NYC's #1 Nona Maria slice, award-winning pizza w/ a classic crust. A must-try West Village pie!
This West Village pizza joint has earned accolades for its award-winning Nonna Maria slice, recognized as the best in NYC by the Food Network. While many rave about its unique pizzas and classic New York style, some find it to be a bit overrated compared to other local favorites.
This establishment is celebrated for its pizza, particularly the Nonna Maria slice, which has received significant recognition, including being named the best pizza in NYC by the Food Network for three consecutive years. While many patrons highlight the unique flavors and classic crust, some reviewers find the pizza to be average and suggest that its popularity may be inflated.
"The Nonna Maria slice is frequently recommended and has been recognized as the best pizza in NYC. Other praised items include the Grandma slice, Red Sicilian slice, and garlic knots."
Customers are divided, with many praising the Nonna Maria slice and classic crust as exceptional. However, a portion of diners feel the pizza is average or overrated, especially when compared to other renowned pizzerias.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest that the quality may have declined over time, or that it is overrated and easily confused with other establishments like John's of Bleecker Street. One opinion states they only sell full pies, which might be a consideration for some.
"Suggests to lose Bleecker Street Pizza from the list."
Negative"Bleecker Street Pizza is considered alright."
Neutral"Recommends skipping Bleecker Street Pizza and suggests several other pizzerias instead."
Negative"Bleecker Street Pizza was once good, but its quality declined after the owners sold and the store expanded. Nolita Pizza is suggested as its successor."
Negative"Bleecker Street Pizza is considered extremely average, with the hype possibly stemming from confusion with John's of Bleecker."
Negative"The user finds Bleecker Street Pizza to be extremely average and mediocre, suggesting it's not particularly special."
Negative"Bleecker Street Pizza is recommended to be skipped as it is very overrated."
Negative"Bleecker Street Pizza is grouped with Joe's and East Village Pizza as tasting nearly indistinguishable and generic."
Neutral"The commenter hasn't had baked ziti in years as they no longer live in the neighborhood, but stated that Bleecker Street Pizza's baked ziti was phenomenal and hoped it still was."
Positive"This user advised against Bleecker St Pizza, stating it has been exceedingly average for over a decade. They did note that their chicken and meatball parm heroes are still on point."
Negative"The user mentioned Bleecker Street Pizza as part of their 5-day NYC itinerary."
Neutral"The grandma slice at Unregular Pizza in Union Square was tried and loved, considered on par with Bleecker Street Pizza and better than John's of Bleecker for the reviewer's taste."
Positive"The Nonna Maria slice at Bleecker Street Pizza in the West Village is highly recommended, as is their plain cheese slice. The depth of tomato flavor, fresh mozzarella, and parmesan are notable."
Positive"This commenter agreed that the Nonna slice from Bleecker Street Pizza is very good."
Positive"The commenter planned to have a slice of Nonna pizza from Bleecker Street Pizza as part of their day of last meals."
Positive"Bleecker St Pizza is included in a list of recommended slice joints for a pizza crawl."
Neutral"The user notes that Bleecker Street (likely Bleecker St Pizza) is conveniently located less than two minutes' walk from Marie's Crisis for a quick slice."
Neutral"The user recommends Bleecker St Pizza as a reliable option for a quick late-night slice, noting its location in the West Village."
Positive"Bleecker Street Pizza was the commenter's favorite pizza spot during their visit."
Positive"The commenter asserts that Bleecker St Pizza is one of the most overrated pizza spots in NYC, along with Artichoke Basille's."
Negative
