Award-winning NYC pizza spot, famous for its #1 Nonna Maria slice. Get your classic NY slice fix here!
Nestled in the West Village, this pizzeria has earned a reputation for serving up some of the city's best pizza. It's particularly celebrated for its Nonna Maria slice, a pie that has consistently been recognized as top-tier, even earning accolades from sources like Food Network and Trip Advisor. Beyond this standout, the menu offers classic New York-style slices with a satisfying crust, making it a go-to spot for both locals and visitors seeking an authentic slice experience.
This pizzeria specializes in New York-style pizza. The Nonna Maria slice is a standout, frequently cited as a must-try and a contender for the best in the city. Other popular choices include classic cheese and grandma slices, as well as garlic knots. While most feedback is positive, a few reviewers feel the quality has become average or that other pizzerias offer a better experience.
"The Nonna Maria slice is consistently highlighted as a must-try and is often considered the best offering. Other recommended items include the Grandma slice and garlic knots."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pizza, particularly the Nonna Maria slice, with many calling it the best in NYC. While most reviews are positive, a few mention that quality may have declined over the years or that other spots might be superior.
Important Note
Some reviewers suggest that the quality of the pizza may have declined over the years, or that it is not as exceptional as its reputation implies, with a few comparing it unfavorably to other popular pizzerias.
"In response to the 'wild take' comment, the author playfully acknowledged their strong opinion on Bleecker Street pizza."
Neutral"This commenter found the bagel takes debatable but defended the opinion on L'Industrie, noting its quality has declined and it's now just an average slice unless there's no line."
Negative"This commenter playfully teased the original poster about their strong opinion on Bleecker Street pizza."
Neutral"This commenter agreed with the original poster's list, except for the strong opinion about Bleecker Street pizza."
Neutral"This commenter found the claim that Bleecker Street is the best New York pizza to be a 'wild' take."
Neutral"This commenter agreed that L'Industrie's quality has significantly declined."
Negative"This commenter recommended Sunnyside pizza off 40th st station and Carmines in East Williamsburg as the best pizza in the city."
Neutral"This commenter noted that L'Industrie's quality has dropped since expanding, now offering just a fine slice if there's no line."
Negative"Regarding pizza, the author found Mamas Too outstanding, John's on Bleecker great, but was very let down by L'Industrie, considering it average."
Positive"The author declared Bleecker Street Pizza the best pizza in NYC ('FIGHT ME IDC') and also tried Mamas Too and John's on Bleecker."
Positive"This commenter recommended the 'Nonna Maria' slice at Bleecker Street Pizza as the best."
Positive"The author enjoyed a white basil slice and a margarita slice. The cheese on the white pizza was praised, though the slice was a bit oily. The margarita was standard and yummy. It was a quick stop they would revisit."
Positive"Bleecker street p.zzA is mentioned as a late-night option."
Neutral"This user stated that the 'Nonna' slice is the best, and the cheese is excellent when fresh. They noted that reheated cheese slices are just okay."
Positive"The user expressed enjoyment of the pizza with a simple positive comment."
Positive"The user simply expressed that Bleecker Street Pizza is their favorite."
Positive"Had a comparably good slice at Bleecker Street Pizza over Thanksgiving weekend to Joe's, finding them on par."
Neutral"Recommended Bleecker Street Pizza and mentioned Taco Mahal next door as a good option if hungry."
Positive"Likes Bleecker Street Pizza but feels the quality has changed in recent years."
Neutral"Stated the Nonna slice at Bleecker Street Pizza is preferred, and Joe's slice is too thin."
Positive
