Iconic NY slice joint w/ a must-try upside-down slice. The best, hands down.
This spot is a quintessential New York pizza experience, consistently ranked among the city's best. It's lauded for its classic slices and unique options like the upside-down slice, making it a must-visit for pizza aficionados.
This pizzeria is celebrated for its classic New York-style pizza slices, with many recommending the unique 'upside down slice.' While most feedback is positive, a few users found the pizza to be average or too expensive.
"The 'upside down slice' is frequently recommended, along with the 'Hot Honey slice' and 'Fig & bacon slice'."
Customers overwhelmingly praise this establishment for its exceptional pizza, often citing it as a favorite and a true representation of a New York slice.
Important Note
Some users found the pizza to be somewhat expensive for the quality, and a few mentioned it could be a bit messy.
"NY Pizza Suprema is mentioned as a place Anthony Bourdain loved."
Positive"This user suggests Suprema's burger as an option along the lines of what the original poster is looking for."
Positive"Pizza Suprema is considered a classic slice, with the commenter disliking 'new new york style' places that have too much char."
Neutral"The user recommended NY Pizza Suprema for the best regular slice."
Positive"The post author is organizing a pizza tour across Manhattan and lists NY Pizza Suprema as one of the pizzerias to visit."
Neutral"Pizza Suprema is mentioned as a potential alternative for pizza, alongside Scarr's and Lucia's."
Neutral"This user enthusiastically endorsed NY Pizza Suprema with pizza slice emojis."
Positive"This user confirmed that NY Pizza Suprema is on their list and, despite having good pizza in Scotland, is happy to try a slice of NY style pizza."
Positive"The user plans to try NY Pizza Suprema based on multiple recommendations, noting it's a place they've read about frequently."
Positive"NY Pizza Suprema is highly recommended as an iconic and excellent pizza spot that embodies the spirit of a 'pizzeria'. It's located next to MSG and is considered a good value for NYC."
Positive"NY Pizza Suprema was listed as a recommended pizza spot, part of a sequence of pizza places including Joe's and Cello's/Lucia of Avenue X."
Positive"The original post mentioned NY Pizza Suprema as their favorite pizza place in the city."
Positive"NY Pizza Suprema is recommended as a go-to spot before or after Knicks games."
Positive"The 'Fig & bacon slice' at NY Pizza Suprema is recommended."
Positive"A simple 'Yes' in agreement, likely endorsing NY Pizza Suprema."
Positive"NY Pizza Suprema is a go-to spot, and the 'Upside down slide' pizza is highlighted as excellent."
Positive"After visiting NY Pizza Suprema, the user found the atmosphere nostalgic and the staff friendly, describing the experience as great."
Positive"The 'Hot Honey slice' at NY Pizza Suprema is recommended with a 'fire' emoji."
Positive"NY Pizza Suprema is described as a fantastic, non-fancy, but delicious pizza place located across 8th Avenue from MSG."
Positive
