TLDR
A slice of NYC pizza w/ standout pepperoni, but beware mixed reviews & accusations of fake hype.
Details
Uncle Sam's Pizza, located on Clinton Street in Manhattan, is a spot that garners mixed reviews. While some users recommend it for its pepperoni and square slices [1], others describe the pizza as mediocre and a 'fucking joke' [2], [3]. The restaurant also seems to have an ongoing issue with accusations of fake reviews, even displaying a sign addressing it [4]. Despite the varied opinions, it has been noted as a potential stop on a Manhattan pizza tour [5].
Food Overview
Uncle Sam's Pizza is known for its pizza, particularly its square slices and pepperoni, which have been highlighted as particularly good by some patrons [1]. However, a significant portion of feedback describes the pizza as mediocre, with one user going as far as to call it a 'fucking joke' [2], [3]. There are also mentions of the restaurant displaying a sign related to accusations of fake reviews [4].
The pepperoni on their square slices has been specifically highlighted as being particularly good [1].
Caveats
Some users claim the restaurant has been accused of fake reviews and displays a sign addressing these accusations [1]. Another user mentions that the pizza is mediocre and not worth going out of your way for [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About UNCLE SAM PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"This commenter confirms that the pizza in the original post is from Uncle Sam's Pizza on Clinton Street."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter suggests Uncle Sam's Pizza on Clinton Street in the Lower East Side as a potential match for the described pizza. They note that the shop is small, uses brown plates, and the location aligns with the original post's description."
NeutralFrom post: I Visualized The Ratings For The 668 Pizza Places
"A direct statement calling Uncle Sam's 'trash'."
NegativeFrom post: I Visualized The Ratings For The 668 Pizza Places
"Uncle Sam's has a sign addressing accusations of fake reviews, and the user finds their pizza to be mediocre, even when sober."
NegativeFrom post: I Visualized The Ratings For The 668 Pizza Places
"The user claims Uncle Sam's is a 'fucking joke' and used to offer free slices for 5.0 reviews."
Negative