neutral"Recommends skipping Bleecker Street Pizza and suggests several other pizzerias instead."
Negative"Bleecker Street Pizza was once good, but its quality declined after the owners sold and the store expanded. Nolita Pizza is suggested as its successor."
Negative"Bleecker Street Pizza is considered extremely average, with the hype possibly stemming from confusion with John's of Bleecker."
Negative"The user finds Bleecker Street Pizza to be extremely average and mediocre, suggesting it's not particularly special."
Negative"Bleecker Street Pizza is recommended to be skipped as it is very overrated."
Negative
