Authentic NYC pizza with a spicy pepperoni square slice reminiscent of a famous downtown spot. An underrated gem for high-quality, classic slices.
This pizza joint is a must-try for any New Yorker or visitor seeking an authentic slice. With roots tracing back to a former Prince Street Pizza maker, it offers a similar, craveable spicy pepperoni square slice that has fans swearing off other pizzerias. It's considered an underrated gem, delivering solid, high-quality pizza that frequently lands on top ten lists.
The star of the show here is the pizza, particularly the spicy pepperoni square slice, which is frequently compared to and recommended as a high-quality alternative to slices from Prince Street Pizza. While most feedback is positive, one user found the offerings solid but not exceptional.
"The spicy pepperoni square slice is highly recommended, drawing comparisons to Prince Street Pizza. Other praised slices include Pepperoni, Margherita, and Mushroom."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the pizza, with many highlighting the spicy pepperoni square slice as a standout. It's frequently mentioned as an underrated or 'slept on' favorite.
Important Note
One user found the pizza offerings solid but not exceptional.
"The user declared their love for Made in NY pizza after having Pepperoni, Margherita, and Mushroom slices, officially swearing off pizza from their 'motherland' for NY pies."
Positive"This user considers Made in NY Pizza and Bagels a go-to spot, mentioning a recent experience where they received 24 bagels in one bag."
Positive"The user found Made in NY Pizza's offerings to be solid but not exceptional, and speculated if the founder might have previously worked at Prince Street Pizza."
Neutral"Made In Ny Pizza is listed as one of the commenter's top ten most frequented spots in the area."
Positive"Made in New York Pizza is described as 'slept on' (underrated) and is believed to have the same owner as Emily, suggesting high quality."
Positive
