Timeless New Orleans-inspired escape. Stellar oysters & classic cocktails w/ tableside flair. Enchanting garden patio.
Molly Fitzpatrick reviews Maison Premiere, a Williamsburg establishment that has maintained its charm and quality for over a decade, offering a timeless New Orleans-inspired experience with exceptional cocktails and a standout raw bar.
This New Orleans-inspired Brooklyn establishment has stood the test of time, offering a timeless ambiance reminiscent of the French Quarter. Its cocktail program is a major draw, featuring classic recipes and tableside preparations, while the raw bar boasts an extensive selection of oysters. Standout dishes include the balanced Bay Scallop Crudo and flavorful Montauk Shrimp Pasta, though the Lobster Roll is reportedly a miss.
The restaurant is highly acclaimed for its extensive raw bar, featuring a wide variety of oysters from both coasts, and its expertly crafted cocktails, including absinthe-based drinks and tableside preparations. While dishes like the Bay Scallop Crudo and Montauk Shrimp Pasta receive high marks for flavor and balance, the Lobster Roll has been noted as a dish to avoid.
"The raw bar selection, particularly oysters, is a must-try. The Bay Scallop Crudo, Steak Tartare, and Montauk Shrimp Pasta are also highly recommended for their flavor and preparation."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the restaurant for its exceptional ambiance, particularly its beautiful garden, and its high-quality seafood and expertly crafted cocktails. Some find it to be on the pricier side.
Important Note
Some patrons find the restaurant to be on the expensive side. One negative experience involved a patron being accidentally groped due to close table seating.
"At Maison Premiere, the commenter recommends ordering a dozen oysters, the bread and seaweed butter, and a great cocktail."
Positive"Maison Premiere is mentioned as a restaurant with an impressive aesthetic."
Positive"During an anniversary celebration at Maison Premiere, the commenter reported being accidentally groped by patrons at an adjacent table due to the tables being seated side-by-side and the neighbors being overly affectionate."
Negative"This user recommended Maison Premiere for its warm and cozy atmosphere with a New Orleans French Quarter twist."
Positive"Suggested Maison Premiere as a place to get a drink while waiting for a table at Four Horsemen, mentioning it's usually accessible for standing room."
Positive"Recommended Maison Premiere as a top choice for a drink while waiting, noting its proximity to Four Horsemen."
Positive"This commenter recommended Maison Premier for drinks and food, detailing several dishes like bay scallops, lobster roll, steak tartare, oysters, and a seafood tower, all of which they found great. They also praised the bar, cocktails, and desserts, advising to talk to the bartender for drink recommendations."
Positive"This commenter suggested Maison Premier for a drink."
Positive"Madison Premiere is recommended."
Positive"This recommendation is considered fantastic, but it's noted that the date should enjoy oysters and absinthe."
Positive"This user believes Maison Premiere is too expensive for a first date."
Negative"This place is recommended, but another user commented that it might be too expensive for a first date."
Neutral"The author rated Maison Premiere a perfect 10.0 overall, with high scores for drinks, vibe, and food. They particularly enjoyed the Yellow Parrot cocktail, calling it a favorite, and praised the outstanding oysters and cherrystone clams."
Positive"Maison Premiere is listed as a recommended restaurant."
Neutral"Maison Premiere is recommended."
Positive"Maison Premiere is recommended."
Positive"Maison Premiere is recommended."
Positive"This comment sarcastically noted that tableside cocktail service at Maison Premiere should only take forty minutes."
Neutral"Maison Premier was identified as a top choice for oysters and advised booking in advance."
Positive"Maison Premiere was suggested as a place for oysters and cocktails, with an emphasis on their tableside cocktail service."
Neutral
