TLDR
Must-try babka & croissants that rival the best [1], [11]. This celebrated bakery offers a unique sweet treat, esp. Jewish baked goods like rugelach & halva [5], [7].
Details
Michaeli Bakery is a highly recommended spot in Manhattan, celebrated for its exceptional babka and a variety of Jewish baked goods like rugelach and challah [1], [5]. Reviewers often compare its babka favorably to other well-known bakeries, with some even calling it 'life changing' [22], [18]. The bakery also receives praise for its croissants, with one commenter noting a Parisian native's high praise for them [11], [12], [26].
Food Overview
Michaeli Bakery is renowned for its Jewish baked goods, particularly its babka, which is often cited as a must-try and even surpasses other popular establishments [1], [5], [22]. The bakery also receives high marks for its croissants, with one person noting that a Parisian native found them to be the best they'd ever had [11], [26]. Other recommended items include halva rugelach, chocolate/cinnamon/poppy rugelach, challah, duvshaniot, and savory burekas, specifically spicy cheese sticks [5], [7], [20].
Highlights / Recommended
"Michaeli Bakery is highly recommended for its babka and croissants, with some users calling the babka 'life changing' and a Parisian native praising the croissants as the best ever tasted [1], [11], [18], [26]. Other popular choices include halva rugelach, chocolate/cinnamon/poppy rugelach, challah, duvshaniot, and savory burekas like spicy cheese sticks [5], [7], [20]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •hamantaschen(2)
Caveats
One commenter noted that while the baked goods are excellent, the coffee at Michaeli Bakery is not highly rated [26]. Availability of specific items, like hamantaschen, may be limited and calling ahead is advised [25].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MICHAELI BAKERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Pistachio Croissant
"Michaeli Bakery on the LES/UES is recommended for their pistachio-cherry croissant, described as incredible and not overly sweet."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Place For Hamantaschen Especially Black
"This commenter praises Michaeli as the best, also noting their babkas are great and the staff is friendly, though the coffee is not highly rated."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Place For Hamantaschen Especially Black
"This commenter agrees that Michaeli is excellent."
PositiveFrom post: Favorite Place For Hamantaschen Especially Black
"The commenter advises calling Michaeli to check if they still have hamantaschen, as availability might be limited."
NeutralFrom post: Favorite Place For Hamantaschen Especially Black
"This commenter recommends Michaeli for a delicious hamantaschen and suggests calling ahead to check availability."
PositiveFrom post: What Local Spots Pastry Or Nycesque Items Would
"Chocolate babka from Michaeli Bakery is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: Best Place For Savory Pasteries
"Michaeli Bakery is recommended for its spicy cheese sticks and other varieties of savory burekas."
PositiveFrom post: French People In Nyc Where Has Best Croissants In
"This user, who is 1/4 French, recommended Michaeli Bakery."
PositiveFrom post: Best Midtown Bakeriescafes
"Michaeli Bakery is listed as one of the recommended bakeries."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Babka
"The author praises Michaeli Bakery for its chocolate babka."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Babka
"Considers Michaeli Bakery's babka to be among the best, alongside Breads Bakery."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Babka
"The author found Michaeli Bakery's babka 'life changing' and possibly better than Breads Bakery's."
PositiveFrom post: Best Croissant For Mom Who Grew Up In Aix En
"This commenter stated they love the croissants from Michaeli Bakery."
PositiveFrom post: Best Croissant For Mom Who Grew Up In Aix En
"This commenter mentioned that a Parisian native said Michaeli Bakery has the best croissant they have ever had."
PositiveFrom post: Best Croissant For Mom Who Grew Up In Aix En
"This commenter mentioned that a Parisian native said Michaeli Bakery has the best croissant they have ever had."
PositiveFrom post: Best Croissant For Mom Who Grew Up In Aix En
"This commenter mentioned that a Parisian native said Michaeli Bakery has the best croissant they have ever had."
PositiveFrom post: Best Almond Croissant
"This commenter agrees with the previous recommendation for Michaeli's bakery and mentions that the owner previously worked at Breads and created their babka."
PositiveFrom post: Best Almond Croissant
"The commenter highly recommends Michaeli's bakery, stating it is very good."
PositiveFrom post: Best Rosh Hashanah Treats
"The commenter strongly endorses Michaeli's (mentioning three locations, with Division St. being the original) for its wide assortment of Rosh Hashanah treats and amazing dough, rating it better than Breads Bakery."
PositiveFrom post: Best Rosh Hashanah Treats
"Michaeli is mentioned as a good place for baked goods, alongside Onegs for babka."
Positive