Next.js logo

SAINT STREET CAKES

Updated

Phone: (347) 569-5395

Address: 86 SOUTH PORTLAND AVENUE 11217

TLDR

Whimsical, elevated cakes and standout, gooey salted chocolate chip cookies in a charming Fort Greene bakery. Perfect for daily indulgences and custom celebrations.

Reddit Sentiment for SAINT STREET CAKES(based on 38 Reddit opinions)

92% Positive5% Neutral3% Negative

Tags

american 9bakery 3dessert 2dessert 27cookie 16chocolate chip cookie 10View All

Neighborhoods

Fort Greene

Instagram Posts References

Saint Street Cakes serves a salted chocolate chip cookie that stands out for its generous 'chocolate puddles' and plentiful flaky salt. The cookie is visually appealing and deeply flavorful.

Saint Street Cakes offers unique 'cake martinis' with rotating flavors. An espresso-flavored version was featured, which was met with positive reception.

Featured Articles

Dedicated reviews and comprehensive features focusing directly on this restaurant.

Saint Street Cakes
positive

Willa Moore reviews Saint Street Cakes in Fort Greene, a bakery that makes cake an everyday delight, offering mini cakes, decadent slices, and creative cake martinis. Perfect for any occasion, from birthdays to a simple treat.

Willa Moore • Jul 7, 2025
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

A delightful Fort Greene bakery that elevates cake into an everyday indulgence, offering everything from whimsical mini cakes to creative cake martinis [1]. Known for its moist double chocolate berry slices and gooey, salted chocolate chip cookies, it serves as a top-tier destination for both casual treats and custom cakes [1]. While generally beloved, some visitors find specific items like the lavender lemonade loaf to be a bit too dense or perfumey [1].

Food Overview

The bakery excels in American-style desserts, particularly their moist double chocolate berry cake and highly-rated, gooey salted chocolate chip cookies that feature abundant chocolate and flaky salt [1], [2]. While the cake martinis and gluten-free brownie are also popular highlights [1], some diners have found specific specialty items like the lavender lemonade loaf to be too dense, and others have reported inconsistent textures in their cakes [1], [2].

Highlights / Recommended

"The salted chocolate chip cookie is widely celebrated for its texture and flavor, while the double chocolate berry slice and fun, visually appealing cake martinis are also top recommendations [1], [2]."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • •salted chocolate chip cookie(3)
  • •cake martinis(2)

Customer Sentiment

Patrons are overwhelmingly enthusiastic about the shop's sweet offerings, often citing the cookies and cakes as personal favorites [2]. While the quality is highly regarded, some customers have noted that the cookies can feel small relative to their price point [2].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About SAINT STREET CAKES

This thread features a deep dive into the bakery's chocolate chip cookies, with multiple users praising them as some of the best in the city, though some debate the portion size.
A ranking post that highlights the bakery's double chocolate cake as a top choice among city options.
The community recommends this spot for custom cake orders, noting the high quality despite a higher price point.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Deinfluence Or Influence My Nyc Bakery Wishlist

"Found the cake textures poor and lacking distinct flavor."

Negative
Aug 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: In Honor Of National Chocolate Chip Cookie Day 84

"The commenter highly recommends the salted chocolate chip cookie."

Positive
Aug 4, 2026View Comment →

From post: Tasting And Ranking Of Seven Chocolate Cakes In

"Double chocolate cake is highly recommended."

Positive
Jul 28, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Are Some Bakeriescakes That You Would

"The user describes them as incredibly sweet, stating they hadn't been 'out-sweetened' until visiting."

Positive
Jul 4, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Custom Cake In Nyc Both For Design And

"Saint Street Cakes was mentioned as a place for custom cakes, with a note that it can be expensive."

Positive
Jun 28, 2026View Comment →

More in Fort Greene

See all

More American in NYC

See all