TLDR
Iconic, hand-crafted pies and decadent old-fashioned cakes that have defined NYC holiday traditions for decades.
Details
A legendary Hell's Kitchen institution, this bakery is celebrated for its extraordinary variety of homemade-style desserts [1], [2]. Customers frequently praise their exceptional pies, which are often cited as among the best in the world, alongside an old-fashioned chocolate cake that many consider a local favorite [3], [4]. These high-quality treats have become a beloved fixture for holiday gatherings, birthday celebrations, and even as a popular alternative to traditional wedding cakes [3].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American-style bakery classics, with the sour cream apple walnut pie frequently lauded as an extraordinary, must-try staple [1], [2]. Customers also hold the Key Lime pie, Georgia peach pie, and old-fashioned chocolate cake in high regard [3]. While the shop is primarily recognized for its extensive pie selection, the personal-sized chocolate cakes are also highly recommended by patrons as a delicious, individual treat [4].
Highlights / Recommended
Mentioned Dishes:
- •old fashioned chocolate cake(4)
- •sour cream apple walnut pie(4)
- •walnut sour cream apple pie(3)
- •key lime pie(3)
- •mississippi mud pie(2)
- •pecan pie(2)
Customer Sentiment
Customer feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with patrons consistently describing the bakery as a premier destination for high-quality desserts that evoke a sense of nostalgia and artisanal care [1], [3]. Visitors often remark on the consistently pleasant aroma and the shop's status as a reliable, institution-level staple for celebrations [3].
Caveats
Some customers note that while the shop is famous for its pies, it is equally worth visiting for its cakes, which might be overlooked by those solely focused on the pie menu [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About LITTLE PIE COMPANY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Lemon Bars In The Citythe Tangier The Better
"The user notes that the key lime pie at Little Pie Company is fabulous, even though it is not a lemon bar."
PositiveFrom post: On The Hunt For Warm And Gooey Desserts With Ice
"The Mississippi mud pie can be served warm with ice cream for an extra cost."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Sour Cream Fudge Chocolate Cake Since
"The user suggests trying the old fashioned chocolate cake as a potential match for the requested style."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"A user from Georgia gives high praise, stating the peach pie is authentic."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"Recommends getting the Georgia Peach Pie while it is in season."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"Located in Hell's Kitchen, the commenter praises their cheddar crust apple pie."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"Mentions the shop as a recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Peach Pie By The Slice Restaurant Bakery Or Whole
"The user recommends this shop."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Buy Some Bussin Pastries Near
"A suggested spot for pies."
PositiveFrom post: Hey Need Dessert Reccos For Celebration On Door
"This establishment is recommended for its pies."
PositiveFrom post: Black Actor And Entrepreneur Arnold Wilkerson
"The commenter states that the pies from Little Pie Company are some of the best bakery-made pies they have ever had, even considering they usually bake their own pies at home."
PositiveFrom post: Black Actor And Entrepreneur Arnold Wilkerson
"Replying to a comment about pie, this user states that the sour cream apple walnut pie from Little Pie Company is the best apple pie they have ever had."
PositiveFrom post: Black Actor And Entrepreneur Arnold Wilkerson
"This user agrees about the chocolate cake, specifically mentioning that the personal-sized chocolate cakes are delicious and a treat they indulge in occasionally."
PositiveFrom post: Black Actor And Entrepreneur Arnold Wilkerson
"A brief comment labeling Little Pie Company as a New York 'Thanksgiving' institution."
PositiveFrom post: Black Actor And Entrepreneur Arnold Wilkerson
"The commenter shares that they broke tradition to have the pecan pie from Little Pie Company for Thanksgiving, declaring it extremely good and extending that praise to all their pies."
PositiveFrom post: Black Actor And Entrepreneur Arnold Wilkerson
"The commenter enjoys walking past Little Pie Company because of the consistently pleasant aroma emanating from the establishment."
PositiveFrom post: Black Actor And Entrepreneur Arnold Wilkerson
"Echoing other positive sentiments, this user loves Little Pie Company and specifically reiterates the strong recommendation for the sour cream and walnut apple pie."
PositiveFrom post: Black Actor And Entrepreneur Arnold Wilkerson
"This commenter shares a detailed personal history with Little Pie Company, particularly praising the sour cream apple walnut pie. They recount how they discovered the pie before the shop even existed, its ability to impress even pie-skeptics, and a humorous anecdote involving the pie and New York Magazine."
PositiveFrom post: Black Actor And Entrepreneur Arnold Wilkerson
"This commenter chose Little Pie Company for dessert catering at their wedding, finding it a refreshing and popular alternative to traditional wedding cake."
PositiveFrom post: Black Actor And Entrepreneur Arnold Wilkerson
"The commenter expresses gratitude for the post introducing them to Little Pie Company and states their intention to visit soon."
Positive