NYC's go-to for thick, decadent cookies w/ creative flavors. Some love 'em, some find 'em a bit too much - try the THINs!
This cookie shop is a standout in the NYC dessert scene, known for its generously sized, decadent cookies. Many customers rave about the creative flavor combinations and the satisfyingly thick, chewy texture, with some even declaring it their go-to spot for a sweet treat. While generally loved, some find them a bit too sweet or rich, suggesting the 'THINs' or specific flavors might be preferable.
The cookies here are the star, with customers frequently recommending them for their size and creative flavor profiles. While many enjoy the thick, chewy texture, a few find them excessively sweet and rich, with some suggesting the 'THINs' or specific flavors as a better alternative. The 'baklava cookie' is noted as a rare but highly recommended item.
"The 'baklava cookie' is a highly recommended, though rarely available, option. The 'cookies and cream' cookie is also praised, and some suggest trying the 'THINs' which are considered by some to be better than their regular cookies."
Customers generally love these cookies, often praising their creative flavors and satisfyingly thick, chewy texture. However, a minority find them overly sweet or rich.
Important Note
Some customers find the cookies excessively sweet and rich, and one commenter mentioned concerns about ingredients and ownership stories.
"This user believes Chip City pays influencers."
Neutral"The author felt Chip City's ingredients might be heavier than other places but considered it a good occasional treat."
Positive"The author acknowledges Chip City cookies are sweet but felt their body needed the sugar at that point, contributing to their enjoyment."
Positive"This commenter feels Chip City cookies are now too sweet compared to before COVID."
Negative"This commenter avoids Chip City due to concerns about ingredients and ownership stories."
Negative"This commenter agrees Chip City is underrated and notes that it's often empty compared to Crumbl, despite having consistently good cookies."
Positive"This commenter agrees that Chip City is underrated and prefers it over Crumbl."
Positive"The author was impressed with Chip City, finding their cookie better than those from more popular places like 'Appartement 4F' or 'Seven Grams'."
Positive"This commenter stated that Chip City is super underrated and makes really delicious cookies."
Positive"The author enjoyed the cookies and cream cookie, rating it their second favorite of the day."
Positive"Chip City offers any cookie for free during the birthday person's birthday month, which is considered much better than Crumbl. The cookies are highly recommended."
Positive"This cookie shop is mentioned as a place that might offer birthday freebies. The specific freebie is not detailed."
Neutral"This commenter noted that blind rankings, potentially done at an office, might have negatively impacted the scores of cookies that are best enjoyed warm, like Chip City's."
Neutral"The user gives an honorable mention to Chip City's thin cookies, calling them fantastic."
Positive"Chip City is explicitly stated to be superior to Levain."
Positive"The commenter states a personal preference for Chip City."
Positive"Chip City is recommended and described as 'delicious'."
Positive"The commenter suggests that the preference between Chip City and Levain depends on one's specific craving, implying both offer distinct but desirable cookie styles."
Neutral"Chip city"
Neutral"Ranked #13 out of 15 NYC chocolate chip cookies. Strongly disliked for being excessively sweet, thick, and rich, described hyperbolically as decadent and unenjoyable."
Negative
