TLDR
Top-tier Chicago-style hot dogs and excellent Italian beef in a vintage, nerd-themed setting. Authentic, high-quality street food worth the premium.
Reddit Sentiment for DOG DAY AFTERNOON(based on 36 Reddit opinions)
Details
Renowned for serving arguably the best Chicago-style hot dogs in New York City [1], [9], [20], this vintage, nerd-themed spot is a go-to destination for authentic American street food [11], [24]. In addition to their signature dogs, the menu features standout Italian beef sandwiches and Polish kielbasa that frequently earn high praise from visitors [2], [8], [15], [29], [36]. While some patrons find the price point high for the category [4], [22], [30], [32], many argue the quality and generous toppings make it well worth the cost [10], [12], [18].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American staples like Chicago-style hot dogs, Italian beef sandwiches, and Polish kielbasa [1], [2], [8], [36]. Customers consistently highlight the Italian beef and Polish kielbasa as standout options [8], [15], [29], [36], while also noting the availability of excellent vegan dog alternatives [6], [17].
Highlights / Recommended
"The Chicago-style hot dog and Italian beef sandwich are highly recommended favorites [2], [9], [29], [36]. The Polish kielbasa, sourced from a local butcher, is also frequently praised by guests [8], [36]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •italian beef(3)
- •polish kielbasa(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons generally hold the restaurant in high regard, frequently labeling it the city's premier spot for authentic Chicago-style hot dogs [1], [23], [27]. While the quality of food is widely celebrated, some customers occasionally express hesitation regarding the higher price point of the menu items [4], [30], [32].
Caveats
Some visitors find the pricing to be high, with certain hot dogs and sausages ranging from $9 to $14 [4], [30], [32].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About DOG DAY AFTERNOON
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Somewhere I Can Buy Soft Poppy Seed
"The user inquired about a local butcher's polish kielbasa, suggesting it's a good alternative to Vienna brand and that the restaurant's beef sandwich is also excellent."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Hot Dog Spots
"This user debated the prices at Dog Day Afternoon, stating the Polish was a kielbasa and others were still $9."
NeutralFrom post: Favorite Hot Dog Spots
"This user argued about the prices at Dog Day Afternoon, claiming certain dogs were $11 and the Polish hot dog was $14 after tax."
NegativeFrom post: Favorite Hot Dog Spots
"This user discussed the merits of Chicago dogs versus those from papaya places, mentioning Dog Day Afternoon as a better alternative to Shake Shack for Chicago dogs."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Hot Dog Spots
"In response to a comment about prices, this user indicated they would still order Chicago dogs there."
Positive