Hell's Kitchen gem w/ incredible scones & authentic sourdough. Don't miss their massive cakes!
A beloved bakery nestled in Hell's Kitchen, this establishment has been serving up delicious baked goods for years. They are particularly known for their exceptional scones, with many customers raving about the oat scone and the cherry cream scone. Beyond scones, their cakes, including a moist and delicious old-fashioned yellow cake with pink frosting and a massive chocolate cake, are highly recommended. For bread lovers, their authentic sourdough is a must-try, often compared to San Francisco's best.
This bakery is celebrated for its exceptional baked goods, with a particular emphasis on its highly recommended scones, such as the oat scone and cherry cream scone. Customers also rave about their cakes, including an old-fashioned yellow cake with pink frosting and a large chocolate cake. The authentic sourdough bread is frequently mentioned as a standout item, drawing comparisons to San Francisco's renowned sourdough. While most feedback is positive, one commenter found a 'smothered' dish to be just 'fine.'
"Highly recommended are the scones (especially oat and cherry cream), an old-fashioned yellow cake with pink frosting, and authentic sourdough bread. The chocolate cake is also noted for its size and quality."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the baked goods, highlighting the exceptional quality and taste of their scones, cakes, and sourdough bread. There are no significant negative sentiments noted.
Important Note
Seating may be limited, but outdoor seating might be available nearby.
"This commenter frequently visits Amy's and praises their chocolate cake slice, noting it's very large."
Positive"This comment confirms Amy's has a few tables and specifically recommends their scones, even for those who don't typically like scones. They also mention their chocolate cake."
Positive"Amy's is recommended as a dessert spot, with a note about limited seating but potential outdoor seating nearby. They also mention their scones."
Positive"Amy's Bread is recommended for breakfast and tea."
Positive"This commenter strongly recommends Amy's, suggesting to try an oat scone even if one typically dislikes scones, stating everything they make is amazing."
Positive"Amy’s Bread is recommended as a place to buy fresh, delicious, authentic sourdough bread in Manhattan or Brooklyn."
Positive"Amy's on Chelsea Marketplace is noted for having a flavor profile closest to San Francisco style sourdough."
Positive"The original poster noted that there is an Amy's Bread location near their work and plans to visit it."
Neutral"Amy's Bread is suggested as a good bakery."
Positive"This user had a delicious slice of Amy's Bread banana cake from the Stavros Niarchos Foundation Library cafe and enjoyed it on the balcony."
Positive"This user recommended Amy's Bread in Midtown."
Positive"The user noted that Amy's Bread has moist cake and delicious sponge, though the frosting can be sweet."
Neutral"The user mentioned Amy's Bakery as one of the coffee places located inside Chelsea Market."
Neutral"The commenter mentions Amy's as similar to Charles Pan Fried Chicken, noting that their smothered dish was "fine" despite the commenter being a self-proclaimed "hard grader" for Southern food."
Neutral"The user recommends Amy's Bread for brownies."
Neutral"Amy's Bread on 9th Ave is recommended, especially the black and white layer cake and cherry cream scone."
Positive"Recommends Amy's Bread's coconut cake, noting they're located in Hell's Kitchen."
Positive"Suggested Amy's Bread cookbook."
Positive"Lists Amy's Bread among other bakeries in the city."
Neutral"The original poster listed Amy's Bread as a place to potentially get birthday carrot cake and cheesecake."
Neutral
