TLDR
An NYC staple serving up indulgent cake slices and treats since 2005. Best known for pumpkin spice and strawberry flavors, though consistency can vary.
Reddit Sentiment for LITTLE CUPCAKE BAKESHOP(based on 33 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Little Cupcake Bakeshop, an NYC institution since 2005, is currently celebrated for having the 'hottest cake slice' in the city. The pumpkin spice cake slice is specifically called out for its excellent frosting-to-cake ratio, fluffy texture, perfect pumpkin flavor with just the right amount of spice, and a light cream cheese frosting that doesn't overpower the cake.
Details
A staple of the New York City dessert scene since 2005, this family-owned bakery is frequently celebrated for its wide variety of indulgent cake slices [1]. While many patrons adore the signature pumpkin spice and strawberry cakes [1], [15], the establishment faces ongoing criticism regarding the inconsistent texture of its baked goods and the extreme sweetness of its frosting [20], [22]. Opinions on quality remain deeply polarized, with some visitors enjoying the rich flavors and others noting concerns about dryness and value [20], [23], [26].
Food Overview
The bakery offers a broad selection of American-style sweets, including popular items like the Brooklyn blackout cake and various cupcakes [2], [6], [10]. While the pumpkin spice cake is praised for its excellent frosting-to-cake ratio [1], other items such as the chocolate cake have been criticized for being dry [22]. Customers should be aware that the offerings are generally very sweet, with some gluten-free options available depending on the day [13], [18].
The Brooklyn blackout cake is frequently highlighted as a standout, alongside the pumpkin spice cake slice and the banana chocolate chip cupcake [1], [6], [10], [27].
Customer feedback is highly divided, ranging from praise for the variety of treats to frustration over inconsistencies in quality, perceived over-sweetness, and occasional service issues regarding pricing [12], [20], [24].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01blackout cake2 mentions
- 02chocolate cake2 mentions
Caveats
Patrons note that the cakes can be quite sweet, and consistency is often described as hit or miss, with some reporting dry textures in their orders [20], [24], [25].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About LITTLE CUPCAKE BAKESHOP
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: If You Could Only Pick One What Is Your Favorite
"The user highlights their banana chocolate chip cupcake as a top sweet."
PositiveFrom post: Tasting And Ranking Of Seven Chocolate Cakes In
"Had a similarly disappointing impression of their chocolate cake."
NegativeFrom post: Tasting And Ranking Of Seven Chocolate Cakes In
"Suggests it might have been an off day but acknowledges the reputation for dryness."
NeutralFrom post: Tasting And Ranking Of Seven Chocolate Cakes In
"Agrees with the negative assessment."
NegativeFrom post: Tasting And Ranking Of Seven Chocolate Cakes In
"Notes that the 'hostess slice' is better than the blackout cake."
Neutral