TLDR
Classic, hand-rolled bagels capturing the authentic spirit of the neighborhood's most beloved former staple. Same great taste, new name.
Details
Located in the Upper West Side, this bagel spot is the re-established successor to the neighborhood favorite, Absolute Bagels [1], [2]. Loyalists find the quality to be indistinguishable from the previous iteration, offering that classic Jewish-American experience [4], [5]. Visitors appreciate that the bagels remain consistent with their memories, served fresh and with generous portions of cream cheese [6].
The classic bagels are highly recommended and noted by visitors to be just as enjoyable as they were under previous ownership [4], [6].
Sentiment is generally positive among those who focus on the product quality, with many finding the bagels indistinguishable from the original shop [4], [5], [6]. Some potential customers have expressed initial skepticism regarding online review practices [3].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01bagels2 mentions
Caveats
Some individuals have expressed concern regarding the legitimacy of recent online reviews for the establishment [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About 2788 BAGELS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Some Highlights From Five Days Of Eating In New
"The visitor was happy to find the bagels tasted exactly as they remembered from a previous visit."
PositiveFrom post: Searching For An Uws Manhattan Replacement For
"Acknowledged concerns about review practices but noted the bagels are indistinguishable from the old ownership."
PositiveFrom post: Searching For An Uws Manhattan Replacement For
"Suggested focusing on the actual quality of the bagel rather than reviews, noting they enjoy it as much as the original."
PositiveFrom post: Searching For An Uws Manhattan Replacement For
"Expressed skepticism and reluctance to visit due to suspected fake bot-generated reviews."
NegativeFrom post: Searching For An Uws Manhattan Replacement For
"Clarified that 2788 is the name of the reopened Absolute Bagels."
Neutral