TLDR
Authentic Italian gelato from Bari, Italy [1]—praised as potentially the best in NYC [1]. Try the pistachio gelato obsession [1] or grapefruit sorbetto [2].
Details
Originating from Bari, Italy, Gelateria Gentile offers gelato with an antique quality, praised as potentially the best in town [1]. With locations in Nolita, University Place, and Williamsburg, they also serve coffee for affogatos [1]. The gelato is noted for having the right temperature and good texture, with interesting flavors served in covered containers, indicating quality [2].
Food Overview
Gelateria Gentile, with origins in Bari, Italy, offers authentic gelato that customers describe as having the right temperature and good texture, with interesting flavors served in traditional covered containers [2], [3]. The pistachio gelato is a standout flavor, with one commenter expressing particular obsession [1]. Other highly recommended items include the delicious grapefruit sorbetto [2] and the phenomenal Spagnoli Gelato (sour cherry & cream) [4]. They also offer coffee, suitable for affogatos [1]. A vegan Black Forest cake is also mentioned as a potential offering [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About GELATERIA GENTILE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Veganeggless Bakery Recommendation Not Preorder
"A commenter suggested Gelaterie Gentile might have a vegan Black Forest cake."
PositiveFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"Found Gelateria Gentile's gelato to have the right temperature and good texture, with interesting flavors. They noted it's served in covered containers, indicating quality gelato in Italy."
PositiveFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"Recommends Gelateria Gentile as a favorite for authentic gelato, originally from Bari, Italy."
PositiveFrom post: Cherry Dessertsdrinks
"The Spagnoli Gelato (sour cherry & cream) from Gelateria Gentile is described as phenomenal."
PositiveFrom post: Grapefruit Gelato
"This user recently had grapefruit sorbetto at Gelateria Gentile near Union Square and found it to be absolutely delicious."
PositiveFrom post: Itinerary Review For Part 3 Of 72 Hours In Nyc
"The user expresses personal enthusiasm for pistachio gelato, aligning with the previous recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Itinerary Review For Part 3 Of 72 Hours In Nyc
"The commenter highly recommends Gelateria Gentile, expressing a particular obsession with their pistachio gelato flavor."
Positive