TLDR
Top-tier Chicago-style hot dogs and excellent Italian beef in a vintage, nerd-themed setting. Authentic, high-quality street food worth the premium.
Reddit Sentiment for DOG DAY AFTERNOON(based on 36 Reddit opinions)
Details
Renowned for serving arguably the best Chicago-style hot dogs in New York City [1], [9], [20], this vintage, nerd-themed spot is a go-to destination for authentic American street food [11], [24]. In addition to their signature dogs, the menu features standout Italian beef sandwiches and Polish kielbasa that frequently earn high praise from visitors [2], [8], [15], [29], [36]. While some patrons find the price point high for the category [4], [22], [30], [32], many argue the quality and generous toppings make it well worth the cost [10], [12], [18].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American staples like Chicago-style hot dogs, Italian beef sandwiches, and Polish kielbasa [1], [2], [8], [36]. Customers consistently highlight the Italian beef and Polish kielbasa as standout options [8], [15], [29], [36], while also noting the availability of excellent vegan dog alternatives [6], [17].
Highlights / Recommended
"The Chicago-style hot dog and Italian beef sandwich are highly recommended favorites [2], [9], [29], [36]. The Polish kielbasa, sourced from a local butcher, is also frequently praised by guests [8], [36]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •italian beef(3)
- •polish kielbasa(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons generally hold the restaurant in high regard, frequently labeling it the city's premier spot for authentic Chicago-style hot dogs [1], [23], [27]. While the quality of food is widely celebrated, some customers occasionally express hesitation regarding the higher price point of the menu items [4], [30], [32].
Caveats
Some visitors find the pricing to be high, with certain hot dogs and sausages ranging from $9 to $14 [4], [30], [32].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About DOG DAY AFTERNOON
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Somewhere I Can Buy Soft Poppy Seed
"The user inquired about a local butcher's polish kielbasa, suggesting it's a good alternative to Vienna brand and that the restaurant's beef sandwich is also excellent."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Hot Dog Spots
"This user debated the prices at Dog Day Afternoon, stating the Polish was a kielbasa and others were still $9."
NeutralFrom post: Favorite Hot Dog Spots
"This user argued about the prices at Dog Day Afternoon, claiming certain dogs were $11 and the Polish hot dog was $14 after tax."
NegativeFrom post: Favorite Hot Dog Spots
"This user discussed the merits of Chicago dogs versus those from papaya places, mentioning Dog Day Afternoon as a better alternative to Shake Shack for Chicago dogs."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Hot Dog Spots
"In response to a comment about prices, this user indicated they would still order Chicago dogs there."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Hot Dog Spots
"This user expressed that the prices at Dog Day Afternoon were too high for a hot dog."
NegativeFrom post: Favorite Hot Dog Spots
"This user recommended Dog Day Afternoon."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Hot Dog Spots
"This user recommended Dog Day Afternoon in South Park Slope for hot dogs."
PositiveFrom post: Hot Dogs And Nachos
"This user suggested Dog Day Afternoon as a place for hot dogs."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Hard To Find Food Items For You
"This user listed Dog Day Afternoon as a place in Windsor Terrace that offers Chicago-style hot dogs."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Hard To Find Food Items For You
"This user mentioned Dog Day Afternoon in Williamsburg as a place that potentially meets all the criteria for a Chicago-style hot dog."
PositiveFrom post: Hot Dogs Nyc Vs Chicago
"The commenter mentions Dog Day Afternoon."
NeutralFrom post: Hot Dogs Nyc Vs Chicago
"Dog Day Afternoon is recommended for its authentic Chicago-style hot dogs and full menu."
PositiveFrom post: Hot Dogs Nyc Vs Chicago
"The commenter finds Dog Day Afternoon to be too expensive for a hot dog without fries."
NegativeFrom post: Hot Dogs Nyc Vs Chicago
"The commenter highly recommends Dog Day Afternoon, praising both the hot dogs and fries."
PositiveFrom post: Hot Dogs Nyc Vs Chicago
"This is a recommendation for Dog Day Afternoon as a place to get a Chicago-style hot dog in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Hot Dogs Nyc Vs Chicago
"This restaurant is recommended for its hot dogs."
PositiveFrom post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day
"This commenter indicates that Dog Day Afternoon also caters to vegans."
PositiveFrom post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day
"The commenter praises the friendly staff at Dog Day Afternoon, noting they accommodate dogs and that the Polish and Italian sausages are pork-based for those who don't eat beef."
PositiveFrom post: Various Hot Dogs And Sausages From Dog Day
"The commenter states that the Italian beef is their favorite item at Dog Day Afternoon and that it is very good."
Positive