Next.js logo

DOG DAY AFTERNOON

Last Updated: 3 months ago

Phone: (781) 264-1835

Address: 266 PROSPECT PARK WEST 11215

TLDR

Brooklyn's ultimate Chicago-style hot dog destination. Snappy Vienna sausages, authentic toppings, and even vegan dogs.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 28 Reddit comments)

71% Positive25% Neutral4% Negative

Tags

american 21chicago 2hot dog 8hot dogs 4chicago dog 4View All

Neighborhoods

Windsor Terrace

Details

Experience a taste of Chicago in Brooklyn at this acclaimed hot dog joint. Known for their authentic Chicago-style dogs, Vienna sausages with a satisfying snap, and even vegan options, they aim to please all palates. Beyond hot dogs, explore delights like Italian beef and Polish sausages, making it a go-to for a diverse and flavorful quick bite.

Food Overview

This establishment excels in offering authentic Chicago-style hot dogs with a great snap and flavor. Popular choices include the Vienna sausages, Italian beef, and Polish sausages. Vegan hot dog options are also available and well-regarded. While most feedback is highly positive, a few customers find the $9 price for a hot dog without fries to be a bit steep.

Highlights / Recommended

"Highly recommended are the authentic Chicago-style hot dogs, known for their snap and flavor. Other popular choices include the Italian beef and Polish sausages."

Customer Sentiment

Customers overwhelmingly praise the authentic Chicago-style hot dogs and the quality of the sausages, with many considering it the best in NYC. Some minor concerns are raised about the price point, though others feel it's justified by the generous toppings and overall quality.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

This post highlights the variety of hot dogs and sausages offered, with many commenters praising the authenticity of the Chicago dogs and recommending other items like the Italian beef and Polish sausage. The original poster called them the best in NYC.
Several users recommend this place for its authentic Chicago-style hot dogs, with one commenter specifically mentioning the great fries as well. Another user defends the price point by comparing it to other premium hot dog establishments.
This thread discusses various hot dog vendors, and multiple comments specifically praise Dog Day Afternoon for its authentic Chicago-style experience. One user notes minor deviations like not steaming buns but still considers it the closest to authentic.
In a broader NYC food discussion, this comment briefly notes that Dog Day Afternoon has veggie dogs available.

Recent Mentions

From post: Hot Dogs Nyc Vs Chicago

"The commenter mentions Dog Day Afternoon."

Neutral
Oct 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: Hot Dogs Nyc Vs Chicago

"Dog Day Afternoon is recommended for its authentic Chicago-style hot dogs and full menu."

Positive
Oct 18, 2025View Comment →

From post: Hot Dogs Nyc Vs Chicago

"The commenter finds Dog Day Afternoon to be too expensive for a hot dog without fries."

Negative
Oct 18, 2025View Comment →

From post: Hot Dogs Nyc Vs Chicago

"The commenter highly recommends Dog Day Afternoon, praising both the hot dogs and fries."

Positive
Oct 17, 2025View Comment →

From post: Hot Dogs Nyc Vs Chicago

"This is a recommendation for Dog Day Afternoon as a place to get a Chicago-style hot dog in NYC."

Positive
Oct 17, 2025View Comment →

From post: Hot Dogs Nyc Vs Chicago

"This restaurant is recommended for its hot dogs."

Positive
Oct 17, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"This commenter indicates that Dog Day Afternoon also caters to vegans."

Positive
Sep 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"The commenter praises the friendly staff at Dog Day Afternoon, noting they accommodate dogs and that the Polish and Italian sausages are pork-based for those who don't eat beef."

Positive
Sep 29, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"The commenter states that the Italian beef is their favorite item at Dog Day Afternoon and that it is very good."

Positive
Sep 29, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"The commenter explains that high prices are due to inflation and the generous amount of toppings offered at Dog Day Afternoon."

Neutral
Sep 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"This commenter expresses love for Dog Day Afternoon, praising the owners and the vintage nerd-themed shop, which sometimes sells records."

Positive
Sep 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"The commenter states that prices are comparable to Chicago and that the food at Dog Day Afternoon is well worth the cost."

Positive
Sep 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"The commenter expresses their liking for Dog Day Afternoon."

Positive
Sep 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"A brief positive comment stating that the food at Dog Day Afternoon looks great."

Positive
Sep 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"This commenter praises Dog Day Afternoon, stating it serves the best Chicago dog in Brooklyn."

Positive
Sep 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"This commenter defends the price of hot dogs at Dog Day Afternoon by comparing it to other establishments like Nathan's and Criff Dog, suggesting $9 is in line with premium hot dogs."

Positive
Sep 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"In response to a query, this commenter identifies the dish as a Polish dog, likely their best, featuring Polish Kielbasa with mustard, onions, and a pepper."

Positive
Sep 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"The commenter inquires about the identity of the first dish on the left, which is described as a Polish dog."

Neutral
Sep 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"This comment indicates Dog Day Afternoon also has a presence at H&H bar in Williamsburg."

Neutral
Sep 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day

"Responding to a question about a specific dish, this commenter clarifies it was a vegan dog with toppings and found it outstanding."

Positive
Sep 27, 2025View Comment →