TLDR
A slice of NYC pizza w/ standout pepperoni, but beware mixed reviews & accusations of fake hype.
Details
Uncle Sam's Pizza, located on Clinton Street in Manhattan, is a spot that garners mixed reviews. While some users recommend it for its pepperoni and square slices [1], others describe the pizza as mediocre and a 'fucking joke' [2], [3]. The restaurant also seems to have an ongoing issue with accusations of fake reviews, even displaying a sign addressing it [4]. Despite the varied opinions, it has been noted as a potential stop on a Manhattan pizza tour [5].
Food Overview
Uncle Sam's Pizza is known for its pizza, particularly its square slices and pepperoni, which have been highlighted as particularly good by some patrons [1]. However, a significant portion of feedback describes the pizza as mediocre, with one user going as far as to call it a 'fucking joke' [2], [3]. There are also mentions of the restaurant displaying a sign related to accusations of fake reviews [4].
Highlights / Recommended
"The pepperoni on their square slices has been specifically highlighted as being particularly good [1]."
Caveats
Some users claim the restaurant has been accused of fake reviews and displays a sign addressing these accusations [1]. Another user mentions that the pizza is mediocre and not worth going out of your way for [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About UNCLE SAM PIZZA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"This commenter confirms that the pizza in the original post is from Uncle Sam's Pizza on Clinton Street."
PositiveFrom post: Help Me Find This Pizza I Had It A While Ago And
"Commenter suggests Uncle Sam's Pizza on Clinton Street in the Lower East Side as a potential match for the described pizza. They note that the shop is small, uses brown plates, and the location aligns with the original post's description."
NeutralFrom post: I Visualized The Ratings For The 668 Pizza Places
"A direct statement calling Uncle Sam's 'trash'."
NegativeFrom post: I Visualized The Ratings For The 668 Pizza Places
"Uncle Sam's has a sign addressing accusations of fake reviews, and the user finds their pizza to be mediocre, even when sober."
NegativeFrom post: I Visualized The Ratings For The 668 Pizza Places
"The user claims Uncle Sam's is a 'fucking joke' and used to offer free slices for 5.0 reviews."
NegativeFrom post: I Visualized The Ratings For The 668 Pizza Places
"Uncle Sam's is described as having mediocre pizza, though the user notes they do have some good square slices. It's not recommended to go out of the way for."
NegativeFrom post: One Shot One Perfect Pepperoni Slice Where
"For a square pepperoni slice, Uncle Sam's on the LES is recommended for its very good pepperoni, despite the odd name. A photo was linked."
PositiveFrom post: Join Me For A Nyc Pizza Tour
"The post author is organizing a pizza tour across Manhattan and lists Uncle Sam omenclature's Pizza as one of the pizzerias to visit."
NeutralFrom post: Is Scarrs Still Good What Pizza Is The Best In
"This user recommends Uncle Sam's."
Positive