TLDR
Cult-favorite dry-aged beef burgers and standout pizzas that consistently outshine famous NYC rivals.
Instagram Posts References
Emily is home to the 'Emmy Burger', a cult-favorite made with Pat LaFrieda dry-aged beef, Emmy sauce, caramelized onions, and Grafton cheddar on a pretzel bun. It's described as rich, juicy, and packed with flavor, potentially the best on the list.
The user had initially intended to dine at Emily but was deterred by a 90-minute wait, leading them to seek out another restaurant.
Details
Renowned for its cult-favorite Emmy Burger, this spot serves up a rich, juicy patty featuring Pat LaFrieda dry-aged beef, caramelized onions, and Grafton cheddar on a pretzel bun [1]. Beyond the famous burger, the menu features standout pizzas that have been known to outperform other acclaimed NYC pizzerias [2]. It is frequently recommended as an excellent choice for celebratory group dinners and provides strong value, earning a spot on the Michelin Bib Gourmand list [3], [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American-style burgers and highly praised pizzas, with the 'Emily Pizza'—featuring white sauce, pistachio, hot honey, and mozzarella—often cited as a highlight [2]. The Emmy Burger is widely considered a top-tier destination dish, though one diner noted a less favorable experience where the burger felt drowned in sauce [1], [6]. Waffle fries are also available and have been described as a delicious accompaniment [7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About EMILY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking To Go For A Family Dinner Focused On
"User had an okay experience, noting the burgers were salty and drowned in sauce."
NegativeFrom post: Looking To Go For A Family Dinner Focused On
"Mentioned as a place the user wants to try."
NeutralFrom post: Seeking Economical Dinner Places 4560 Pp In
"Recommended as a place to check out for better price points via the Michelin Bib Gourmand list."
PositiveFrom post: New York Food Adventures During The World Cup
"The pizza was a surprising star of the meal, even outperforming other famous NYC pizza spots."
PositiveFrom post: What Burgers Should I Eat During A Week Off From
"Suggested that a lack of long lines or exclusivity might contribute to Emily's decreased popularity on Reddit, contrasting it with the 'mediocre bar food' trend."
Neutral