TLDR
An iconic, long-standing destination for classic NY-style pizza. Beloved for its heritage and convenient location near Penn Station.
Reddit Sentiment for NEW YORK PIZZA SUPREMA(based on 103 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The user visited NY Pizza Suprema, a place they had saved for its vegan options. Despite a line out the door, the service was efficient. They tried the vegan Margherita slice, which cost $7, and found it to be delicious. Although they were hoping for vegan Alfredo or white pizza, they were satisfied with the Margherita. The restaurant has a spacious seating area in the back and the user indicated they would return.
Pizza Suprema, situated near Madison Square Garden, is presented as a long-standing and respected pizza establishment in Midtown. The reviewer samples a regular slice for $4.50, emphasizing its sweet sauce and overall quality. The pizzeria is lauded for being a reliable spot that has consistently delivered great pizza in the area for a considerable time.
Details
Renowned for its classic New York-style slices, this long-standing pizzeria near Madison Square Garden is often cited as a city institution and a favorite for travelers and locals alike [1]. While many patrons laud it as a top-tier slice shop and an Anthony Bourdain-endorsed staple [2], [3], others express mixed feelings, pointing to concerns over consistency, pricing, or the texture of the crust [4], [5]. Despite occasional debates regarding its current standing, it remains a go-to for those seeking an authentic and convenient pie near Penn Station [6], [7].
Food Overview
The restaurant specializes in classic New York-style pizza, offering a variety of pies ranging from traditional round cheese to unique specialty options. While many praise the flavor and quality of the slices [1], [5], others have reported issues such as oiliness or a 'gummy' dough texture if the pizza isn't baked to order [2], [3], [4].
Highly recommended favorites include the Hot Honey slice, the Fig & bacon slice, and the 'Upside down' pizza [1], [2]. Vegetarians also frequently point to the vegan Margherita slice as a delicious, standout option [3].
Customer sentiment is largely positive, with many diners considering the shop a must-visit institution for a classic slice [1], [2]. However, some recent visitors feel the experience has become inconsistent or tourist-focused, leading to occasional critiques regarding value and quality [3], [4].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01slice4 mentions
- 02upside down slice3 mentions
- 03hot honey slice2 mentions
- 04fig & bacon slice2 mentions
- 05pizza2 mentions
Caveats
Some visitors report that the shop can be occasionally cash-only if the card machine is experiencing technical issues [1]. Additionally, diners have noted that requesting a slice to be 'extra crispy' or baked longer can help avoid a soggy or undercooked crust [2], [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About NEW YORK PIZZA SUPREMA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Im From La Visiting Nyc For The First Time And
"Recommended for good pizza by the slice in Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: Plan My Once In A Lifetime Nyc Pizza Crawl Doctor
"A recommended pizza spot in Midtown Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: Plan My Once In A Lifetime Nyc Pizza Crawl Doctor
"Ranked as the number one spot in a five-borough crawl due to having the best sauce."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Good Cheap Quick Eats Under 10 Near Penn
"Defends the quality and notes that requesting 'extra crispy' helps."
Positive