Authentic Italian w/ tableside cacio e pepe & stellar chicken parm. A top-tier choice for date nights or casual dining.
This Italian restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere, making it a great spot for a foodie weekend itinerary or a casual Italian meal. Customers rave about the cacio e pepe prepared tableside in a cheese wheel, as well as highly recommended dishes like chicken parmesan and cheesecake. While there was a past concern regarding health inspections and mice, recent feedback suggests this issue has been resolved and the overall dining experience remains positive.
The Italian cuisine here is highly praised, with the cacio e pepe served in a cheese wheel being a standout dish. Other recommended items include chicken parmesan and cheesecake. There was a past mention of mice, but recent experiences suggest this is no longer a concern.
"The cacio e pepe prepared tableside in a cheese wheel is highly recommended, along with the chicken parmesan and cheesecake."
Customers generally have a very positive experience, praising the delicious food and attentive service. While there was a past concern about mice, it seems to have been addressed and is not a current issue for diners.
Important Note
There was a past concern regarding health inspection notes about mice, though recent feedback suggests this has been resolved. One commenter noted that the cacio e pepe served in a cheese wheel cannot be taken out.
"Recommends Osteria Nonnino as another good Italian option in the West Village."
Positive"This commenter is not a big fan of Cacio e Pepe but highly recommends Osteria Nonnina. They also enjoyed the chicken Parmesan and the cheesecake."
Positive"Osteria Nonnino is recommended for its cacio e pepe, which is served in a cheese wheel."
Positive"Osteria Nonnino in the West Village offers cacio e pepe in a cheese wheel, though it cannot be taken outside."
Positive"Osteria Nonnino is mentioned as having a more relaxed and chill vibe compared to Torrisi."
Neutral"This user broadly advises that one should always be worried when eating out, offering a general cautionary perspective in the context of the discussion about Osteria Nonnino's health inspection."
Negative"Responding to concerns about mice at Osteria Nonnino, this user indicates that mouse sightings are common in New York City restaurants and are not a significant worry as long as food contamination is avoided."
Neutral"This user explains that mice are prevalent in NYC kitchens and suggests that health inspections are often about extracting fines rather than protecting consumers, using examples to illustrate the perceived flaws in the system related to concerns about Osteria Nonnino."
Neutral"The user questions why NYC health inspections are considered a joke, noting that genuine issues like mice are recorded for some restaurants but not all, suggesting that the inspections have some validity concerning places like Osteria Nonnino."
Neutral"This user states that NYC health inspections are unreliable and advises not to worry about them when considering Osteria Nonnino, implying the issues found are not serious concerns."
Neutral"The user recently visited Osteria Nonnino and had a very positive experience, praising the great food and service. They were concerned about past health inspection notes regarding mice but noted the issue seems to have been resolved and asked for reassurance."
Positive"Recommends Osteria Nonnino in Chelsea."
Positive"Recommends Osteria Nonnino among other Italian and American options."
Positive"Commenter recommends Osteria Nonnino as a superior Italian alternative to La Pecora Bianca, noting potential last-minute reservation availability."
Positive
