TLDR
Neighborhood go-to for brunch classics and craveable baked goods. Charming spot known for signature skillet pancakes and standout cookies.
Details
Located in Washington Heights, this American bakery and brunch spot is widely recognized as a local staple for its cozy atmosphere and quality baked goods [1], [20]. While many patrons enjoy the house specialties and fresh, oven-warmed offerings, experiences can vary regarding service consistency and the range of bread products available [5], [8]. Overall, it remains a frequently recommended destination for those exploring the area near the Cloisters [2], [4], [15].
Food Overview
The menu features American cafe staples, with high praise for their namesake Dutch baby pancakes, brioche French toast, and unique pastries like parmesan chive scones and salted chocolate shortbread [10], [18], [21]. While the chocolate chip cookies are frequently highlighted as some of the best in the city [7], some customers have criticized the bakery for overbaked items and a lack of variety in their bread offerings [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About DUTCH BABY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Affordable Lunch Recs Somewhat Near
"Mentioned as a local staple in the area."
NeutralFrom post: Upper Manhattan Highlights Specifically
"Included in a list of favorites with a specific pastry mention."
PositiveFrom post: Upper Manhattan Highlights Specifically
"Suggested as a good spot for brunch."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find A Cheddar Chive Scone In
"A user suggests trying the parmesan chive scone at Dutch Baby in Washington Heights, describing it as very yummy."
PositiveFrom post: Lunch Places Near The Cloisters
"Suggested Dutch Baby Bakery as a good option, noting it's more of a cafe but serves good food, and is walkable or accessible by the M4 bus."
NeutralFrom post: Lunch Places Near The Cloisters
"Recommended Dutch Baby Bakery for the group's 'somewhat bougie' taste."
PositiveFrom post: Lunch Places Near The Cloisters
"Mentioned a bakery/sandwich spot on 187 and Fort Washington as a potential option."
NeutralFrom post: Lunch Places Near The Cloisters
"Included Dutch Baby Bakery among options on the same block as Kismat on 187th street."
NeutralFrom post: Visiting Nyc Next Month Best Food Suggestions For
"Dutch Baby is recommended as a good bakery and brunch spot."
PositiveFrom post: Brunch Recs Inwood Upper Manhattan
"Dutch Baby Bakery is secondarily recommended. No specific dishes were mentioned."
PositiveFrom post: Brunch Recs Inwood Upper Manhattan
"Dutch Baby Bakery is recommended for brunch, and it is noted that they have a full brunch menu. No specific dishes were mentioned."
PositiveFrom post: Bakeries In Hamiltonwashington Heights
"The commenter mentioned Dutch Baby as the only bread bakery they could think of in the Hamilton/Washington Heights area, though they acknowledged their knowledge might be slightly outdated."
PositiveFrom post: Great Rec Dutch Baby Was Really Good
"The commenter had a positive experience at Dutch Baby Bakery, noting that sometimes items are available fresh from the oven. They also recall receiving free cake slices near closing time, which they found to be a sweet gesture."
PositiveFrom post: Great Rec Dutch Baby Was Really Good
"The commenter states that Dutch Baby Bakery is quite good."
PositiveFrom post: Great Rec Dutch Baby Was Really Good
"Dutch Baby Bakery is considered solid, though not exceptional. The commenter notes that they offer good items, as well as some catering to specific dietary needs or tastes. They specifically enjoyed the biscuit and scones, and found the ambiance to be a nice, sunny room."
NeutralFrom post: Great Rec Dutch Baby Was Really Good
"The commenter believes Dutch Baby Bakery has a spectacular chocolate chip cookie, possibly among the best in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Great Rec Dutch Baby Was Really Good
"The bar for quality is perceived as low in this area. The commenter finds that pastries are overbaked and only one type of bread is typically offered. Additionally, the service is described as quite poor."
NegativeFrom post: Great Rec Dutch Baby Was Really Good
"The original poster enjoyed their 'brunch' at Dutch Baby Bakery, specifically mentioning the Dutch Baby and brioche French toast as highlights."
PositiveFrom post: Lunch By The Cloisters
"This commenter agreed that Dutch Baby would be a suitable choice for brunch."
PositiveFrom post: Lunch By The Cloisters
"This commenter simply seconded the recommendation for Dutch Baby."
Positive