Next.js logo

SUSHI DOKORO MEKUMI

Updated

Phone: (212) 925-1613

Address: 70 CHARLTON ST 10014

TLDR

Exclusive omakase counter featuring Ishikawa seafood & weekly flown-in snow crab. Unexpectedly closed after 6 months.

Reddit Sentiment for SUSHI DOKORO MEKUMI(based on 51 Reddit opinions)

31% Positive37% Neutral29% Negative

Tags

japanese 51american 10ishikawancuisine 6sushi 51seafood 20omakase 14View All

Neighborhoods

SoHo

Featured Articles

Dedicated reviews and comprehensive features focusing directly on this restaurant.

This is Eater’s guide to all the New York City restaurants, bars, and cafes that closed in April 2026.
very negative

Sushidokoro Mekumi, an exclusive eight-seat omakase counter focused on Ishikawa Prefecture seafood, has unexpectedly closed after only six months.

n/a • Date unknown

Details

This exclusive eight-seat omakase counter, known for its focus on Ishikawa Prefecture seafood, has unexpectedly closed its doors after a brief six-month run. Despite offering a unique 18-course tasting menu featuring seasonal fish and rare delicacies like weekly flown-in snow crab, and showcasing specialty sake, the restaurant cited unforeseen circumstances for its closure. It remains uncertain if its associated bar, Maeda, will continue operations.

Food Overview

Specializing in omakase, this Japanese restaurant highlighted seafood from Japan's Ishikawa Prefecture, including snow crab. While dishes like shrimp, Spanish mackerel, and blackthroat nigiri were praised, and a unique white marlin dish stood out, the high price point, particularly an $888 special crab menu, drew significant criticism and was a likely factor in its short lifespan.

Highlights / Recommended

The white marlin rolled in vinegar daikon was highlighted as a standout dish. Other praised items included shrimp, Spanish mackerel, and blackthroat nigiri.

Customer Sentiment

Customer feedback is mixed, with initial positive remarks on unique dishes like the white marlin and friendly service, but growing concern over price increases and the restaurant's ultimate closure.

Most Mentioned Dishes

  • 01
    crab appetizers
    3 mentions
  • 02
    crab menu
    2 mentions
  • 03
    ishikawa crab
    2 mentions

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About SUSHI DOKORO MEKUMI

This post details a positive experience with the omakase meal, highlighting favorite nigiri and a standout white marlin dish. It also notes the price increase and the availability of house-made ginger ale.
This thread discusses the reasons behind the restaurant's closure, including tariffs, sourcing issues, and the exceptionally high price of a special crab menu. It also touches on broader trends in the high-end dining market.
Commenters debate the merits of sourcing Japanese versus local seafood, discussing the costs and logistics involved, and questioning the business model of high-end sushi restaurants in NYC.
This discussion delves into the specifics of the $888 crab menu, with users analyzing its components and debating whether the price was justified by the Ishikawa crab and other additions.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Sushi Mekumi Nyc Is Closing After 7 Months

"The commenter expresses gratitude for the positive reception of their post analyzing the NYC sushi market."

Positive
Apr 12, 2026View Comment →

From post: Sushi Mekumi Nyc Is Closing After 7 Months

"The commenter expresses appreciation for a well-written post discussing the challenges and dynamics of high-end sushi restaurants in NYC."

Positive
Apr 11, 2026View Comment →

From post: Sushi Mekumi Nyc Is Closing After 7 Months

"Another restaurant, Muku, managed to receive a Michelin star shortly after opening around the same time as Sushi Mekumi."

Neutral
Apr 10, 2026View Comment →

From post: Sushi Mekumi Nyc Is Closing After 7 Months

"The high cost of the crab appetizers was due to sourcing from Ishikawa prefecture, which incurred inflated shipping expenses, and these costs were passed on to the consumer."

Neutral
Apr 9, 2026View Comment →

From post: Sushi Mekumi Nyc Is Closing After 7 Months

"The original plan for Sushi Mekumi was to feature Ishikawa crab, renowned from its Japanese counterpart. However, shipping costs for this specific crab to NYC were unexpectedly high, leading to a split menu: a regular $300-400 meal with Hokkaido crab and an $800 highlighting the Ishikawa crab, a setback that likely contributed to its closure."

Neutral
Apr 9, 2026View Comment →

More in SoHo

See all

More Japanese in NYC

See all