Known for standout Detroit-style pizza & burgers [2]. A top choice for flavorful Caesar salad [4, 5].
This American-Italian eatery is celebrated for its exceptional pizza, with a particular nod to its Detroit-style offerings that cater to those who appreciate this niche [2]. Beyond pizza, the restaurant has garnered a reputation for serving one of the best burgers in NYC, often highlighted as a must-try item [2, 6, 9, 11]. Even the salads, like the Caesar, receive high praise for their unique preparation and flavor profiles [4, 5].
The restaurant is lauded for its pizzas, especially the Detroit-style variety, and is also frequently mentioned for having one of the best burgers in New York City. The Caesar salad is another standout, noted for its anchovy-forward flavor and fresh ingredients [2, 4, 5, 9, 11]. One diner found the sauce at the restaurant to be unpalatable [8].
"The Detroit-style pizza and burgers are frequently highlighted as must-try items. The Emmy Burger, in particular, has been called the best burger a diner has ever had."
Customers generally have a positive view, frequently praising the high-quality pizza and burgers. Some diners note that the restaurant can be quite pricey [7].
Important Note
One reviewer found the restaurant to be quite pricey [7], and another did not enjoy the sauce [8].
"The user recommended Emily for birthday dinners, stating that they have attended events there which were similar to the original poster's request and found the food delicious and plentiful."
Positive"This user compared the cottage fries at S&P Lunch to the waffle fries served with the Emmy Double Stack Burger at Emily West Village, noting they were good and they could have eaten a full plate of them."
Positive"This commenter expresses love for the burger at Emily, stating it's a place they enjoyed."
Positive"This restaurant was mentioned as a recommendation."
Positive"This user states that the Emmy Burger at Pizza Loves Emily is the best burger they've ever had, despite its $31 price tag."
Positive"This restaurant is suggested as a suitable option for the user's group and budget."
Positive"Emily is listed among the top 5 favorite classic burgers."
Positive"This user loved Emily but found it to be quite pricey."
Positive"This user did not like the sauce at Emily."
Negative"Emily's West Village is suggested as a place with a top-notch burger, though they also focus on pizza. The user also noted nearby bars like Little Branch for after."
Positive"A user praises Emily West Village's Caesar salad for its fresh, crunchy whole leaf romaine, calling it a 'deconstructed' but favorite version."
Positive"A user loves the Caesar salad at Emily West Village but notes its strong anchovy flavor, appealing to those who enjoy it."
Positive"Emily is described as fantastic, particularly appealing to New Yorkers who may not frequently encounter Chicago or Detroit-style pizza."
Positive"Emily in West Village is recommended for its good Detroit-style pizza and is noted for having one of the best burgers in NYC."
Positive"Emily was suggested as a potential restaurant for a family lunch near Barclays Center."
Neutral
