Detroit-style pizza w/ unique toppings & a highly-debated, cult-favorite burger. Also, an anchovy-heavy Caesar salad.
Known for its distinctive 'Detroit-style' pizza, this eatery offers a unique take on a classic. While the pizza garners praise, the burgers are a subject of mixed reviews, with some calling them exceptional and others finding them disappointing or too rich. The establishment also serves other American fare, including a Caesar salad that's noted for its strong, anchovy-forward flavor.
The restaurant is best known for its 'Detroit-style' pizza, which is described as a unique and delicious offering. The burgers are a significant point of discussion, with some patrons considering them among the best in NYC, while others find them to be too buttery, heavy, or disappointing compared to past experiences. A Caesar salad is also mentioned, noted for its strong anchovy flavor.
"The 'Colony Pizza' and 'Detroit-style Pizza' are highly recommended. The 'Emmy Burger' is frequently mentioned, with many considering it exceptional, although there are also negative reviews."
Customer feedback is largely positive, with many praising the unique Detroit-style pizza and some hailing the burger as the best they've ever had. However, there are also a significant number of reviews finding the burger disappointing or overly rich.
Important Note
Some patrons note that the restaurant can be pricey, and there are mixed reviews on the burger's quality, with some experiencing a decline in taste over time. One reviewer also mentioned finding a live bug in a salad appetizer.
"This commenter expresses love for the burger at Emily, stating it's a place they enjoyed."
Positive"This restaurant was mentioned as a recommendation."
Positive"This user states that the Emmy Burger at Pizza Loves Emily is the best burger they've ever had, despite its $31 price tag."
Positive"This restaurant is suggested as a suitable option for the user's group and budget."
Positive"Emily is listed among the top 5 favorite classic burgers."
Positive"This user loved Emily but found it to be quite pricey."
Positive"This user did not like the sauce at Emily."
Negative"Emily's West Village is suggested as a place with a top-notch burger, though they also focus on pizza. The user also noted nearby bars like Little Branch for after."
Positive"A user praises Emily West Village's Caesar salad for its fresh, crunchy whole leaf romaine, calling it a 'deconstructed' but favorite version."
Positive"A user loves the Caesar salad at Emily West Village but notes its strong anchovy flavor, appealing to those who enjoy it."
Positive"Emily is described as fantastic, particularly appealing to New Yorkers who may not frequently encounter Chicago or Detroit-style pizza."
Positive"Emily in West Village is recommended for its good Detroit-style pizza and is noted for having one of the best burgers in NYC."
Positive"Emily was suggested as a potential restaurant for a family lunch near Barclays Center."
Neutral"A user noted that Emily used to only make 25 burgers per night, requiring early arrival."
Neutral"The user plans to try Emily's Emmy Burger on their next visit to NYC."
Neutral"A user highly praised the Emmy Burger at Emily's Brooklyn location as one of the best they'd ever had, noting it was superior to the West Village location."
Positive"The author recommends the burger at Emily in the West Village."
Positive"The commenter (OP) tried the burger at Emily's but found it to be too buttery and heavy for their liking."
Negative
