NYC's top-tier bagel spot w/ insane schmear selection & fast lines. Worth the trip for amazing bagels & BECs.
This establishment lives up to its name, offering a highly regarded bagel experience in Manhattan. Reviewers consistently praise their bagels, often calling them among the best in the city. Popular choices include classic combinations with various cream cheese flavors, and the Bacon, Egg, and Cheese sandwich is also a standout.
The bagels here are the star, consistently receiving high marks for texture and taste. Customers rave about the 'insane' variety of cream cheese (schmear) options, with specific mentions of wasabi and sundried tomato flavors. The Bacon, Egg, and Cheese sandwich is also a popular and recommended item. While most feedback is positive, one user found the lox portion to be excessive on a bagel with lox, though still acknowledged the bagel's quality.
"The bagels themselves are universally praised, with a particular shout-out to the wide and creative selection of cream cheese (schmear) options. The Bacon, Egg, and Cheese (BEC) sandwich is also highly recommended."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the quality of the bagels, with many considering them the best they've had. The extensive cream cheese options and the BEC sandwich are also frequently highlighted as excellent.
Important Note
One user found the lox portion on a bagel to be excessive and compared the lox quality unfavorably to a more specialized establishment. Another user had a strongly negative experience with the bagel itself, deeming it one of the worst they've had, contrasting with the overwhelmingly positive feedback.
"The original poster found the lox bagel from Best Bagel and Coffee to be solid, with generous fillings and no lines."
Positive"The user responded to a comment about the generous portion of lox, confirming it was indeed very generous."
Neutral"The user responded to a question about Barney Greengrass, indicating they had not tried it but were interested in the commenter's thoughts."
Neutral"This user recommended Best Bagels, also noting that they offer a great BEC (Bacon, Egg, and Cheese) sandwich."
Positive"This user expressed that Best Bagels is their favorite in NYC, a preference they have held for 13 years."
Positive"In defense of their post, the user stated they were sharing a bagel they ate and not asking for recommendations, pushing back against a critical comment."
Neutral"In response to a query about price, the user stated the bagel with extra scallion cream cheese cost $15, which was considered a good deal."
Positive"The user clarified that they felt there was too much filling relative to the bagel, which is why they removed some of the lox."
Neutral"This user agreed with the original poster's sentiment that there was too much filling in the bagel sandwich, suggesting a reduction in the filling would make it ideal."
Positive"This user mentioned that Best Bagels are their favorite after a local place in Astoria, indicating a high regard for the establishment."
Positive"The user confirms that Jezebel's was the restaurant they were trying to remember for their 25th birthday celebration. They recall it being a nice, dimly lit, and inviting soul food spot."
Positive"This user confirmed the location of the highly-rated bagel place, stating it is on 35th street."
Positive"The user found the bagel itself to be great, with a crispy exterior and chewy interior. However, they felt the ratio of bagel to filling was off and removed some of the lox to compensate. They also compared the quality of the fish unfavorably to Russ & Daughters."
Negative"Best Bagels is recommended as a better option for bagels compared to Utopia Bagels, praised for its chew and taste. It is also noted to be close to Hudson Yards."
Positive"This commenter became addicted to the bagels at Best Bagel & Coffee, returning multiple times after an initial visit for work."
Positive"This user recommends Best Bagels & coffee as a good bagel option near Penn Station, noting that it won't have massive lines."
Positive"Best Bagel in Chelsea is highly recommended with a 10/10 rating."
Positive"The commenter recommends Best Bagel as a good option."
Positive"The commenter lists Best Bagel & Coffee as one of their regular bagel go-tos."
Positive"A user expresses willingness to take the 1 train down to 35th St for bagels from Best, indicating they are worth the trip."
Positive
