Next.js logo

GELATERIA GENTILE

Updated

Phone: (917) 409-5979

Address: 75 UNIVERSITY PLACE 10003

TLDR

Authentic Italian gelato, w/ antique quality & amazing flavors. A must-try for dessert lovers in NYC.

Reddit Sentiment for GELATERIA GENTILE(based on 7 Reddit opinions)

86% Positive

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo

Tags

italian 7gelato 7View All

Neighborhoods

Greenwich Village

Recent Articles

Details

Hailing from Bari, Italy, Gelateria Gentile brings an authentic, antique-quality gelato experience to New York City. With multiple locations and a reputation for potentially being the best gelato in town, it's a must-visit for dessert lovers. Don't miss the chance to pair their exquisite gelato with a coffee for a perfect affogato.

Food Overview

Gelateria Gentile is celebrated for its authentic Italian gelato, with a strong emphasis on unique and delicious flavors. Fan favorites include pistachio gelato, grapefruit sorbetto, and a sour cherry and cream flavor called Spagnoli Gelato. The establishment is noted for its high-quality gelato, often compared to traditional Italian offerings.

Highlights / Recommended

"Customers highly recommend the pistachio gelato and grapefruit sorbetto. The Spagnoli Gelato (sour cherry & cream) is also noted as a phenomenal flavor choice."

Customer Sentiment

Customers highly praise Gelateria Gentile for its authentic Italian gelato, with many singling out specific flavors as exceptional. The quality and unique taste are consistently highlighted in feedback.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About GELATERIA GENTILE

This post enthusiastically recommends Gelateria Gentile as a favorite for authentic gelato, noting its origins in Bari, Italy. Other comments praise the gelato's temperature, texture, and interesting flavors, comparing it favorably to gelato found in Italy.
A user describes their recent experience with the grapefruit sorbetto at Gelateria Gentile, calling it absolutely delicious. This highlights a specific refreshing flavor option available at the establishment.
This comment expresses a strong recommendation for Gelateria Gentile, with a particular obsession noted for their pistachio gelato flavor. Another user chimed in, agreeing with the enthusiasm for the pistachio gelato.
The Spagnoli Gelato, a sour cherry and cream flavor from Gelateria Gentile, is described as phenomenal by a user, adding to the variety of praised flavors.
A brief mention that Gelateria Gentile usually has lemon sorbet available, suggesting it as a potential option for those seeking this particular flavor.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer

"Found Gelateria Gentile's gelato to have the right temperature and good texture, with interesting flavors. They noted it's served in covered containers, indicating quality gelato in Italy."

Positive
Apr 16, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer

"Recommends Gelateria Gentile as a favorite for authentic gelato, originally from Bari, Italy."

Positive
Apr 15, 2026View Comment →

From post: Cherry Dessertsdrinks

"The Spagnoli Gelato (sour cherry & cream) from Gelateria Gentile is described as phenomenal."

Positive
Mar 23, 2026View Comment →

From post: Grapefruit Gelato

"This user recently had grapefruit sorbetto at Gelateria Gentile near Union Square and found it to be absolutely delicious."

Positive
Aug 1, 2025View Comment →

From post: Itinerary Review For Part 3 Of 72 Hours In Nyc

"The user expresses personal enthusiasm for pistachio gelato, aligning with the previous recommendation."

Positive
Jun 11, 2025View Comment →

From post: Itinerary Review For Part 3 Of 72 Hours In Nyc

"The commenter highly recommends Gelateria Gentile, expressing a particular obsession with their pistachio gelato flavor."

Positive
Jun 11, 2025View Comment →