Next.js logo

JAX PIZZA JOINT

Updated

Phone: (718) 406-2362

Address: 27-20 JACKSON AVENUE 11101

TLDR

24+ hr proofed dough, epic slice selection, & mind-blowing chicken parm hero. Best pizza in LIC?

Reddit Sentiment for JAX PIZZA JOINT(based on 48 Reddit opinions)

10% Positive13% Neutral77% Negative

Tags

american 3pizza 3View All

Neighborhoods

Long Island City

Instagram Posts References

Jax's Pizza Joint is a new slice shop in Long Island City, founded by the team behind Utopia Bagels, known for their expertise in bread-making. The pizza dough is proofed for over 24 hours, contributing to a superior crust. The restaurant offers a diverse and 'epic' selection of pizza slices, including classic, pepperoni, prosciutto & burrata, and vodka. They also provide various dipping sauces to enhance the pizza experience. Surprisingly, their hero sandwiches are highlighted as being equally impressive, with special mention of the Chicken Parm hero featuring vodka sauce and burrata, which is described as 'mind-blowing'. The establishment positions itself as serving the best pizza in Long Island City.

Details

This Long Island City spot, founded by the team behind Utopia Bagels, offers a unique pizza experience with dough proofed for over 24 hours. They boast an 'epic' selection of slices, from classic to prosciutto & burrata and vodka. Don't miss their 'mind-blowing' Chicken Parm hero, which rivals their highly praised pizza.

Food Overview

The pizza here features dough proofed for over 24 hours, aiming for a superior crust. While some reviews highlight the 'epic' selection of slices like classic, pepperoni, prosciutto & burrata, and vodka, with dipping sauces like hot honey and Calabrian chili also recommended, there's significant criticism. Many commenters found the pizza unappealing, describing it as 'bread and sauce,' 'dry and sad,' or a 'pathetic display.' The Chicken Parm hero with vodka sauce and burrata is frequently mentioned as a standout, even rivaling the pizza.

Highlights / Recommended

"While the pizza receives mixed to negative reviews, the Chicken Parm hero with vodka sauce and burrata is consistently praised as 'mind-blowing' and a must-try."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • red slice(2)

Customer Sentiment

Customers are divided, with some praising the unique dough and creative toppings, while others express strong disappointment with the pizza's appearance and taste, with some even comparing it unfavorably to pita bread.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About JAX PIZZA JOINT

This post features a picture of a pizza slice that garnered significant negative reactions, with many users criticizing its appearance and comparing it to various unappetizing things. Discussions also touch on the price and the definition of a proper tomato pie.
Several commenters expressed strong disappointment, with one calling it 'Against god' and another comparing it to a 'pathetic display.' The preparation and appearance of the pizza were major points of contention.
One user detailed their experience with multiple slices, finding them mediocre and specifically criticizing a slice with seared cheese as 'Pizza the Hutt.' They suggest there are many better pizza options available.
This comment highlights a positive, albeit specific, experience, noting that the red slice has improved with each visit and that the sauce tastes like a slow-cooked pasta sauce. They also mention adding parmesan enhances it.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter suggested that the pictured slice was a marinara slice, which is a classic in some parts of Italy."

Neutral
Apr 9, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"A short, negative reaction of "Awful" was posted."

Negative
Apr 9, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter expressed a feeling of sudden depression after seeing the pizza."

Negative
Apr 9, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter described the sauce as looking terrible and called the pizza slice the worst-looking one they had ever seen."

Negative
Apr 9, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter stated that the entire menu was disappointing."

Negative
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter noted that the pizza had a "hidden face.""

Neutral
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter described the pizza slice as looking like a toy from a toddler's play cooking set."

Negative
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter criticized the business for prioritizing PR and social media over the quality of their product."

Negative
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter inquired if this pizza place is associated with Utopia Bagels."

Neutral
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter expressed a mutual sense of doubt with the pizza slice, as if they were both questioning each other."

Negative
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter, clarifying the price is $3.75, finds the red slice improved with each visit, particularly enjoying the sauce which tastes like a slow-cooked pasta sauce."

Positive
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter questioned the $7 price, stating the actual price is $3.75, and mentioned liking the pizza despite some inconsistency."

Positive
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter likened the pizza slice to something that would summon demons, implying it looked very unappealing."

Negative
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter questioned if the pizza was served cold, noting it looked like it came directly from the display case."

Negative
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter described the pizza as literally "bread and sauce.""

Negative
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter tried the vodka and fig jam slices, finding both disappointing due to imbalanced flavors and a letdown in the dough."

Negative
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter suggested that the first mistake was getting pizza in LIC."

Negative
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter made a pun asking if it was "Rhode Island City?", implying it's not a desirable location for pizza."

Negative
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter stated the pizza looked "dry as hell.""

Negative
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Rosso Pizza From Jax Pizza Joint Lic

"The commenter described the pizza as looking dry and sad, and also questioned the $7 price."

Negative
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

More in Long Island City

See all

More american in NYC

See all