Next.js logo

SAL & CARMINE PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (212) 663-7651

Address: 2671 BROADWAY 10025

View on Google Maps

TLDR

A quintessential, no-frills destination for authentic NY-style slices that hit the spot with pure, old-school nostalgia.

Reddit Sentiment for SAL & CARMINE PIZZA(based on 7 Reddit opinions)

86% Positive14% Neutral

Tags

italian 7pizza 7View All

Neighborhoods

Upper West Side

Details

Located on Broadway, this spot is widely celebrated as a premier destination for classic New York-style pizza [1]. Visitors often highlight the restaurant for providing a nostalgic experience that captures the essence of a traditional slice shop [1]. It is also highly regarded as a convenient, no-frills neighborhood staple for locals and visitors alike [2].

Food Overview

The menu focuses on authentic New York-style pizza, which is consistently hailed as a perfect example of a classic slice [1][2].

Highlights / Recommended

The classic pizza is highly recommended for those seeking an authentic NYC slice experience [2].

Customer Sentiment

Feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with the community consistently praising the shop as a local favorite for a classic slice [1].

Most Mentioned Dishes

  • 01
    sauce
    2 mentions

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About SAL & CARMINE PIZZA

https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1w5h7ri/two_brazilians_eating_their_way_through_nyc_part_1/
This post highlights the restaurant as a go-to for a no-frills, traditional NYC pizza experience.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1szm48m/best_bagel_or_slice_near_saint_john_the_divine/
A thread where multiple users confirm the spot as a local favorite for a classic slice and a touch of nostalgia.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1vu6h67/96th_and_broadway_to_columbus_circle_a_walk_with/
The shop is suggested as a prime starting point for a walking tour through the neighborhood.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Two Brazilians Eating Their Way Through Nyc Part 1

"Recommended as a 'no-frills' traditional NYC pizza experience."

Positive
Sep 3, 2026View Comment →

From post: 96th And Broadway To Columbus Circle A Walk With

"Suggested as a starting point for the walk to expand the tour route."

Positive
Aug 21, 2026View Comment →

From post: Looking For Pizza Recs For Queens Brooklyn And

"Mentioned as a spot to visit after Joe's."

Positive
Aug 5, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Bagel Or Slice Near Saint John The Divine

"Sal and Carmines is confirmed as a vote for a classic NYC slice."

Positive
Apr 30, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Bagel Or Slice Near Saint John The Divine

"Sal and Carmine's is mentioned as a favorite for pizza, offering a real nostalgia play."

Positive
Apr 30, 2026View Comment →

More in Upper West Side

See all

More Italian in NYC

See all