TLDR
An iconic, long-standing slice shop near MSG known for serving the platonic ideal of a classic NYC pizza. The go-to spot for an authentic, reliable, and nostalgic slice.
Reddit Sentiment for NEW YORK PIZZA SUPREMA(based on 105 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The user visited NY Pizza Suprema, a place they had saved for its vegan options. Despite a line out the door, the service was efficient. They tried the vegan Margherita slice, which cost $7, and found it to be delicious. Although they were hoping for vegan Alfredo or white pizza, they were satisfied with the Margherita. The restaurant has a spacious seating area in the back and the user indicated they would return.
Pizza Suprema, situated near Madison Square Garden, is presented as a long-standing and respected pizza establishment in Midtown. The reviewer samples a regular slice for $4.50, emphasizing its sweet sauce and overall quality. The pizzeria is lauded for being a reliable spot that has consistently delivered great pizza in the area for a considerable time.
Details
A quintessential NYC institution, this pizzeria is beloved for serving classic, reliable slices that frequently earn top marks from locals and visitors alike [1], [25]. Its convenient proximity to Penn Station and Madison Square Garden makes it a go-to for travelers and concert-goers seeking a quick, authentic bite [24], [38]. While the quality is generally hailed as top-tier, some diners occasionally note inconsistencies in freshness or price [17], [56].
Food Overview
Specializing in Italian-American New York-style pizza, the menu offers everything from classic cheese slices to specialty options like the 'Upside Down' slice, 'Hot Honey', and 'Fig & Bacon' [9], [27], [29]. While widely celebrated, some diners suggest asking for slices to be baked longer to achieve a crispier texture [3], [22]. Additionally, the shop provides vegan options, such as a well-regarded vegan Margherita slice [Instagram-2].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended items include the 'Upside Down' slice, the 'Hot Honey' slice, and the 'Fig & Bacon' slice [27], [29]. Vegetarians are encouraged to try the burrata or vegan Margherita slices [21, Instagram-2]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •slice(4)
- •upside down slice(3)
- •hot honey slice(2)
- •fig & bacon slice(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons frequently laud the establishment as an enduring favorite, often praising its consistent quality and friendly atmosphere [28], [47]. Some customers, however, express disappointment regarding perceived price hikes, occasional sogginess, or feelings that the shop has become overrated [14], [17], [56].
Caveats
Some visitors report that the pizzeria can be cash-only when card machines are down [53], [54]. Additionally, some slices may sit out for too long, potentially leading to a 'gummy' or undercooked texture unless requested to be extra crispy [3], [22], [56], [61].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About NEW YORK PIZZA SUPREMA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Are Good Cheap Quick Eats Under 10 Near Penn
"Defends the quality and notes that requesting 'extra crispy' helps."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Good Cheap Quick Eats Under 10 Near Penn
"Critiques the current quality as having declined since the pandemic, feeling it is now tourist-focused and often gummy/doughy."
NegativeFrom post: What Are Good Cheap Quick Eats Under 10 Near Penn
"Positive review of the pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendation For Fried Eggplant Pizza Pie In
"The commenter agrees that this is a great choice for pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendation For Fried Eggplant Pizza Pie In
"The commenter recommends this spot as a high-quality pizza option."
Positive