Next.js logo

EMILY

Last Updated: 1 day ago

Phone: (917) 955-6434

Address: 35 DOWNING STREET 10014

TLDR

NYC's go-to for acclaimed Detroit-style pizza & the legendary Emmy Burger, though quality can vary. A delicious, buzzy spot.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 40 Reddit comments)

55% Positive25% Neutral20% Negative

Tags

american 29italian 3pizza 3burger 15pizza 14burgers 14View All

Neighborhoods

West Village

Details

This American eatery is a must-visit for its standout Detroit-style pizza and the legendary Emmy Burger, often hailed as one of NYC's best. While some patrons rave about the burger's unique flavor, others have noted a decline in quality or found it too rich. Don't miss the chance to try their highly-regarded pizzas, though keep in mind that some find the Caesar salad an acquired taste due to its prominent anchovy notes.

Food Overview

The restaurant is known for its American cuisine with a notable offering of Detroit-style pizza, which some find exceptional, though not strictly traditional. The Emmy Burger is a frequently mentioned dish, receiving high praise from many as one of the best they've ever had, with mentions of a unique tangy/spicy sauce. Conversely, some diners have found the burger to be inconsistent, declining in quality over time, or too buttery. A Caesar salad is also highlighted, appreciated for its fresh ingredients but noted for a strong anchovy flavor. There are mixed reviews on whether the restaurant is still as good as it used to be, with some suggesting a decline.

Highlights / Recommended

"The Emmy Burger and the Detroit-style pizza are frequently recommended. The brussels sprout salad is also noted as excellent."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • burger(8)
  • emmy burger(5)
  • detroit style pizza(3)
  • pizza(2)
  • caesar salad(2)

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have positive things to say about the food, with many praising the unique Detroit-style pizza and the highly-rated Emmy Burger. However, there are some reports of declining quality and inconsistencies, particularly with the burger, and one customer experienced a negative incident with a salad.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

This post enthusiastically recommends Emily, highlighting the excellent Emmy burger and brussels sprout salad, and notes past enjoyment of their pizzas. The reviewer states they visited three times in a row.
Emily in West Village is recommended for its good Detroit-style pizza and is noted for having one of the best burgers in NYC. The restaurant is described as fantastic and appealing to those who may not frequently encounter this style of pizza.
A user declares the Emmy Burger at Pizza Loves Emily as the best burger they have ever eaten, despite its $31 price tag. This highlights a strong positive sentiment for this specific dish.
A user highly praises the Caesar salad at Emily West Village, noting its fresh, crunchy whole leaf romaine and calling it a favorite. However, they also mention its strong anchovy flavor, which might appeal more to certain palates.
This post discusses differences between Emily and Emmy Squared, with a user noting that the Emily West Village location has really good Detroit-style pizza, although it might not be typical. Another user recalls liking a tangy/spicy burger sauce.
While acknowledging the sauce at Emily's was 'heavenly,' one user states recent visits for their burger were 'so disappointing,' suggesting a decline in the burger itself. Another user agrees, stating their burger from past experience 'is my favorite burger I’ve ever had.'
Emily is listed among the top 5 favorite classic burgers, with one user finding it pricey but loving the burger. Another user did not like the sauce served with the burger.

Recent Mentions

From post: Looking For An Italian Restaurant That Serves

"This restaurant was mentioned as a recommendation."

Positive
Aug 17, 2025View Comment →

From post: Go To Minetta Tavern But Dont Order The Black

"This user states that the Emmy Burger at Pizza Loves Emily is the best burger they've ever had, despite its $31 price tag."

Positive
Aug 10, 2025View Comment →

From post: Precomedy Cellar Dinner

"This restaurant is suggested as a suitable option for the user's group and budget."

Positive
Jul 24, 2025View Comment →

From post: Who Really Has The Best Burger Shake Shack Jg

"Emily is listed among the top 5 favorite classic burgers."

Positive
Jul 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Who Really Has The Best Burger Shake Shack Jg

"This user loved Emily but found it to be quite pricey."

Positive
Jul 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Who Really Has The Best Burger Shake Shack Jg

"This user did not like the sauce at Emily."

Negative
Jul 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Iso Birthday Dinner Recs Help Me Choose

"Emily's West Village is suggested as a place with a top-notch burger, though they also focus on pizza. The user also noted nearby bars like Little Branch for after."

Positive
Jul 2, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Caesar Salad

"A user praises Emily West Village's Caesar salad for its fresh, crunchy whole leaf romaine, calling it a 'deconstructed' but favorite version."

Positive
Jun 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Caesar Salad

"A user loves the Caesar salad at Emily West Village but notes its strong anchovy flavor, appealing to those who enjoy it."

Positive
Jun 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Sit Down Pizza Lunch Wv Soho

"Emily is described as fantastic, particularly appealing to New Yorkers who may not frequently encounter Chicago or Detroit-style pizza."

Positive
Jun 6, 2025View Comment →

From post: Sit Down Pizza Lunch Wv Soho

"Emily in West Village is recommended for its good Detroit-style pizza and is noted for having one of the best burgers in NYC."

Positive
Jun 6, 2025View Comment →

From post: Restaurants Near Barclays

"Emily was suggested as a potential restaurant for a family lunch near Barclays Center."

Neutral
Jun 4, 2025View Comment →

From post: Did A Burger Tour Last Week 4 Charles Red Hook

"A user noted that Emily used to only make 25 burgers per night, requiring early arrival."

Neutral
May 19, 2025View Comment →

From post: Did A Burger Tour Last Week 4 Charles Red Hook

"The user plans to try Emily's Emmy Burger on their next visit to NYC."

Neutral
May 19, 2025View Comment →

From post: Did A Burger Tour Last Week 4 Charles Red Hook

"A user highly praised the Emmy Burger at Emily's Brooklyn location as one of the best they'd ever had, noting it was superior to the West Village location."

Positive
May 19, 2025View Comment →

From post: Dinner Recommendations Italian Burger Steak

"The author recommends the burger at Emily in the West Village."

Positive
May 11, 2025View Comment →

From post: Gramercy Tavern Burger Just Wow From An Italian

"The commenter (OP) tried the burger at Emily's but found it to be too buttery and heavy for their liking."

Negative
May 11, 2025View Comment →

From post: Fried Onion Burger From Hamburger America By

"Would sooner go to Emily and pay twice as much than have a typical smash burger like Hamburger America's, implying Emily is much better."

Positive
May 6, 2025View Comment →

From post: 25 Hours In Nyc

"While acknowledging the sauce at Emily's was "heavenly," the user reiterates that recent visits for their burger were "so disappointing," suggesting a decline in the burger itself."

Negative
May 5, 2025View Comment →

From post: 25 Hours In Nyc

"The original poster expresses sadness about hearing of Emily's decline, stating their burger from past experience "is my favorite burger I’ve ever had.""

Positive
May 5, 2025View Comment →