Best bagels in NYC, with amazing schmear options. Expect deliciousness, but some mixed reviews on the bagels themselves.
This bagel shop is a true standout, consistently earning rave reviews for serving some of the best bagels in the city. Customers particularly praise the unique and generous cream cheese selections, with the wasabi and sundried tomato varieties being frequently mentioned as must-tries. While most patrons are delighted, a few have noted mixed experiences with the bagels themselves or other offerings like lox.
This restaurant is celebrated for its high-quality bagels, with many customers considering them the best in the city. The cream cheese selection is also a major draw, with specific mentions of wasabi and sundried tomato flavors being particularly popular. While the bagels themselves receive widespread acclaim, one user found them unremarkable, and another expressed uncertainty about the quality of the lox.
"The wasabi cream cheese and sundried tomato cream cheese on a jalapeno cheddar bagel are highly recommended. Some customers also praise the lox."
Customers overwhelmingly praise this establishment for its exceptional bagels, with many declaring them the best they've ever had. The variety and quality of cream cheese, particularly the wasabi and sundried tomato options, are frequently highlighted as outstanding.
Important Note
One user found the bagels themselves to be unremarkable, and another expressed uncertainty about the quality of the lox.
"Best Bagels is recommended as a better option for bagels compared to Utopia Bagels, praised for its chew and taste. It is also noted to be close to Hudson Yards."
Positive"This commenter became addicted to the bagels at Best Bagel & Coffee, returning multiple times after an initial visit for work."
Positive"This user recommends Best Bagels & coffee as a good bagel option near Penn Station, noting that it won't have massive lines."
Positive"Best Bagel in Chelsea is highly recommended with a 10/10 rating."
Positive"The commenter recommends Best Bagel as a good option."
Positive"The commenter lists Best Bagel & Coffee as one of their regular bagel go-tos."
Positive"A user expresses willingness to take the 1 train down to 35th St for bagels from Best, indicating they are worth the trip."
Positive"According to the commenter, Best Bagel and Coffee Co in Midtown previously offered the most generous lox portions they had seen, at least half an inch thick. They did note, however, that it had been over a year since their last visit, so things might have changed."
Positive"In a discussion about convenient food options near Times Square, the author recommended Best Bagel on 35th Street (between 7th and 8th Ave) as their pick."
Positive"Author briefly recommended 'Beat bagel' (presumed to be Best Bagel & Coffee) in response to a request for bagels."
Positive"Replying to a positive comment about 'best bagel', this user strongly disagreed, stating it provided one of the worst bagels they've ever had."
Negative"Author mentioned Best Bagel on 35th St as a source for very good bagels, though noting it can be pricy and touristy. They were uncertain about the quality of the lox."
Neutral"The user simply names 'Best bagel' (presumably Best Bagel & Coffee) as living up to its hype."
Positive"Best Bagel in Midtown is highly recommended; check Google for pictures."
Positive"The user expresses excitement about visiting Best Bagel, which is on their list."
Positive"The commenter praises Best Bagel's bagels and sandwiches, noting they wrap them well for takeaway unlike some other popular spots."
Positive"The commenter strongly advocates for Best Bagel, mentioning their amazing bagels, insane schmear selection, and fast-moving line despite crowds. They suggest enjoying the bagels nearby at the Highline or Moynihan Hall."
Positive"The commenter included Best Bagel & Coffee on a suggested Northbound itinerary, noting its location on 35th street."
Neutral"The user included Best Bagel and Coffee on their planned itinerary for a day trip to NYC."
Positive"SkyeFarg0 provided an update that Best Bagel, a potential option for the original poster, closes at 4 PM."
Neutral
