Iconic NYC slice joint; consistently ranked among the city's best pizzas. A true taste of old-school NYC.
This classic NYC pizzeria has been a go-to for locals and visitors alike, often cited as a top contender for the best slice in the city. It's praised for its consistent quality, friendly service, and a nostalgic atmosphere that harks back to the golden age of New York pizza. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or settling in for a meal, this spot offers a genuine taste of authentic New York pizza.
This establishment is renowned for its classic New York-style pizza slices, with many customers highlighting the "upside down slice" and "regular cheese slice" as must-tries. The pizza is often described as having a perfect balance of sauce and cheese, with some noting a slightly sweet sauce. While overwhelmingly positive, a few opinions suggest it can be a bit pricey for a slice and some may find it overrated.
"The 'upside down slice' is frequently recommended, with some also suggesting the 'regular NY slice' and 'hot honey slice' as standout options."
Customers overwhelmingly praise this pizzeria for its consistently excellent pizza, often calling it the best in the city. It's a beloved spot that lives up to its hype, offering a classic New York pizza experience.
Important Note
Some users have noted that the pizzeria may be cash-only at times, and a few reviews suggest that slices might be reheated or that the price is high for a single slice.
"NY Pizza Suprema is recommended for its great slices and is noted as being vegetarian and vegan-friendly, with a mention of a past endorsement by Bourdain."
Positive"This user mentioned Suprema, stating that they offer a pizza slice with a "Veggie Medley" topping combination, though it does not include mini mozzarella balls."
Positive"This user recommended Pizzeria Supreme for pizza."
Positive"This user simply stated 'Pizza Suprema' in response to the OP's request for recommendations."
Neutral"This commenter linked to the website of Pizza Suprema, suggesting it as a relevant option based on its name."
Neutral"The commenter states that NY Pizza Suprema is a non-negotiable stop whenever they travel through Penn Station."
Positive"Every time the commenter visits NYC via Amtrak, they go directly to NY Pizza Suprema."
Positive"The commenter recalls NY Pizza Suprema as their first exposure to NYC pizza during college, being located near their dorms, and was initially disappointed with other pizzerias as they expected them to be as good."
Positive"The commenter recalls NY Pizza Suprema as their first exposure to NYC pizza during college, being located near their dorms, and was initially disappointed with other pizzerias as they expected them to be as good."
Positive"When going to MSG, this commenter always chooses NY Pizza Suprema."
Positive"This commenter visits NY Pizza Suprema or Best Bagel and Coffee when they have about 30 minutes to kill near Penn Station."
Positive"This commenter visits NY Pizza Suprema or Best Bagel and Coffee when they have about 30 minutes to kill near Penn Station."
Positive"The user mentions NY Pizza Suprema as a go-to spot for a quick bite when returning from Penn/MSG."
Positive"Pizza Suprema on 8th and 30th is recommended and is located near Penn Station."
Negative"NY Pizza Suprema is the go-to recommendation for pizza."
Negative"Pizza Suprema is mentioned as a good neighborhood spot for basic pizza."
Negative"This user defended Pizza Suprema, suggesting that plain and pepperoni slices are usually fresh and that it's one of the best options in Midtown Manhattan."
Positive"This commenter stated that the traditional Neapolitan round pie at Pizza Suprema is good, though specialty slices might sit out. They also recommended Pops on 57th."
Positive"This commenter stated they hadn't been to Pizza Suprema in months and planned to check if the quality had declined, calling it an NYC institution."
Neutral"The original commenter reiterated their point about not getting fresh pies if they have to be put back in the oven."
Negative
