TLDR
Montreal-style bagels w/ chewy, crispy crust & soft, salty interior [1], [4]. Convenient option for a tasty bite, though some prefer other local spots [1], [4].
Reddit Sentiment for BLACK SEED BAGELS(based on 6 Reddit opinions)
Details
This Brooklyn-based bagel shop offers a unique take on the classic New York bagel, leaning towards a Montreal-style [1]. Reviewers suggest looking for a chewy, crispy crust and a soft, slightly salty interior, regardless of origin [4]. While some find it 'mid' compared to other local favorites, others consider it a pretty good option for a convenient bite [1], [4].
Food Overview
The bagels here are noted for their Montreal-ish style, characterized by a chewy and crispy crust with a soft, slightly salty interior [4]. While some patrons consider them 'mid' or overrated compared to other bagel establishments, others find them to be a solid and convenient choice [1], [2], [4]. There's a critique of heavily topping bagels, questioning if the appeal lies with the bagel itself or its adornments [5].
Highlights / Recommended
"The bagels are described as having a chewy, crispy crust and a soft, slightly salty interior [4]."
Caveats
Some customers feel that Black Seed is 'mid' or not as good as other local bagel options and question the emphasis on toppings rather than the bagel itself [1], [2], [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BLACK SEED BAGELS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Bagelsbreakfast Near Barclays My Wife Put Me
"This user notes that Black Seed offers Montreal-ish style bagels and criticizes the trend of heavily topping bagels, questioning if the recommendations are for the bagels themselves or the toppings."
NegativeFrom post: Best Bagelsbreakfast Near Barclays My Wife Put Me
"This user, who grew up in the area, believes Black Seed is 'pretty good' and suggests a test for identifying a good bagel: chewy, crispy crust and soft, slightly salty interior, regardless of where it's from."
PositiveFrom post: Best Bagelsbreakfast Near Barclays My Wife Put Me
"This user considers Black Seed 'mid' and not an exclusive 'transplant' place, contrasting it with what they consider great options like Bagel Pub and Gertie."
NegativeFrom post: Best Bagelsbreakfast Near Barclays My Wife Put Me
"Bagel pub is recommended alongside Black Seed."
PositiveFrom post: Best Bagelsbreakfast Near Barclays My Wife Put Me
"This user noted walking past Black Seed and was at White Noise Coffee."
NeutralFrom post: Best Bagelsbreakfast Near Barclays My Wife Put Me
"Black Seed is noted as the most convenient option but is described as Montreal-style and overrated, with a recommendation to avoid it if seeking authentic NY bagels."
Negative