TLDR
A dessert destination boasting ample outdoor seating & loads of gelato flavors [1], [3]. Generous portions & ability to sample before ordering make it a popular choice for a sweet treat [3].
Details
ANITA GELATO is a popular dessert spot known for its beautiful shop and generous portions of gelato [1]. It offers a wide array of flavors, allowing customers to sample them before making a choice, and their smallest cup can hold a surprising amount of gelato [3]. While some consider it a favorite, others find its gelato too sweet and not authentically Italian [8], [10].
Food Overview
ANITA GELATO is praised for its wide variety of gelato flavors and its generous portion sizes, with customers able to sample flavors before purchasing [1], [3]. Some reviewers, however, find the gelato excessively sweet and question its authenticity, suggesting it's more like dense soft-serve made with cream rather than milk [8], [10], [13], [14]. It's also noted that the founders are not Italian [12]. While primarily known for gelato, they also offer froyo with unlimited toppings, which some prefer over their gelato [7], [9].
Caveats
Some reviewers have raised concerns about the authenticity of the gelato, stating it is overly sweet, not made with milk, and that the founders are not Italian. There are also mentions of past grade-pending issues with the chain in general.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ANITA GELATO
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Recs For Last Restaurant To Visit Before I Move
"This user is intrigued by Anita's toppings, comparing it to 40 carrots and planning to visit to experience the decadent toppings."
PositiveFrom post: Recs For Last Restaurant To Visit Before I Move
"Clarifying the unlimited refills at Anita, the commenter states you can't leave and come back, but refills are allowed during the same dine-in visit, a feature they enjoyed in Australia."
PositiveFrom post: Recs For Last Restaurant To Visit Before I Move
"Excited by the mention of unlimited refills at Anita, this user expresses that their life has been changed by this information."
PositiveFrom post: Recs For Last Restaurant To Visit Before I Move
"This commenter suggests Anita for froyo, noting that while known for gelato, their froyo comes with unlimited house-made toppings and refills while dining in."
PositiveFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"States Anita is not Italian-owned and is very sweet."
NegativeFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"Includes Anita among the best gelato tried in NYC so far, but later criticizes it for being too sweet and not Italian-owned."
NegativeFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"Notes that Anita is a transnational chain with a history of grade-pending issues, suggesting it's cheaper to hire lawyers than address food safety. They also describe its taste as half corn syrup."
NegativeFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"States that Anita is more of a dense soft serve than gelato and def uses cream not milk."
NegativeFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"Considers Anita's gelato an affront to 'authentic' gelato due to its high piles and overly sweet taste."
NegativeFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"Recommends Rivareno for authentic gelato and Anita for fun flavors."
PositiveFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"States Anita is way too sweet and its founders are not Italian."
NegativeFrom post: Best Authentic Gelato For The Summer
"Believes Anita is generally pretty good, but prefers their soft serve frozen yogurt over their gelato due to unlimited toppings and the same high-quality housemade sauces and mix-ins."
NeutralFrom post: Which Ice Cream Places Have The Best Top Tier
"This user listed Anita La Mamma del Gelato as one of the ice cream places to consider."
NeutralFrom post: 60 Hours In Nyc
"The commenter stopped by Anita Gelato for gelato as they walked back to their hotel."
NeutralFrom post: Visiting Nyc For The First Time
"Anita is considered great, especially for soft serve froyo with unlimited toppings, but Caffe Panna is called more special."
PositiveFrom post: Visiting Nyc For The First Time
"Anita is considered great, especially for soft serve froyo with unlimited toppings, but Caffe Panna is called more special."
PositiveFrom post: Two Days Manhattan
"Anita Gelato is recommended as a dessert spot with many flavors, allowing customers to try them before ordering. Their smallest cup can hold a surprising amount of gelato."
PositiveFrom post: Sorbet Spots
"Anita La Mamma is mentioned as a gelato shop that may offer sorbet, in the context of a search for sorbet-specific places."
PositiveFrom post: Low Food Budget Suggestions
"Anita Gelato in Flatiron was a favorite dessert treat, described as a beautiful shop with ample outdoor seating that generously overstuffs cups, even for small sizes."
Positive