Euro-Summer vibes meet Italian cuisine in the West Village, with standout pasta for some but overpriced and mediocre food for others.
This West Village establishment offers a distinctly European-inspired ambiance, evoking a Euro-Summer vibe with its elegant bar and lively outdoor dining. It's positioned as a spot for a vibrant dining experience, particularly for Italian cuisine. However, opinions are split regarding the culinary offerings. While some highlight the pasta as a standout, enjoying it immensely, a significant portion of diners find the food to be average at best and question the value proposition due to high prices. The restaurant seems to excel more in its atmosphere and aesthetic than in consistently delivering on food quality, making it a place that might impress with its setting but could leave some diners wanting more from the menu.
The cuisine is primarily Italian, with a focus on pasta. While some patrons rave about the pasta and describe it as amazing, others find the food to be only 'mid' or not good, and consider it to be ridiculously overpriced for the quality. There isn't a clear consensus on specific dishes to avoid, but the general sentiment suggests a potential inconsistency in food quality.
"Pasta dishes are highlighted as a potentially amazing part of the menu, with one user specifically mentioning a positive experience with them."
Overall, customer sentiment towards this restaurant is mixed, with a notable divide between those who praise its unique ambiance and those who are disappointed with the food quality and pricing. Some diners find the experience delightful, especially the pasta dishes, while others feel the food is mediocre and overpriced.
Important Note
The restaurant is noted for being ridiculously overpriced with mid food at best by some customers, while others praise its pasta dishes.
"iamintothat2 describes Saint Theo's as ridiculously overpriced with mid food at best."
Negative"Lfs1983 disagrees with negative opinions of Saint Theo's, stating that two of their girlfriends and they had amazing pasta there."
Positive"supremekeyboard states that the food at Saint Theo's is just not good, in response to a question asking why to avoid it."
Negative"eringobrah21 recommends avoiding Saint Theo's in the West Village."
Negative"Lists St. Theos as a potential option."
Neutral"While recommending other West Village spots, the user advises skipping Saint Theos."
Negative
